Depeche Mode
A Broken Frame


3.5
great

Review

by Major Tom CONTRIBUTOR (139 Reviews)
February 23rd, 2011 | 10 replies


Release Date: 1982 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Without Vince Clark's influence, DM created one of the most intriguing albums in their catalogue, sprinkled with oddity, melancholic beats and a lone underrated classic 'The Sun and the Rainfall'.

1982. Vince Clark who pretty much made Depeche Mode’s debut album (Speak And Spell,1981) his record, had left to form Yazoo and Dave, Martin and Fletch were left alone to try and build upon the success they had from tracks like 'Just Can't Get Enough' and 'New Life'.

Speak and Spell never really sounded like a DM album - it was more a collection of sugar-coated, pop friendly synth tunes that sounded light years away from the dark, electronic noise fans would come to love. And unfortunately, neither does this album.

However, aside from 'A Photograph Of You' and 'See You' (both songs are essentially clones of the simple, synth pop found on their debut, although the latter scored them their highest chart position to date, at the time), the album does make a considerable amount of progress from their Clark-dominated debut.

The first track, 'Leave In Silence' is a pretty simple synth-pop tune but is far from upbeat and jolly, with lines like "Stop this thing from spreading like a cancer", it becomes apparent that the boys did make a slight effort to make this record less overtly joyful. The same could be said for 'My Secret Garden' (one of the best tracks on ABF). It's a pretty simple synth-pop song again but there are subtle signs of darkness throughout - Dave’s voice is an unconcerned whisper and the tempo is fairly downbeat, especially with its slow-building intro.

There are a few quite odd songs in 'A Broken Frame', that end up being some of the most interesting moments on the album, if not for sheer curiosity factor alone. 'Monument' is one of the aforementioned, with its squelchy rhythm and odd chanting chorus of "My monument - it fell down, Work all of my days - it fell down". It's a pretty pointless lyric but the overall feel of the tune is 100% more downbeat and dark than anything found on 'S&S'.

'Satellite' captures that same feeling. It's as melancholic and grey as the artwork on the cover of the album - Dave’s voice drags along the song, with whining synth that subtly jumps in near the back end of the song, adding to the misery. 'Shouldn't Have Done That' is just bizarre - with marching, wind, and child samples, odd tinkering beats, despair filled vocals and even odder lyrics, it's not a brilliant song but is strangely lovable and worth a listen for pure bizarre-o factor, alone.

The album does contain one much underrated classic, however, with 'The Sun and the Rainfall'. The melody is just gorgeous, with gentle synth falling and rising and a pounding drum-beat that kicks in on the chorus. Dave’s gentle vocals (found throughout the record) finally seem suitable as he sings the most emotional line on ABF, "Things must change", as the tune gently fades out.

Whether it was the effect of a primary songwriter leaving or the pressure of trying to deliver more chart success, overall the album feels like somewhat of a failure - a failure in the sense that the band had an opportunity to move away from the upbeat, campy Vince Clark tunes found on 'Speak And Spell' and create their own sound, but they didn’t seem confident enough to do so.

There is a subtle undercurrent of melancholy running across most tracks but it just wasn fully formed yet, so most songs just feel miserable, as opposed to their later dark sound that was both depressing yet uplifting. Things hadn't quite gelled yet, but there are hints of darkness throughout and "The Sun and the Rainfall" is essential listening for any Depeche fan.



Recent reviews by this author
Metronomy Love LettersTemples (UK) Sun Structures
Bombay Bicycle Club So Long, See You TomorrowOasis Dig Out Your Soul
Oasis Don't Believe the TruthOasis Heathen Chemistry
user ratings (138)
Chart.
3
good
other reviews of this album
KovenantDM (3.5)
This is Depeche Mode's rebound after songwriter Vince Clarke left after their first album. It is fla...

analoguecrazy4 (4)
After the departure of Vince Clarke, Depeche Mode as we know it were born. But without a clear sense...

Stephen Gore (2)
The real Depeche are born, but it's an ugly birth......


Comments:Add a Comment 
bloc
February 23rd 2011


35004 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

This is one of the few DM albums I just cannot stand

Digging: The Birthday Massacre - Superstition

Tom93M
Contributing Reviewer
February 23rd 2011


1106 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Yeah, its not the easiest of listens. They just hadn't found their sound yet.

bloc
February 23rd 2011


35004 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Good work though, I suppose you'll be reviewing their entire discography?

omnipanzer
February 23rd 2011


21646 Comments


A very nice and complete review. Cheers for reviewing an almost 30 Y/O album. I like seeing hoe opinions change over time.

Pos'd

Tom93M
Contributing Reviewer
February 23rd 2011


1106 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Thanks for the nice comments, guys. Re: Bloc - Yes, in chronological order (just main studio albums for now, mabye live albums/compilations after that).

kygermo
February 23rd 2011


996 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Great review, album is very meh. However, the next album is quite excellent

Titan50
February 24th 2011


4588 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

Another good review.

Easily their worst album though

Tom93M
Contributing Reviewer
February 24th 2011


1106 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

thanks, Titan50 and yeah, unfortunately it is one of their worst. Gotta love 'the sun and the rainfall', though.

marguskiis
September 1st 2014


8 Comments


One of their best albums, experimental and strange. Although very underrated.

Sabrutin
November 8th 2014


999 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

My rating may not suggest it, but I love this album's nostalgic sound. It kinda reminds me of the melancholic OST from Spyro: Attack of the Rhynocs for the GBA.

"My Secret Garden" is definitely my fav track here.

Digging: AC/DC - Rock or Bust



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy