Mumford and Sons
Sigh No More


1.5
very poor

Review

by Adam Knott EMERITUS
July 7th, 2011 | 361 replies


Release Date: 2009 | Tracklist

Review Summary: If you don't listen to it properly, Sigh No More is a fantastic debut.

There is an unspoken truth within the self-proclaimed indie community that people who enjoy music that gets played on radio stations are in some way the victims of an elaborate con. The logical progression of this belief is the even quieter suggestion that a lot of people don't actually enjoy what they purport to, and are - through a combination of their own pretense and the record labels' apparent mastery of brainwashing - simply posturing. When they dance to Lady GaGa and cry to Westlife, they really wish they were swaying to Burial and healing to The National, or something like that.

While this mindset is predominantly the product of a superiority complex and a plethora of self-congratulation, there do exist deeper versions of the argument which hold more water: that, for example, bland pop music teaches people to disengage from musical diversity to such an extent that they don't feel like more "substantial" artists could or do have anything more to offer: a narrowing of the possible criteria, basically, by which an album or song can be judged. Hence, we arrive in 2011 with an undoubtedly astounding performance like Adele's 'Someone Like You' at the BRITs and the reactionary echo is loud but ultimately hollow: "look, an artist with real connection to their songs! Remember that?" But it still only reaches a large audience because of songs like 'Warwick Avenue' which are, in their recorded forms at least, far more trend-driven than heart-driven.

This is why Sigh No More is the worst album ever, because the claims it makes to altering the status quo fall flat before they've even finished being executed. Which claims are these? You surely didn't need to ask that question. It's all too easy to see, and therein lies the first disaster. We will bring folk to the mainstream. We will write lyrics that are meaningful. We will be inspirational. It's actually difficult to imagine that Mumford & Sons used any words other than "meaningful" and "inspirational" in writing their debut album, such is the transparency of the mission statement.

But it is not the objective-driven nature of the songwriting that lets down Sigh No More. No, many a superb album has been written with a full appreciation of an intended effect. But here, much more, it is the fundamental misunderstanding of what those terms - folk, inspirational and meaningful - actually mean, or worse still, a deliberate re-defining of those terms as diversion tactics. What results is a checklist of devices which one would hesitate to call clich├ęd because of their relative absence from the world of pop songwriting, but which are just as empty.

This is why every Mumford & Sons song sounds the same, because like pop's other worst acts (and I emphasise the use of the word acts) - say, Scouting For Girls and Owl City - their formula is their music. Here, the pre-determined soundscape is one of 'earthy' guitar and banjo, decidedly introspective vocals and words whose ambiguity hide the fact that they can't even possibly mean half as much as they seem to. And that inspirational last lift, of course, shouldn't be forgotten; how could you when it is repeated with such amnesia, ad nauseam, the same double-time strumming and the same gang vocals.

Like monkeys on typewriters, of course, Mumford & Sons occasionally type not quite the entire Iliad but maybe a couple of lines which do make sense next to each other. Such is the case with songs like 'Little Lion Man' and 'Winter Winds', and what results is indisputably endearing in isolation. But the images and expressions stumbled upon in these comparative standouts aren't just too infrequent over the course of Sigh No More as a whole - worse still, the gems that do somehow exist get lost amid the static, the forced rhymes and passionate platitudes which surround them.

And so every time an artist as painfully mediocre and meaningless as Mumford & Sons is touted as the next inspired and meaningful thing, the bar is lowered for the next set of pop artists, and soon we'll arrive at a point where even comprehensible lyrics are deemed a telltale sign of personal and emotional songwriting, where any slight vocal crack is labelled fragile in the same way as Conor Oberst's genuinely paper-thin desperation used to be, and any discernible 'real' instrument (banjos being, thankfully, still a last resort right now) is hyped as gritty or raw. Artists like Mumford & Sons are far more dangerous than ones like Katy Perry; their version of satan has been trained in the art of disguise.



Recent reviews by this author
Mumford and Sons BabelAbel (NY) Make It Right
The Gaslight Anthem HandwrittenMotion City Soundtrack Go
Sigur Ros ValtariSilversun Pickups Neck of the Woods
user ratings (1083)
Chart.
3.4
great
other reviews of this album
ImTheOnlyThugInTheBuildin (3)
An album that is only slightly above average...

Michael Philp (3.5)
Despite murdering their best idea with the best intentions Mumford & Sons still manage to craft a se...

Davey Boy STAFF (3.5)
Delivering folk - and the banjo - to the masses....

doug (4.5)
With banjo in hand, Mumford & Sons have created the debut album of the year....

related reviews

Babel

Comments:Add a Comment 
Knott-
Emeritus
July 7th 2011


10198 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0 | Sound Off

This really needed a negative review and hopefully this is one.

BigHans
July 7th 2011


26454 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

hipsters dont like this band cause they dug them for a little bit then they got too popular.

Crymsonblaze
July 7th 2011


7495 Comments


thank god for you knott

Lakes.
July 7th 2011


28396 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

i hate this album too but

Digging: Scott Walker and Sunn O))) - Soused

Lucid
Contributing Reviewer
July 7th 2011


7026 Comments


thank you

DoubtGin
July 7th 2011


6752 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

pretty predictable reviews lately

Tyrael
July 7th 2011


20900 Comments


Oh... nice review Adam

AggravatedYeti
July 7th 2011


7685 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

It's actually difficult to imagine that Mumford & Sons used any words other than "meaningful" and "inspirational" in writing their debut album, such is the transparency of the mission statement.


outdone yourself adam.

Ire
July 7th 2011


41795 Comments


i actually thought you gave this a high rating lol

CrisStyles
July 7th 2011


768 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Lol nice summary, good review too.

Knott-
Emeritus
July 7th 2011


10198 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0 | Sound Off

cheers guyz

also 150 woo

MO
July 7th 2011


18865 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Knice review Knott.

Dismantle
July 7th 2011


398 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Personally, I'm knott too into this band either. good review btw

MisterTornado
Contributing Reviewer
July 7th 2011


4507 Comments


That last paragraph was excellent. Pos'd

Monheim
July 7th 2011


250 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

I have to say, Knott, I really like your negative reviews. This review and the First Days of Spring one are rather epic.

Romulus
July 7th 2011


8441 Comments


this is cool and really well written and all but it's a bit like beating a dead horse don't you think?
but then again this is the first negative review for this so no big deal

zxlkho
July 7th 2011


3465 Comments


I really liked this review. Knott is one of the best imo.

IAmHollywood
July 7th 2011


1443 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

This band was a doorway for a lot of my friends into stuff like Fleet Foxes and Elliot Smith so don't hate, this is something the mainstream needs imo

Knott-
Emeritus
July 7th 2011


10198 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0 | Sound Off

That's pretty nice but it doesn't make this album good.

aok
July 7th 2011


4440 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

hipsters dont like this band cause they dug them for a little bit then they got too popular [2].

also, they realized there was a formula to mumford's music and that pisses them off



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy