Wilco
A Ghost is Born


3.5
great

Review

by something vague USER (16 Reviews)
November 12th, 2005 | 25 replies | 11,813 views


Release Date: 2004 | Tracklist


5 of 5 thought this review was well written

I was sitting here just a little bit ago looking at the cover of this album, and it ignited a undying craving for scrambled eggs that will never be fulfilled. "Why?", you eagerly emote. Well...

We're out of eggs.

Jeff Tweedy - Vocals, electric guitar, acoustic guitar & baritone, twelve-strings, six-string acoustic bass, loops, filters & synths
John Stirrat - Bass, eletric guitar, backround vocals, piano, acoustic guitar, loops, filters & synths
Glenn Kotche - Drums, hammered dulcimer, percussion, loops, filters & synths
Leroy Bach - Piano, Korg CX-3 organ, bass, electric guitar, acoustic guitar, vibes, loops, filters & synths
Mikael Jorgensen - Synthesize, piano, RMI Rocksichord, farfisa organ, Fenix modular synthesizer, Serge modular synthesizer, stylophone
Jim O'Rourke = Piano, bass, electric guitar, acoustic guitar, ARP 2600, loops, filters & synths
Fraknie Montuoro - Hammer dulcimer
Karen Waltuch - Viola

Obviously Jeff Tweedy is not a man that runs out of eggs often. Wilco has been at it for awhile, constantly evolving from a standard alt-country/rock band into one that does a lot more experimenting than say, The Eagles. I'm not sure if I have ever read a overly negative response concerning any of their previous albums. But, one thing you need to take into account before you even consider listening to Wilco's most recent studio effort, A Ghost is Born: don't count your chickens before the eggs hatch.

A Ghost is Born is the sound of a little band wanting to sound like a huge rock band. This is mainly due to Jim O'Rourke, one of the most well-respected and lauded producers in the past ten years or so, especially in the indie world. Other than being a producer and engineer, Jim is also a multi-instrumentalist, which hints at his understanding of dynamics, space, texture, and so on. His, along with Wilco's, production gives A Ghost is Born a distant feel, although it is still as warm, ethearal, and welcoming as you would expect it to be. Not all credit can be given to the production techniques of Jim O'Rourke, though; Jeff Tweedy and the rest of the intstrumentalists here are all fine musicians, with a fine understanding of when not to play. Tweedy's voice can be one of the most depressing around. He sounds fragile, heartbroken, down-on-life, but you know he has just a little bit of hope left somewhere in that lil' heart of his. Often, he is only accompanied by a piano, until each instrument slowly comes in, hinting at a climax somewhere in the song. This is the opening track "At Least That's What You Said", although it goes from a somber piano ballad to a thumping, loud, and exhuberant solo section. Tweedy then proceeds to rip apart the song with sloppy, fuzzed-out soloing. This, however, seems to project so much passion that it's a welcome addition to the song. Epic.

Quite a few of the quieter, mellower songs on A Ghost is Born stand out much more than uptempo, though boring, rockers like "Spiders (Kidsmoke)", which drones on for an unacceptable 10 minutes, and "I'm A Wheel", a fast no-nonsense quicky, just in case you forgot that Wilco couldn't rock out old-school. "Hell is Chrome" follows up the emotional powerhouse "At Least That's What You Said", with a piano part sounding very familiart to The Band's "The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down". It tends to drag though, especially considering that it is placed inbetween more uptempo tracks. What saves the song is Jeff Tweedy's lead guitar playing, just as emotive as his voice. "Hummingbird" is an uptempo, piano-driven ditty with beautiful sections throughout, most notabley Karen Waltuch's viola fills. You know, I really hate to say this about an album, but best thing about A Ghost is Born is that, whether you ignore the lyrics or not, the songs all remain the same as they would have otherwise. Quite a lot of Tweedy's lyrics seem to be nonsense ("Spiders are filling out tax returns / Spinning out webs of deductions and melodies / On a private beach in Michigan"). If there is a backstory or point to A Ghost is Born, than I have certainly missed something by examining these lyrics for several days.

"Handshake Drugs" might just be one of the best songs on A Ghost is Born. Brief guitar stabs, bubbling bass lines, and piano accents along with what could be the most danceable drum part on the whole album accompany what seems to be a mix between a Paul McCartney and Bob Dylan vocal delivery. The lyrics seem to detail scoring drugs, downtown. But Jeff sounds pretty damn happy singing about sunny days and chewing gum (and drugs lolz). It ends with guitars creating some spiraling noise, and some other glitchy supercool stuff that sounds like Chewbaca having sex with a bumblebee. "Wishful Thinking" starts off promising enough, y'know, with kitchen noises and some clattering noises. Until that noisy acoustic strumming comes in. Who can listen to that crap anyway? "Company in My Back" isn't exactly a big winner. It's basically the better acoustic songs on A Ghost is Born, but it's actually pretty boring since Jeff Tweedy just mumbles about while some acoustic melodies come through, which happen to be the only good part about the song. Sorry Jeff. "Theologians" kicks the last two or three songs' asses. You know why? Groovy drums and some more classic rock-influenced playing from the whole band. It could be an Elton John song I guess, but with a Lynyrd Skynyrd fill (It sounds like "What's Your Name") and some pretty rockin' (cheesy) guitar playing. Of course, you're not really allowed to enjoy yourself for too long, right? This is where the terrible, terrible, terrible "Less Than You Think" comes in. Obviously Jim O'Rourke had a lot do with the devolopement of the song; a few minutes of piano balladry ruined by 13 minutes of subterranean noises and a high-pitched wavering noises. "The Late Greats" is nice and alt-country: happy, upbeat, rockin'. Stuff like that. It ends a bombasat-filled album with a non-pretentious note, which I greatly admire for some odd reason because most of the album is good.

Even if some songs are terrible attempts at being overly creative and pretentious ("Spiders (Kidsmoke)", "Less Than You Think"), much of A Ghost is Born shows that it's never too late to try and be a big 'ol rock 'n' roll band, though I highly doubt that Wilco will ever achieve that particular status. Therere guitar heroics in Least That's What You Think" and "Hell is Chrome", but they are easily counterbalanced by plaintively arranged piano sectons and Jeff Tweedy's soulful, fragile voice. Sometimes we all need a good breafast, an egg and maybe some bacon or something like that (pancakes and waffles are for little boys), but A Ghost is Born ain't exactly the egg you want to be crackin' and cookin' up so you can digest it and put it back into the water. Nah. But, it is a fine, beautifully crafted album with a fine attention to detail and a good knack for melodies and not playing. Yeah.

Recommended Songs:
At Least That's What You Said
Hummingbird
Handshake Drugs
Theologians



Recent reviews by this author
The Flaming Lips The Soft BulletinSonic Youth NYC Ghosts & Flowers
Ciccone Youth The Whitey AlbumSonic Youth SYR1: Anagrama
Slowdive SouvlakiSonic Youth Sister
user ratings (316)
Chart.
3.8
excellent
other reviews of this album
ronburgandy (4.5)
Jeff Tweedy is upset......

Kashmir09 (5)
Hey, Tweedy can shred too...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Zebra
Moderator
November 12th 2005



2647 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Very good review. I have always been on and off with Wilco, and this is an average album. There can be some boring moments, but the highlights make up for some of it.

Good review, you detailed everything to the max. This Message Edited On 12.23.05

NEDM
November 12th 2005



1113 Comments


Nice intro paragraph, haha.

Ill check this band out and tell you how I like them.

pulseczar
November 12th 2005



2385 Comments


nice, I've heard older Wilco, they're good :thumb:


[quote="Cheeto-t"]quote me and say this review is like sex[/quote]This Message Edited On 11.12.05

Scott Herren
November 12th 2005



192 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

This album is ok, but nowhere near as good as YHF, Summerteeth, or Being There.

woofwoofwoof
November 12th 2005



156 Comments


i love hammer dulcimer! and wilco!

innerdark
November 14th 2005



749 Comments


nice job on the first paragraph.This Message Edited On 11.14.05

Badmoon
November 14th 2005



384 Comments


Pretty good album. I'm a pretty big fan of Wilco and can easily say they've done better and worse, of course.

There's some great songs off of AGIB: "Hummingbird", "The Late Greats", "Handshake Drugs", etc

The Jungler
February 1st 2006



4827 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I saw a video of them playing "at least thats what you said" live and the guitar solo blew me away.
This album has its high points as opposed to YHF which is one big high point.
nice reveiw, the intro was pretty funny, good work.


Legendary1
April 22nd 2006



10 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

This album was really well done. I think it is a fine peice of music and a great album, there are some great songs. Hummingbird is a very good song I love the chords used. Handshake drugs is also a solid song. The best song on this album would have to be Wishful Thinking.

zachattack
May 10th 2006



1 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I'm in love with this album.
It's too bad the reviewer writes off "Company In my Back", it's easily my favorite song.
I've never heard hammered dulcimer rock harder in my life.

STLMiguel
May 21st 2006



335 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I actually like this more than YHF, I must be the only one. I mean, "At Least That's What
She Said," that song is just awesome.

Good review, I just like this more than you!This Message Edited On 05.21.06

The Jungler
May 31st 2006



4827 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I have faith that even when Wilco start putting out awful records they will still have amazing opening tracks.

Two-Headed Boy
July 12th 2006



4527 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I really like this album. Handshake Drugs and Hell Is Chrome are fantastic.

griftadan
October 31st 2006



10 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

the songs on this album sound much better when played with nels cline in the band. particularly atleast thats what you said and muzzle of bees. i don't know why the review didn't mention that song, its probably one of their best.

Riley12988
May 9th 2007



109 Comments


Pretty much every song sounds better with Nels Cline in the band.

See: Kicking Television

Doppelganger
August 2nd 2007



3124 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

At Least That's What You Said is my favorite Wilco song evar.

thegentlemanFelon
November 18th 2007



8 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Spiders (Kidsmoke) is perfect the way it is. I've never thought of it as being pretentious at all (unlike the aforementioned Less Than You Think).

robin
Emeritus
February 16th 2009



4221 Comments


handshake drugs is so good

Kashmir09
September 12th 2009



772 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I love this album...still just a hair below YHF for me while being just a hair above the rest of their discography, making it my second favorite

Spec
April 15th 2011



26833 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Hummingbird is such a great song.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy