Alkaline Trio
Crimson


3.5
great

Review

by Rudd13 USER (61 Reviews)
November 9th, 2005 | 47 replies


Release Date: 2005 | Tracklist


Alkaline Trio- Crimson

Pop Punk. Itís been a while. Itís quite difficult to come crawling back to a genre you gave a big, fat break for a while. Donít get me wrong, I have great appreciation for this genre and it was the very first I was ever properly introduced to; But noticing the change between different kinds of music lets you hear things that you didnít realize were there before. Coming back from heavy doses of the more raw, and coarse sound of classic punk gives you the ability to see things (or hear for this matter), that the naked eye, or ear, cant pick up on when the song youíre listening to is just one of the many of the day belonging to the same music style. In other words, this review is bound to have pretty good detail as far as Iím concerned.

As well as many pop punk bands that stand at a fairly generic state, Alkaline Trio was never a big impact on me, but it was a damn good way to release some demons if you know what I mean, and entering the bandís headspace was as easy as entering through the same realm other pop punk bands abide at so constantly. Iím not big on the bandís history, but I always enjoy watching the war go on concerning the bandís Ďemoí stance. Iím not here to carelessly continue the argument, but to say that I honestly donít care. Their music is on the enjoyable side and thatís all every fan should really care about when theyíre listening to a band, or these guys, at least. I recently learned they hail from Chicago, and first heard them when my sister let me borrow her copy of Maybe Iíll Catch Fire, which she hated. I gave it a chance, and started to get into the bandís stuff until I became somewhat of a bigger fan when Good Mourning came around in 2003 or so. Apologies for some loss of info about the group, but at this point to me itís clear that if you donít know the info yourself, then it doesnít really matter anyways. Theyíre here to share their somewhat capricious music and thatís all that should be known. Period.

Morbid vocals are a big aspect the band and lead vocalist Matt Skiba brings to my attention. While this isnít exactly all positive and all negative, thereís reasoning behind it. The only flaw (and a pretty big one) with the vocals is that if you were to remove all music from a track, it would be monotone-fest. To me, its almost unbearable, but Skiba quickly makes up for it by entertaining with his distinctive voice to begin with. The band wouldnít be Alkaline Trio without it, and Iím sure itís the first thing every fan pointed out about the music itself at first. His flaw doesnít show in all his work, but enough for you to get used to it. While this is a big part of the band for me to look out for, it still has no comparison to the rest. Which is why I have begun the review with vocals this time around.

By now whoever hasnít figured out the band is made up of three members will I guess have trouble reading any review on the site. Skiba multi-tasks with glee on all his work with his guitar strap and his picks at reach. To say that his guitar-work doesnít do much for the band kind of upsets me, but it is partly true due to the fact that if they instead of Skibaís multi-tasking, a lead guitarist with more concentration, they would be able to crack out all the hooks that lure you into their albums, plus so much more. Thatís up to them, but the truth is that for every impressive introductory/main riff on this album at least, theres about three or four riffs in the other remaining tracks that either act up and make the track less worthwhile, or hold it back from reaching high numbers. Unique, and actually noticeable guitar-work from Skiba can be spotted on tracks like The Poison, Back To Hell and a few more. But overall, Skiba does a great job with transitions and keeping the line clean for the others both at once.

My favorite part of the band is without a doubt the rhythmic section, or technically speaking, two-thirds of the band. Behind of the drums sits Derek Grant, the musician on here that shows off talent the most, and behind the bass stands Dan Andriano. Andriano either has bad luck, or if heís the one that arranges his parts, heís just really stupid. When simple verses and sometimes non-chaotic mid-sections flow freely, Andriano never even bothers of bringing out the big guns, even in the areaís higher points, where Skiba and Grant go a bit over the top to show that some sort of conclusion will come up. Itís in parts where thereís some sort of loud effect or other big distraction that Skiba does his big share. Hopefully, someone will be listening, because I almost couldnít recognize these large groups of notes hit when thereís a backwash of effects coming from the other way. The man has talent, no doubt about that. But it needs to be placed in the right place most of the time. This doesnít go to waste, as he shares with drummer Derek Grant one of the most awesome bass/drum interaction Iíve ever heard from pop punk. Grant is brilliant. Heís got speed, excellent coordination, and the timing that the drummer for the part requires to pull through most of the bandís chaotic melodies. Other than that, Itís the number of effects this guy uses to impress listeners. I cant spot one measure in his work that doesnít have some sort of ghost note, accents, a silenced buzz roll, or cymbal switching. Grant is brilliant, and one of the best that Iíve witnessed in pop punk.

Heading back to the rhythmic section interaction. Grant and Andriano are astonishing when working as a group in certain sections where Skibaís work is not greatly involved. Keeping in mind that Derek has something short and wacky to do at the end of every other lyric, Andriano follows, not always with an unpredictable array of notes, but with mimmicks, or an echo of the drum pattern that Derek shortly finishes. The bass is also sometimes blended in with lower-tones drums so well that it seems as if a note by Andriano is an extra kick by one of Grantís pedals. This is a remarkable thing to look out for, and I highly enjoy the duo working together to begin with. As far as backing vocals by Dan go, they get sort of repetitive and annoying after a while because all they really experiment with in every higher-speed chorus is the over-dubbing technique. Lyrics are also greatly admired by lots of fans, but I donít care for the alcohol-endulged talk Skiba shares with the audience (not to mention death). It never hit me, but it seems to be different with everyone else, so thatís just me.

The singles seem to have the greater impact this time around (Time To Waste, Mercy Me, Burn), and they contain the material that is forthmost best presented in the fashion that fascinates. The marvelous introductory piano part on the first single Time To Waste is a nice change to look out for, as well as synth material to accompany on tracks like Sadie and Smoke. This album is definitely worth a look, but not anywhere close to the bandís best album. Good Mourning still stands as my favorite and it captures more of the bandís emphasis that I like to see and hear. A lot of tracks on here feel all too generic and alike. A few gems, and a bunch of deadened leaves that now lie on the floor. If youíre a fan, by all means, dig in. If not one yet, look elsewhere before beginning the discovery.


Stand Out Tracks:
Time To Waste
Mercy Me
Back To Hell
Smoke

Great.

3.5/5



Recent reviews by this author
Roger Miret and the Disasters My RiotStreet Dogs Back To The World
Flogging Molly Whiskey On A SundayMad Sin Survival Of The Sickest
The Tossers The Valley Of The Shadow Of DeathThe Unseen State Of Discontent
user ratings (646)
Chart.
3.6
great
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
NEDM
November 9th 2005


1113 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

You owned me, by a lot. But that was one of my first reviews so its okay.

:thumb:

Jawaharal
November 9th 2005


1832 Comments


good review man. You get an e-hug and a vote from me.

DesolationRow
November 9th 2005


833 Comments


Nice review, but I absolutely despise anything in this genre. But then again, our tastes are conflicting, so.....

goblue1098
November 9th 2005


61 Comments


good review, id probally give it a 4/5 tho....the weakest track was i was a prayer, and i still loved that....and yea, the intro piano in time to waste is amazing. A3 are great, best album by them yet


Electric City
Staff Reviewer
November 9th 2005


15743 Comments


thumbs up smile face. Great review Rudd, as always and what should be expected from a top 15er.

Chilly-Bean-Bop
November 9th 2005


344 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Lovely review.

I will always like this cd, though I do prefer MICF over this.

pulseczar
November 9th 2005


2385 Comments


cool review rud to da double D [/lame]

even though you forced me to read it because i dont like this band

Rudd13
November 9th 2005


952 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

^ Eheh, pecker-slapped.

Zebra
Moderator
November 9th 2005


2647 Comments


Alkaline Trio has always been a band I could never get into, even in my middle school years. I heard this album was good by a number of people so I might check it out just out of curiousity.

Nice review, your reviews are always detailed to the max.

Chilly-Bean-Bop
November 9th 2005


344 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

[quote="empty hearted"]
Sweet. Great review, you have my vote. I'm gonna get a copy of this album somehow, whether by buying it, downloading it or something...[/quote]

I could send it to you over AIM or MSN if you have it.

Zebra
Moderator
November 9th 2005


2647 Comments


I just listened to the recommended tracks and didn't really enjoy it. It wasn't bad, but it just sounded like uninspired pop-punk music.

Rudd13
November 9th 2005


952 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I have failed you, Zebra. Im so sorry :upset:

*slaps himself*

NEDM
November 9th 2005


1113 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

How was DethBed nor Fall Victim not a recommended track!!!!!!!!!!!

Zebra
Moderator
November 9th 2005


2647 Comments


*Chuckles to himself*

NEDM
November 9th 2005


1113 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Get one of those Zebra. They're sure to please.

Fabz
November 9th 2005


136 Comments


great review

Storm In A Teacup
November 9th 2005


13191 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

The two Beyond suggested are great songs to. I really want to reveiw this, but it would just be more praise, of which there is enough of already. Also Back to Hell and the other bottom recomended song I actually think suck. Wonderful review.







or is thereThis Message Edited On 11.09.05

Killtacular
November 9th 2005


1314 Comments


Nice, review, guy.

I no hear-y any Alkaline Trio, and no want to.

Storm In A Teacup
November 9th 2005


13191 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I nominated you for best reviewer of punk because of this review Rudd, just to let you know.

Rudd13
November 9th 2005


952 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Why thank you. Its a shame no one really reviews the genre anymore... :upset:

Well, just keepin' it alive. :thumb:



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy