Red Hot Chili Peppers
I'm with You


2.5
average

Review

by Ryan Fitz USER (31 Reviews)
September 12th, 2011 | 15 replies | 3,967 views


Release Date: 2011 | Tracklist

Review Summary: If cockblocking isn't allowed, then why does this album exist?

4 of 7 thought this review was well written

John Frusciante, lead guitarist, virtuosic genius and rock savior, has quit the Red Hot Chili Peppers. Just thought I should get that news out of the way early in case you’ve been living under a rock, or Michigan's Upper Peninsula, and didn’t hear it from the music websites, the magazines, the constant speculation, or the widespread panic from fans worldwide. And that panic is well deserved, because for a long time now Frusciante has been the creative force that has kept the Red Hot Chili Peppers afloat, writing some of the Chili Peppers greatest hits, including “Zephyr Song”, “Can’t Stop”, “Californication”, “Scar Tissue”, and the boisterous, if slightly annoying “Give It Away.” With John leaving the band to focus on his acclaimed solo career, he leaves the remaining Chili Peppers to contemplate whether they should continue their own acclaimed career; the only problem is this time, it’s going to be without Frusciante.

Of course, like most bands that have been around since the parting of the Red Sea, the Red Hot Chili Peppers have sunk into a rather comfortable formulaic routine, repeatedly making the same album they have made since Clinton was elected. But rewriting the same album time and time again has never really been a problem for them, because, one way or another, they have always gotten away with it. This is partly because of the fantastic musicianship and energy they display on a consistent basis, and mostly because they’ve written enough hits to outlast Lady Gaga herself for at least the next eight years. So it comes as no surprise that the album that they released without Frusciante is the same album they would of released with Frusciante. Like every album, the flea’s pulsating bass is prominent; the verses are explosions of cheap thrills and groove, and the refrains are soulful yet standard affairs. Anthony Kiedis, the vocalist, yelps, raps, sings, and on the song “Ethiopia”, even beat boxes Old McDonald, because he’s just that hip. His lyricism, as always, ranges from questionable to incredibly stupid, with terrible pick-up lines (“Tick tock I want to rock you like the eighties”), attempts to sound clever (“She was the cutest thing that I ever did see. A drink in her hand and I don't mean tea.”), and some things that just don’t make much sense at all (“All my life, I was swingin' for the fence/ Always lookin' for the triple/ Never playing good defense.”) And just in case you still aren’t sure that this is a standard Peppers album, all but one of these songs are about sex…of course.

Unlike their last several albums though, everything doesn’t go smoothly this time. The musicianship is still impressive, and Klinghoffer, the former sound tech brought in to replace Frusciante, does a decent job of standing in his place. Most of these songs are still deadpan catchy, and the band still shows every sign of being able to jam with the best of them. But compared to the band's illustrious past, everything on the album just seems forgettable. The single “Rain Dance For Maggie” tries to combine the intensity of “Give It Away”, and the infectious nature of “By The Way” but comes nowhere close to either. “Look Around” aims for smash-hit “Dani California” and misses badly. “Police Station” attempts to replicate the emotional “Californication” with lackluster results. Unfortunately for the Chili Peppers, when it comes to the execution of their standard routine, after an unbelievable decade and a half, their hit-making quality is finally appearing to dip.

Adding to the problem, the album features little to no musical ingenuity, and the times when they do attempt to vary it up are mixed at best. “Did I Let You Know” features an unexpected trumpet solo that works beautifully, bringing the song alive at an unexpected moment, and Josh Klinghoffer’s vocals are used brilliantly in “Did I Let You Know’s” refrain, making it easily the most successful song on the album. Unfortunately other times, it all falls flat. “Brandon’s Death Song”, while trying to be the most mature and touching song on the record, instead plays out like the bouncing pop song that it, and every other song on the record, is. “Happiness Loves Company” and “Police Station” attempt piano rock, but there’s a clear reason why you never see the Peppers covering Elton John, because it plain out doesn’t work. Perhaps, most awkward of all is “Even You, Brutus” featuring Kieidis hysterically and theatrically shouting over piano and muted guitar, which, when contrasted with the traditional funk showcased in the rest of the album, sounds just about as out of place as a group of Amish at a rave.

Don’t get me wrong, this isn’t a bad album, but at the same time, there just isn’t much great about it. It’s an album that shows a band stagnated. Not moving forward and fighting not to move backward and therefore going absolutely nowhere. Frusciante’s absence is missed on the record, and not just for the mind warping guitar solos, but more-so, because the Red Hot Chili Peppers just don’t have the same spark without him. Which leaves us with a forgettable, predictable, and ultimately complacent album. Even when compared to the bloated Stadium arcadium, it just doesn’t stand up …but hey, Chili fans, don’t get too down, because on the bright side, at least it’s catchy



Recent reviews by this author
John Mark McMillan BorderlandManchester Orchestra Cope
Sigur Ros KveikurLinkin Park Living Things
Lost In The Trees A Church That Fits Our NeedsKathleen Edwards Voyageur
user ratings (799)
Chart.
3
good
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
letsgofishing
September 12th 2011



874 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

Wrote this review..

Posted it here for the lulz. I'll post a review that matters in a couple of days...But you should all still POS because I
wrote it.

Omaha
Staff Reviewer
September 12th 2011



9468 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

There are a lot of easily fixable mistakes, like misspellings. Anthony Kiedas, John Fruscianti.

"the same album they would of released" would have released.

"the bands illustrious past" the band's

And holy crap, writing a review for the album implies that when there's a TRUMPET solo in a song like "Did I Let You Know", you would need to get that correct!

"which, when contrasted with the traditional funk showcased in the rest of the album, sounds just about as out of place as a group of Amish at a rave"
and this sentence stands out as trying to be really funny and not being too successful; it disrupts the flow of your review.

I'm pointing all of this out, but at the same time I'm wondering why, because you need to take some pride in your work and proofread, and find the mistakes yourself.

Digging: Koan Sound - Dynasty

letsgofishing
September 12th 2011



874 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

Yeah, you're right. I have about 3 different versions of this review on my hard-drive, all in different stages, and i
definitely posted the wrong version here, saxophone and all lol. This looks like the 2nd Draft. But that still displays a
large amount of carelessness on my part, and although I'm perfect, I definitely did fuck up here. Thanks for taking the
time to tear me apart.



Omaha
Staff Reviewer
September 12th 2011



9468 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Trying to be of assistance is all, however ill-intentioned it may seem :] i believe you have earned a pos

mallen-
September 12th 2011



1235 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

I'm as big a Frusciante fan as anyone on this site, but this record would absolutely not be much better with him. It's not like he wasn't around for Stadium Arcadium.

Digging: The War on Drugs - Lost in the Dream

patrickfannon
September 13th 2011



884 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

Good review. Frusciante will be sorely missed.

toxin.
September 13th 2011



11804 Comments


I liked the review tbh. pos'd

insomniac15
Staff Reviewer
September 13th 2011



3155 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

"Rain Dance For Maggie" (aka The Adventures Of Rain Dance Maggie) doesn't sound at all like "By The Way" or even "Give It Away". Also, the same for "Police Station" and especially "Look Around"(this one is funkier than "Dani California" and not that pretentious). You're looking for flaws that aren't there. If you don't like these tracks, point the flaws they have on their own (like what does make you dislike them) , because the songs you said they sound like are nowhere close.
I agree with the rest of the review, it's nicely written, although they probably won't do anything as good as their Frusciante period, Josh is cool, he has a different approach, he's less flashy.

Digging: Amplifier - Echo Street

letsgofishing
September 13th 2011



874 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

I'm not arguing that they're the same songs, this is a different record, and a slightly newer approach...kind of. But what they were trying to achieve with those songs was the the same (arguably). They're obviously not going to make the exact same songs. And these songs may contain newer elements. But those are the roles Police Station, Look Around, etc. play.

telebyrd
September 13th 2011



869 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

The paragraph comparing songs to other songs should be omitted entirely

Aids
Contributing Reviewer
September 13th 2011



23633 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

the flea’s pulsating base is prominent


bass*

good review, if a little awkward in places.

Digging: Trophy Scars - Holy Vacants

Capablanca
September 13th 2011



173 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

I don't mind about orthographic errors in a review, as long as it gets its point across and captures my interest, which this one does. Summary is afwul though

Digging: Cloud Nothings - Here And Nowhere Else

letsgofishing
September 13th 2011



874 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

"Summary is awful though"

Damn, I can't get nothing right.

Thanks for telling it to me straight though guys, wouldn't have it any other way. I'm going to try to work on the infamous 3rd paragraph when I get some time tonight.

garth
September 13th 2011



91 Comments


I'm pretty sure Frusc didn't write Give It Away. It was born out of a jam that began with Flea pumping a bass line that Kiedis started yelling Give It Away over.

letsgofishing
September 13th 2011



874 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

It was a result of a jam session from the Flea and Frusciante, meaning that Frusciante came up with the main guitar riff. Regardless, it is more of a collaboration between the two, but my credit to Frusciante is not in error.

It wasn't until later, when they both showed the "song" to Kiedas that the incident you described happen.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy