The Starting Line
Based on a True Story


4.0
excellent

Review

by goblue1098 USER (6 Reviews)
October 31st, 2005 | 21 replies | 9,118 views


Release Date: 2005 | Tracklist


0 of 3 thought this review was well written

the punk-pop quartet formed in 1999 under the name 'Sunday Drive' that quickly transformed into the starting line as they churned out their first ep, with hopes of starting over, and then their full length debut, say it like you mean it, both under Drive-Thru records. after a while of sucessful touring, they were back in the studio recording Based on a true story -- onward to the review --

The Starting Line are:
Ken Vasoli - Vocals, Bass
Matt Watts - Guitar
Mike Golla - Guitar
Tom Gryskiewicz - Drum

Action - well, this is 30 secconds of pain. a few drum stick clapping together, and then a voice saying "quiet on the set, roll sound, roll camera, and action" its supposed to give the effect of a movie scene, but i think its just stupid and another way to sneak an extra track into the listing. its only 30 secconds long, so it dosent deserve a full rating

Making Love to the Camera - ahhh, after the painful thirty secconds of action, i hear a soft acousit guitar, taking me back to the beginning of 'the best of me' from say it like you mean it. it proceeds into a cool inro riff, sound like a more mature, more polished version of the band i had listend to waiting for this album to come out. this song isn't that lyrically impressive, though it does deliver some cool riffs and beats. this one gets a 3.5/5

Inspired by the $ - guessing from the name and the lyrics, this song is about the thirst for money. the lyrics i thought would be pretty much cliche, and i was right. not too much special there, but the actual song, not lyrics are what carry this oen. it starts out withh a great sounding guitar and bass piece that continues into the verse. unlike in some of the other songs, the bass is quite audible here, which really adds a deeper, richer sound to this song. there's a short but satisfying guitar interlude in the middle, opening up another strong riff. not the best on the album, but near the top. 4/5

Bedroom Talk - this is the first song i heard from the new album, and the lead single. a short, but great sounding drum intro really throws you into the verse, which pretty much contains more cliche lyrics about falling in love, you kno, emo stuff. the lyrics get a little risque with "i'm gonna tear your ass up like we just got married", but it continues onto more cliche love lyrics. the guiutar and bass track aren't nececarily impressive, but they do the job well, not turning attention to themselves. good song, but it gets repetive after around ten listens. 4/5

Suprise, Suprise - great song, and by far my favorite on the album. a cool intro guitar piece melds nicely as a keyboard joins in. The dual vocals really sound great together in this song, and for the first time in the album, the lyrics aren't bad. the shours has a real cool sound to it, and the tempo from that is kept up in the verse as well. after the final chourus piece, the music fades away to leave a single guitar playing the same riff from the beginning. as i said at the top, my favorite song on the record. 5/5

Photography - after being dissapointed in the first two songs' lyrics, these ones really impressed me. although still about finding love, they sing in mere desperation of "swinging from a streetlight" to be with them. a soft acousitc guitar draws you into the ballad, as mellow piano and a faint violin join in. as it just seems to quit out and fade into pure strings, vocals, and piano, a trmendous guitar comes in for a fantastic section of the song. although that is dominated by guitar, you can still faintly hear the strings and piano, which continue throughout the song. great song, it really showed a side of TSL that i hadn't heard before. 5/5

Autography - a twin in name to the previous track, but ploar opposites in sound. instead of a soft acousic guitar leading into the song, a poppy guitar beat starts up this one. like suprise suprise, you can hear a piano in the background. this song is another solid one, but not much to stand out for me. 3/5

The World - starting out like any other pop-punk track, it drastically slows down in the verse, starting with a chours of claps amd soft, easy guitar parts. once it gets back to the chours however, it quickens nicely into a thunderous chours, but slows down again in the verse, evoking nirvana's famous stop and go style. after the seccond chours, a cool guitar solo comes in joined by gang lyrics. i don't neccecarily like this, but it works well for this song. another good track, nothing special though. 3.5/5

Artistic Liscence - unlike autography and the world, Artistic Liscene starts out much harder and with a guitar riff that dosen't sound like a ten minute learn. the tempo is kept up through the song, instead of frequent shifts like in the world. Plus, in parts of the verse, singer vasoli gets semi-close to screaming, adding yet another harder touch. the interlude is much softer, showing off bass skills, which is then followed by a killer solo, something i haven't seen much of from the starting line. the song alone is good, but the great solo is the sugar topping. Artistic Liscene gets a 4.5/5

Stay Where I Can See You - hey, wanna hear ANOTHER song about a girl! well then this one's for you. yea, yea, yea, i just wish i were with you, blah, blah, blah, you know, stay where i can see you, so i can always love you, blah, blah, blah. more cliche lyrics, with pretty borring and unoriginal riffs. this is the shortest song next to action, clocking in at just under three minutes. the only complaint i had for this song is why it couldn't be shorter. easily my least favorite song. 2/5

The B-List - again with this song, and many others on this album, the lyrics are nothing special. the b-lsit starts out with simple singing and an easy guitar piece that progresses into a cool riff. the verse sounds great, with the guitar and bass stopping at short intervals but still keeping the tempo up. the chourus opens up into another great sounding riff really showing off the guitar skills. this is just what i needed after hearing stay where i can see you. 4/5

Ready - instantly after hearing the opening acoustic guitar, i had high hopes for this ballad, seeing as how much i like photography. the first half is very soft and soothing with only the acoustic guitars and vocals. a kind of synth sound and symbol comes in fora while, before all sound muted for a guitar piece throwing 'ready' into a new tempo. it slows back down again, ending the song. this ballad was good, but bad in comparison to photography. 3.5/5

Cut! Print it - with the last song here, i would expect nothing less from the starting line. another good pop-punk song, filled with fun guitar pieces and the ocassional piano.the guitars really shine during the chours, one playing heavy chords, the other soloing to give it a great sounding layered feel. plus, for once, the lyrics don't totally suck. the song fades out with a cool drum piece followed by some feedback. as the last on based on a true story, i was left with a sweet and satisfying record. Cut! print it gets 4/5

based on a true story is a great cd i would reccomend to any fan of the starting line, or for anyone looking for a great cd. my overall rating for this cd is 4/5

best songs: Inspired by the $, Suprise, Suprise, Photgraphy, Artistic Liscence, and Cut! Print it



Recent reviews by this author
Green Day Bullet In A BibleThe Rasmus Into
Green Day ShenanigansThe Vines Winning Days
The Rasmus Hide From The Sun
user ratings (134)
Chart.
3.4
great

Comments:Add a Comment 
Rudd13
October 31st 2005



952 Comments


I could never figure out what was going on in that freakin album cover. Is that a camera? a machine gun?

Its a mystery!

francesfarmer
October 31st 2005



1477 Comments


Looks like a camera to me.

ocelot-05
October 31st 2005



807 Comments


Dude, this is a freaking review, not an instant message. Your review was decent, but you really need to focus a little bit more on punctuation. Just how hard is capitalization? Other than that, it's all good.


goblue1098
October 31st 2005



61 Comments


yea, sorry about the punctuation, i kinda thought about it when i finished it, but i was too much of a pain to go back and change it. im lazy

maddraven1716
October 31st 2005



14 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Yuh, seeing how song titles including "Making Love to the Camera" and "Cut! Print it", I would think the object on the album cover is a camera, and not a machine gun. Its a decent cd, above average, but sometimes follows too much into the generic pop-punk sound. This Message Edited On 10.31.05

xcbmetalcorex
October 31st 2005



18 Comments


Not as good as SILYMI but it's grown on me alot. They're instrumental skills and song writing skills have improved which is good but the slow songs just kill the album. It doesn't have the tremendous energy and catchiness that SILYMI had. I'll be doing a review for this.

skateboysi@aol.com
March 30th 2006



2 Comments


the review was written by an assholeThis Message Edited On 03.30.06

masada
April 3rd 2006



2733 Comments


it's okay at first, but then it just gets boring.

meh.

Psyclone
April 14th 2006



432 Comments


[quote=skateboysi@aol.com]this review was writtin by an asshole[/quote]
What makes him an asshole?

Is that a camera? A machine gun?

The film border probably suggests that it's a camera. Plus, it looks more like a camera than a machine gun.This Message Edited On 04.14.06

DepthsOfDreams555
May 6th 2006



55 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

This album is alright, SILYMI is so much better. Suprise, Surprise is an amazing song. Good review.

jaamieee
May 9th 2006



13 Comments


Congratulations on missing all the subtlety in Ken's lyrics.
Example, you said about 'inspired by the $', "the lyrics i thought would be pretty much cliche, and i was right. not too much special there, but the actual song, not lyrics are what carry this oen" and, "this song is about the thirst for money."
However, this song is a skepticism about the thirst for money,as illustrated beautifully and subtly by the lyrics, "Get it across to the boys at the top of the ladder, I'm climbing up. I have my doubts." It is clear to see you don't truly understand alot of the lyrics.

and the cover is obviously a Camera.This Message Edited On 05.09.06

Athom
Staff Reviewer
October 5th 2008



17195 Comments


I'm gonna tear your ass up like we just got married
And you're all mine now!

bung bung.

DaveyBoy
Staff Reviewer
January 19th 2011



20855 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

The 2nd LP from The Starting Line is clearly a more matured effort, finding a midway point between pop-punk & alt-rock. Kenny Vasoli controls his nasally vocals much better here, while many of the band's rougher edges have been smoothed over. That does result in the effervescently energetic guitar-work being toned down a little too much, and the hooks do take some time to sink in. Yet ultimately, 'Based On A True Story' should grow on most listeners to be another excellent offering that suggests The Starting Line are continuing their sincere attempt at growth. Recommended Tracks: Bedroom Talk, Surprise Surprise, Photography & The World.

Atari
Contributing Reviewer
April 11th 2013



19433 Comments


the world needs another starting line album

Digging: Musk Ox - Woodfall

Atari
Contributing Reviewer
June 28th 2013



19433 Comments


band rules

MuhNamesTyler
June 28th 2013



3694 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I agree with both of these comments

Atari
Contributing Reviewer
June 28th 2013



19433 Comments


lol you must be the only other fan of this band on here. say it like you mean is is way better than this one but whatevs jamming this hard

TheSpirit
June 28th 2013



17136 Comments


Say it like you mean it is pretty underrated around here

Digging: Monarch - Sabbracadaver

Atari
Contributing Reviewer
June 28th 2013



19433 Comments


:D it's so damn good. Pretty much every song is amazing

Atari
Contributing Reviewer
June 28th 2013



19433 Comments


this one rules too tho damn forgot how good surprise, surprise was



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy