Botch
We Are the Romans


5.0
classic

Review

by YetAnotherBrick USER (28 Reviews)
June 15th, 2011 | 76 replies


Release Date: 1999 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Intelligent and abrasive, but never pretentious or obnoxious, We Are the Romans shatters the earth, then leaves without a trace, leaving the listener wondering how metalcore can be so crushing, and at the same time be so subtle and soft-spoken.

There must’ve been something in the air during the recording of We Are the Romans. All of the album’s patterns that seem like they needed to be meticulously worked out, all of the perfectly achieved atmospheres and crushing walls of sound, seem to pass by too nonchalantly to suggest that the band slaved over them to the point of frustration. The numerous transformations and subtle nuances each song contains are executed much too smoothly for the listener to infer that anger, not musically constructive anger, but real, frustrated anger, was poured onto the instruments that recorded this masterpiece. The album is soft-spoken, in both its well-written and intriguingly subtle lyrics, and in the punishing, technical, and at times trance-inducing metalcore madness that makes up its music. The album is intelligent, but never pretentious. It’s abrasive, but never obnoxious. And the way it pounds, strolls, and utterly annihilates its way through its clouds of dissonance and distortion is so puzzlingly perfect, it almost makes the album seem otherworldly.

The album is not overproduced, overworked, or overdone. Every single riff on the album sounds completely organic; each riff is either a variation of the riff that came before it, or something completely different, but either way, it always fits perfectly. Some songs end in a completely different spot than where they started, and some don’t. But the band picked the right structures for the right songs, because not only every song, but every riff, pattern, and harmony, flows flawlessly. From the insanity of opener “To Our Friends In the Great White North,” to the final strums of closer “Man the Ramparts,” the listener is never left wondering where one riff or passage came from, like in “C. Thomas Howell as the ‘Soul Man‘,” where the main verse riff is brilliantly interrupted by a guitar-only passage consisting of repeated eerie, high notes. After a few seconds of this, the rest of the band members come in, and the guitar keeps playing the high notes, just more of them, and in a different pattern. The song then keeps going with this pattern, until it eventually slows down exactly when the song calls for it. The song then goes out with a bang, riding out on a huge, epic chord pattern, backed up by frantic drum fills, all letting the listener know that the song is soon going to crash and burn, in the best way possible.

“Transitions From Persona To Object” is another great representation of the album’s organic nature. Every riff in this song feels completely natural, not forced, or even placed, in the slightest. They feel so natural, that at times it almost seems like the riffs themselves are coming up with the riffs. Beginning with its bewilderingly eerie intro melody, the song comes up with awesome riff after awesome riff, all grooved perfectly to fit the mood that part of the song calls for. All of the heavy riffs that come after the intro eventually lead to a high, dissonant passage, into which the low, heavy riffs and the vocals make their way back. The song then ends with some frantic, discordant noodling that fades out and leaves a few seconds with only the listener and a drum beat.

But not only are all the riffs, tones, melodies, and atmospheres perfectly placed, the sounds themselves are incredible. The riffs that begin the passage around the 2-minute mark in “To Our Friends In the Great White North” are some of the most epic in the entire genre of metalcore, along with the gigantic, soaring chords that lead “Man the Ramparts” through its duration. “Man the Ramparts” also features a passage in which a choir bellows the line “we are the Romans” in a rather grandiose fashion, and then is overtaken by another devastating riff accompanied by the ferocity of all the other musicians. This passage ends the album on a heavy, epic, and yet again, perfect note.

Along with the atmospheres and sounds created by the grandiose outro of “Man the Ramparts,“ and the walls of dissonance in songs like “To Our Friends In the Great White North” and “Transitions From Persona To Object,“ they’re also created by simple, but ominous and trance-inducing guitar leads, like in “Swimming the Channel Vs. Driving the Chunnel.” Due to the frighteningly ominous guitar lead, and all of its subtle build-ups and hints at something bigger to come, this song is probably one of the eeriest songs I’ve ever heard. Nearly the whole song consists of that same guitar melody and variations of it, and it’s accompanied by spoken-word vocals, which definitely only add to the eeriness. When the vocals stop, and the guitar melody keeps playing until the drums eventually fade out, the song is so timid and reserved it could validly be considered “ambient.” All of these organic variations in sounds, among many other examples, like the jazzy passage in “Mondrian Was A Liar” or the vocal trade-offs in “I Wanna Be A Sex Symbol On My Own Terms,” make it so the album never gets stale, and is nearly impossible not to enjoy, or be intrigued by, at the very least.

So yes, the seemingly effortless music of We Are the Romans is definitely a large contributor to the album seeming like it just walks in the listener’s ears, destroys them, and leaves without a trace. But the smart, subtle, and beautifully unpretentious lyrics are a large contributor as well. They address themes that were relevant at the time of this album’s recording, and are still relevant now, like bands arrogantly preaching to their fans, and purposely giving them all they want in order to get more of them, like in “C. Thomas Howell as the ‘Soul Man’:”

The worst music I’ve ever heard,
Honesty that touches a nerve
The words fall onto the floor,
Drive home with no lessons learned


Some of the lyrics also consist of simple, ambiguous angst, angst that slides in next to the crushing and powerful music perfectly, like in “Frequency Ass Bandit:”

Anchored awake, wringing my hands
Weighing my time, running down dreams
Buying your life,
Patience is a girl I’ve been trying to forget about


Every line corresponds with the music that backs it up perfectly, and all the words are delivered with a passionate, unrelenting combination of a hardcore-esque yell and a nasty growl. The intelligence and honesty of the lyrics, and the vehemence they’re delivered with, provide a nice balance with the otherworldliness of the music. Because they deal with human themes that many people can relate to or find relatable themes in, they let you know that this album was indeed made by flawed human beings just like you and me, no matter how unbelievable the music makes that sound.

We Are the Romans is like a firework; once its fuse is lit, it erupts and lights up everything around you with its vibrant colors, and crushes your ears with the loud, pulverizing force with which the colors are launched out of it. During its duration, it seems to be the only thing happening in your world, and then…it’s over. The album never begs for attention, it simply does what it sets out to do so well that the listener can’t not give it their attention. And when it finally comes to a close, they’ll be wondering what the hell just happened.



Recent reviews by this author
The Beatles Rubber SoulSerengeti Family and Friends
The Chinese Stars A Rare SensationThe National Trouble Will Find Me
The Story So Far Under Soil and DirtAesop Rock Labor Days
user ratings (1425)
Chart.
4.3
superb
other reviews of this album
feelthemetallica (2)
Imagine a Between the Buried and me, crossed with a Converge that's vocals are the worstest you coul...

David Driver (5)
Far and away one of the best metal albums of all time....

Ryan Flatley EMERITUS (4.5)
We Are The Romans is an Earth shattering album that fused hardcore and metal to create an album of t...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Parallels
June 15th 2011


6643 Comments


brick? botch?

YetAnotherBrick
June 15th 2011


4504 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Umm...yeah. lol

Pretty proud of this one. Give me feedback please.

Digging: Soul Coughing - Ruby Vroom

TheSpirit
June 15th 2011


17987 Comments


It's pretty good but it reads awkward in a few places

Digging: Volahn - Aq Ab Al

YetAnotherBrick
June 15th 2011


4504 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Where?

hmmmmmm
June 15th 2011


38 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Awesome review, i enjoyed reading that. pos'd

This album is the tits

YetAnotherBrick
June 15th 2011


4504 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

thanks, man.

Parallels
June 15th 2011


6643 Comments


no wai... im still in shock...
ok brick, ill pos it. its golden.
stay gold brick, stay gold.

YetAnotherBrick
June 15th 2011


4504 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Umm...okay. Thank you. hahaha

Enotron
June 15th 2011


7695 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

awesome album

Wheelah
June 15th 2011


756 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

JOHNNY DIEDDDDD

Anyway, have a Pos. This album is flim-flammingly amazing. Review ain't bad either.

Hawks
June 15th 2011


35838 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

This album slays so fucking hard.

MB05032
June 15th 2011


20 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Good content with a few comma splices (second sentence, for instance).
Pos

fsharptrit0ne
June 15th 2011


4814 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

It's ridiculous how much Norma Jean rips off Botch.

-_-

ZombicidalMan
June 15th 2011


1904 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Ah, this is one of my favorite albums ever. Great review.

AfterTheBreakdown
June 15th 2011


7166 Comments


nice review. Will check this out again. I've only listened to one song before by these guys. Pos'd

Blackbelt54
June 15th 2011


4276 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

nice review, this has been growing on me a lot lately, I will probably bump it up

djunior
June 16th 2011


816 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

pos'd.
probably my favorite album. real talk

Digging: Kiasmos - Kiasmos

RagingStorm
June 16th 2011


509 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

nice review dude

dimsim3478
June 16th 2011


5308 Comments


Awesome review, awesome album. Pos'd.

Digging: Crying - Get Olde Second Wind

YetAnotherBrick
June 16th 2011


4504 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

thanks guise



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy