This Is Your Captain Speaking
Eternal Return


4.0
excellent

Review

by ZombicidalMan USER (17 Reviews)
August 13th, 2011 | 13 replies | 4,724 views


Release Date: 2008 | Tracklist

Review Summary: One of the best albums you’ve already heard before.

3 of 3 thought this review was well written

In a world that’s ever changing and growing, it’s hard to be original. People have done so much, in every single aspect imaginable, that we’ve almost given up on being completely creative. Our houses, our cars, our instruments, even our daily lives are built upon principles from another time. We sit here, in the comfort of familiarity, and somehow we still crave difference. Everything seems so concrete and straightforward, that we hardly give it a second thought. Yet, in the world of art, and especially the world of music, there always seems to be someone pushing new, strange ideas – whether it’s Banksy, or Slint. But there comes a time when nothing new is produced, and every single thing is rehashed and redone. It becomes stale. People complain about music being so ‘unoriginal’ or a ‘rip-off of that cooler unknown band’. But I just want to throw something out there – why? Why does the music you listen to need to be fresh and exciting? Just because it follows the same blueprint as its influence, doesn’t mean it’s bad. This Is Your Captain Speaking, a band hailing from down under, proves that point exactly with their second album, Eternal Return. Sit back, relax, and listen. You might just enjoy yourself.

This Is Your Captain Speaking. The name itself pretty much just shouts ‘post-rock’, but is very appropriate to the sound of the music. When I think of a captain on a ferry, or a plane, I think of that voice telling you it’s going to be okay. There’s this voice that appears, throughout the journey, telling you things, fading in and out behind a wall of static. You’ll be pulled into the calm and commanding tone, waiting for the end. This, in effect, is the formula on Eternal Return. The album seems to lull in and out of consciousness, with reverb and echo ever present in the guitars. ‘Part 1’, the album opener starts out as mere silence, and then continues to grow. Faded guitar notes transform into tremolo-picked flurries, with drums padding on softly behind them. The build up stops. A quiet guitar continues under a slow wall of sound, and the drums pick up. Another guitar enters, ever so softly, and then another. An entire wall of sound is formed in a few minutes, in what seems like forever. Guitars are layered upon one another, with a main riff slowly playing while a lead part quietly echoes underneath. The effect is somehow natural, and yet completely surreal. Each song here has a great atmosphere to it, and while the album feels theme-less, the music itself creates a theme.

This Is Your Captain Speaking do something many post-rock bands fail to achieve, in creating something completely enthralling. When you listen to the music, you’re sucked in entirely. The music is intricate, the notes tightly knit around each other, never letting up. If one guitar slows down, the other slows down right with it, weaving melodies underneath. The guitars are almost never inactive, and act as the base for the layers of sound. The bass is always apparent as well, almost bouncing around the guitars, in a way that complements each new rhythm. Oddly, though, the drums here are almost non-existent. If any instrument on the album should have been showcased a little more, it is definitely the drums. The performance on them is tight, and equally important in the music (as drums usually are), yet also laid back. Cymbals are used effectively in each passage, with the snare and bass pedal only appearing in the ‘climax’ of songs. They almost sound as if the other band members said ‘Just play as quietly as you can, and as little as you can, so we can show off a little, alright?’ However, that’s my only gripe about the album, and, in a way, it works for This Is Your Captain Speaking. They’re definitely a band focused on the melodies of stringed instruments, and in turn, create some of the most beautiful and captivating sounds heard from Australia's music scene.

Anyone who calls themselves a fan of post-rock, and dare I say, music, should listen to Eternal Return. From serene, echoing passages, to massive soundscapes, the album never loses the attention of its listener. The production is polished and meticulous, with every song rising and fading in exactly the right way. It may not be anything new, but it’s good enough that it stands head and shoulders above dozens of albums coming out today.



Recent reviews by this author
Boris NoiseMarty Friedman Dragon's Kiss
Molecular Corporation Ambient Sputnik and The Dancing GovernmentKinoko Teikoku Long Goodbye
Asobi Seksu / Boris SplitAsobi Seksu Rewolf
user ratings (23)
Chart.
4
excellent
related reviews

Storyboard
trending alt & indie albums

Lowborn

AM

To Be Kind

Reflektor

Comments:Add a Comment 
ZombicidalMan
August 13th 2011



1760 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I thought this was a really great album, I listen to it as much as any Red Sparowes or Sigur Ros release. Review is kind of eh...

YetAnotherBrick
August 13th 2011



4405 Comments


Good review, man. What I've heard from this band is awesome.

iFghtffyrdmns
August 13th 2011



7047 Comments


your first paragraph, while well written and correctly placed, doesn't seem totally necessary to me here. it's a good thought and all, but, ironically enough, it's the sort of paragraph that I feel like I've read at the start of far too many sputnik reviews. I dont know though, it does seem like you put some thought into it so you aren't by any means in the wrong if you keep it, it just seems kind of dispensable to me.

As for the rest of the review, very nicely done :] That second paragraph is great, especially the bit about the captain part.
This sounds pretty cool, perhaps I'll check it if I get around to it.


ZombicidalMan
August 13th 2011



1760 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks a lot for the kind words. I agree that it's cliche to write about 'originality' in music, but I felt adding the bit at the end fixed it a little =P

I was listening to this last night, I might go back and add a few points to the review.

North0House2
August 13th 2011



5840 Comments


Lol, I still have yet to read a post-rock review that doesn't start off with the," post-rock has lost originality" statement. I even have put it in a few of my reviews.

Nonetheless, great review.

Digging: Amen Dunes - Love

foxblood
August 13th 2011



6797 Comments


the statement "One of the best albums you’ve heard before." isn't really a summary. i just think you could probably come up with a better one that's less vague. you make the album sound damn good though, i'll have to give it a listen

ZombicidalMan
August 13th 2011



1760 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks, North0House2.

@ Foxblood - I don't know, I think it explains it pretty well. It's music you've heard from other bands, but it's still really fantastic IMO. I admit it's pretty vague though =P Fair enough complaint, and I'm also glad I sparked your interest a bit.

foxblood
August 15th 2011



6797 Comments


ohh i totally misunderstood what you meant by it. i thought it was just a weird poorly worded sentence that meant it's one of the best albums we'll hear in a while, i didn't get that you meant that it's one of the best albums you've ALREADY heard from a million other bands.

maybe you should phrase it " One of the best albums you’ve already heard before." or something. that's actually a pretty accurate summary then:] my bad

acorncheese
August 15th 2011



7119 Comments


YEAH SUN

crazyblinddude
August 15th 2011



3389 Comments


From what I can remember these guys own.

ZombicidalMan
August 16th 2011



1760 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

@ Foxblood - I'll add 'already' into there, it does sound much better. Thanks man, haha.

And yeah, these guys do own.

crazyblinddude
August 16th 2011



3389 Comments


Yeah, had to play Storyboard over again to remind myself.

I think I like that one just a little bit more than this one. Solid band though.

cb123
December 5th 2012



2002 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

great album/band, they deserve a lot more love round here



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy