Neutral Milk Hotel
In the Aeroplane Over the Sea


4.5
superb

Review

by USER (6 Reviews)
January 14th, 2005 | 29 replies | 8,428 views


Release Date: 1998 | Tracklist


1 of 1 thought this review was well written

Neutral Milk Hotel-In the Aeroplane Over the Sea

So, this album is something different from what I usualy find myself listening to. Built on an acoustic folk foundation, but adding other instruments such as horns, organs, accordions, banjo and zanziphones, gives this band something different, sometimes they seem like a marching band. The vocals also seem emotional (although a lot of the time I don't know what's being sung), but never go that step further and become whiney. For me, the vocals are one of the best points about this album, complementing the acoustic guitar work perfectly. The production isn't the best standard, but this adds effect to the songs, and adds to the honesty of the music.

Although at first listen, many of these tracks may seem similar, there is actually quite a range of tracks, from Holland, 1945, probably the most catchy song on here, to The Fool, showing of Neutral Milk Hotel's...err..marching band qualities. The singer, Jeff Magnum, proclaims his love for Christ on the song King of Carrot Flowers, Parts 2&3, while demonstrating his subtlety on Communist Daughter, which has a great use of horns (or whatever that instrument is, the scope of instruments used on this album is quite large), which add to the song, and add Neutral Milk Hotel's own stamp on the acoustic ballad. A special mention must also be given to [Untitled] , which uses electronic instruments, alongside the acoustic ones to produce something very interesting indeed.

Put simply, this is an extremely good album. Even though the lyrics may seem like nonsense, the way they are sung, you can't help but feel some kind of emotion. I don't know, maybe that was the idea in the first place. Even without looking at the lyrics, you can still somehow understand the emotion he is trying to convey. The songs flow into each other naturally, yet the album never seems like one song, such is the variety of the album. Although I don't know how well this album did upon its release, I am certain this should be remembered as one of the great albums of the nineties. But, then again, I doubt Jeff Magnum cares about sales of the album, and upon listening to this album, I think that maybe the band made this album made this record for themselves, rather than for anyone else.

However, to some, this album may be too different to what they listen to usualy for them to enjoy it. But, if you open your mind and take a listen, I'm sure that a lot of you would enjoy this album. It is calming yet never boring, energetic yet never out of control.

4.5/5



Recent reviews by this author
OutKast Speakerboxxx/The Love BelowFrom Autumn To Ashes The Fiction We Live
Red Hot Chili Peppers One Hot MinuteTaking Back Sunday Tell All Your Friends
Million Dead A Song to Ruin
user ratings (3374)
Chart.
4.5
superb
other reviews of this album
1 of
trending alt & indie albums

El Pintor

AM

To Be Kind

Lowborn

Comments:Add a Comment 
Scott Herren
April 2nd 2004



192 Comments


Here is a reply. Nice album, one of my favorites. Pretty good review, although you didn't mention the title song which is my favorite.

moderaterock222
April 2nd 2004



121 Comments


Could have been more in depth in the review, like a song by song..
Its a good album too, one ive discovered from this forum

Kaden
May 9th 2004



222 Comments


Sounds interesting, if Indiana didn't suck so much I'd probably buy it, but I doubt if anyone has it here.

So I'll get it off the internet!

Dimes Make Dollars
May 9th 2004



241 Comments


"King of Carrot Flowers" (I forgot which part it is; it's the short acoustic one) is a great song, but it's all I've heard. I'll check this out, good review.

Well_Respected_Man
September 10th 2004



75 Comments


This is a great album that's just recently grown on me. Part two of King of Carrot Flowers always cracks me up "I love youuuuuuuuu Jesuuuuuuuuus chriissssssssst" and then of course the fuzz jam at the end is classic. It's really a worthwhile listen.

I would probbaly give it a 4/5 right now

KazooVirtuoso
September 10th 2004



30 Comments


[QUOTE=moderaterock222]Could have been more in depth in the review, like a song by song..[/QUOTE]

Bah. I find song-by-song reviews to not be very helpful, unless the band does songs with very different styles. An overall description of the album's style along with mentions of the better songs works a lot better for me.

But anyway... Great album, probably my favorite from the whole Elephant 6 thing. I need to check out their other albums, this is still the only one I've heard...

Zappa
September 10th 2004



355 Comments


I hate this album.

Badmoon
September 11th 2004



384 Comments


I was going to buy this album today, but I passed and bought Live from Mars. I may pick it up tommorow though

Great review :thumb:

Kaden
October 9th 2004



222 Comments


I'd probably give it a 4/5. On another note: am I the only one who loves his lyrics?

el doctor
October 9th 2004



83 Comments


[QUOTE=Kaden]I'd probably give it a 4/5. On another note: am I the only one who loves his lyrics?[/QUOTE]
I'd hope not. In my opinion, the lyrics are the strong part of the music. I love a song like olland 1945 where somehow the song can be incredibly upbeat and catchy, but the lyrics are rather depressing.

cbmartinez
October 9th 2004



2525 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I heard these guys for the first time a couple weeks ago and I was really impressed. Excellent review.

shift_REALITY
October 9th 2004



4 Comments


I love this CD, originally heard it a few months ago while in spain and couldn't get enough of it. Oh Comely has possibly the greatest lyrics to any song I've ever heard. This band doesn't go over too well with people who don't listen to alot of wierd music, especially Holland, 1945.

There's some debate about whether or not this CD is actually about Anne Frank. It's easy to argue both for and against it.

ultraspamboy
April 13th 2005



1 Comments


the lyrics actually do have a meaning, it's just really hard to access. Try songmeanings.net.


BlackDeathMetalJazz or really ANYTHING else please-
April 14th 2005



200 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I think the lyrics are psychedelic in a way kind of Syd Barrettish you know?

Love this album...Great reveiiw.

Med57
Moderator
April 14th 2005



1001 Comments


I absolutely love this album. I would think of something else to say, but it's simply brilliant.

woofwoofwoof
May 6th 2005



156 Comments


if you like these guys, which you should, then try the decemberists. i'm having trouble deciding who's better.

Iai
Emeritus
June 25th 2005



3553 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I used to have this and.....I don't know. Just didn't really grab me. I listened to it twice and was left with no opinion on it whatsoever.

masada
August 18th 2005



2733 Comments


So, I finally have the whole album.

If Jesus made an album, this would be it.

Zappa
August 18th 2005



355 Comments


I hate this.

Zappa
August 18th 2005



355 Comments


Haha, I didn't realize I'd already replied. Sorry about that.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy