Matt Elliott The Broken Man

  full reviewuser ratings (9) 
Tracklist:
1. Oh How We Fell
2. Please, Please, Please
3. Dust, Flesh and Bones
4. How to Kill a Rose
5. If Anyone Tells Me "It's Better to Have
Loved and Lost Than to Never Have Loved at All"
I Will Stab Them in the Face
6. This Is For
7. The Pain That's Yet to Come


Release Date: 01/16/2012

user rating
3.5
great
Chart.

recommended by reviewer
Nick Drake Pink Moon
Mark Lanegan Whiskey For The Holy Ghost
Elliott Smith Either/Or
First Aid Kit The Lion's Roar


  On 5 Lists

4.0
excellent
Ali USER (96 Reviews)

January 27th, 2012 | 12 replies | 1,252 views

Summary: A splendid journey into the self-explanatory rhelmes of "dark folk."

2 of 2 thought this review was well written

2012 has, by this writer's estimation at least, been a bit slow out of the blocks, but one thing that can't be argued with is that folk music has gotten off to a flyer. This week has seen the release of Swedish sisters First Aid Kit's stunning sophomore The Lion's Roar to virtually universal acclaim, and although it's passed somewhat under-the-radar by comparison, the same could be said of the new album from Bristol singer-songwriter Matt Elliott. I'll be honest, I don't profess to have much (if any) in depth knowledge regarding Elliott's expansive discography, nor that of The Third Eye Foundation, the electronic project that he was formerly involved in. I could fake omniscience, but I'd be made to look like a fool by someone who actually does know their stuff, so this review is very much from an outsider's point of view. What I can make clear, however, is that on The Broken Man his brand of "dark folk" works a treat, and makes for a record that's constantly rewarding and occasionally spellbinding.

There's not really any point in discussing the ins and outs of Elliott's sound, because at the end of the day that dubious genre - "dark folk" paints a clearer picture than any overly elaborate explanation. In simple terms, it's how you'd imagine Pink Moon-era Nick Drake would sound, had be possessed a baritone and incorporated some of the psychedelic wanderings and Gothic overtones of Mark Lanegan. Sparse and cold, yet deep and beautiful, it's a record which revolves overwhelmingly around the singer's voice, and despite it's initial blankness there are moments when it can prove utterly spine-tingling. Nine-minute highlight 'Dust Flesh And Bone, for instance, carries with it a real sense of sorrow, with Elliott's wistful mourns of "this is how it feels to be alone" providing a staggering emotional punch that's genuinely unsettling. Such an extended run-time may seem a little much, but it's never less than captivating, and even so is far from being the most sprawling track here. 'If Anyone Tells Me' clocks in at thirteen minutes, with opener 'Oh How We Feel' not far behind at twelve, and it comes as no surprise that these cuts stand as the record's unmistakable centerpieces, with most of the other tracks seemingly concieved to fit around them.

This gives rise to a seamless sense of cohesion throughout - an improbable feat given that many of these songs seem to lack a recognisable structure. Indeed this complaint could be viewed as The Broken Man's primary weakness, but truthfully it pales into insignificance when moulded the record's perennial intensity and unlikely flow, two features which reign supreme from the off. How does it compare to the rest of Elliott's works? I obviously couldn't tell you, but if nothing else it's convinced me to delve into his back catalogue in search of further delights. For now, though, this thoroughly excellent record is more than enough to get by with, and although it's one that requires a certain frame of mind to enjoy it'll no doubt find itself on my playlist for the rest of 2012, and potentially beyond.

Share: Facebook Stumble Digg!Digg Twitter Del.icio.us


Recent reviews by this author
The Walkmen Heaven
Admiral Fallow Tree Bursts In Snow
The Tower And The Fool How Long
The Cribs In the Belly of the Brazen Bull
Holy Esque Holy Esque
Spiritualized Sweet Heart Sweet Light

Comments:Add a Comment 
AliW1993
January 26th 2012



5773 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Also posted at http://www.muzikdizcovery.com/

This is borderline 3.5/4 for me, but I think that this deserves the benefit of the doubt.

Digging: The Walkmen - Heaven

Digging: The Walkmen - Heaven

Lucidity
January 26th 2012



6000 Comments


It's all about Drinking Songs. If you want to check this guy out start there.

Digging: Animal Collective - Honeycomb/Gotham

Digging: Animal Collective - Honeycomb/Gotham

MisterTornado
January 26th 2012



1114 Comments

Album Rating: 3

If Anyone Tells Me is so good, need to revisit this.

Digging: Laurel Halo - Quarantine

Digging: Laurel Halo - Quarantine

wonarabbit
January 26th 2012



4341 Comments


nice, drinking songs is a fucking great album.

SowingSeason
Staff Reviewer
January 26th 2012



11574 Comments


how are you not a contrib yet, jeez



Digging: mewithoutYou - Ten Stories

CaptainDooRight
January 26th 2012



4957 Comments


Good review, will check

Digging: Wintersun - Time

RiffOClock
January 27th 2012



8087 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

best 2012 so far

Digging: Florence & The Machine - Split

Digging: Florence & The Machine - Split

Lucidity
January 27th 2012



6000 Comments


^not much of an accomplishment

FelixCulpa
January 27th 2012



995 Comments


Listened to this last night and it was pretty cool. He has a great deep voice.

Also if you have not yet heard Giles Corey - S/T you should check it out Ali. It's has a more shoegazy feel but it's more "dark folk". Also you should be contrib.

Digging: Japandroids - Celebration Rock

Digging: Japandroids - Celebration Rock

Relinquished
January 27th 2012



14280 Comments


really like all of this guy's material

Digging: Neurosis - Times of Grace

Digging: Neurosis - Times of Grace

fuckthatnoise
January 30th 2012



1110 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

well... that was an interesting first listen.

can't say if i like this yet, but it's definitely interesting regardless.

Digging: Mount Eerie - Clear Moon

Digging: Mount Eerie - Clear Moon

AliW1993
January 31st 2012



5773 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I liked it on first listen, but it certainly took a few more before it properly sank in.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2012 Sputnikmusic.com
All Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy