36 Crazyfists
Collisions and Castaways


2.5
average

Review

by Deviant STAFF
July 23rd, 2010 | 114 replies | 18,914 views


Release Date: 2010 | Tracklist

Review Summary: The sound of a band starting to give up

Despite their recent accommodation into the more accessible realm of “mainstream metalcore”, 36CF are a band that I’ve always managed to have a lot of time for. Yes, they’ve never been the most innovative or cutting edge band on the scene, but constant travels through my music collection have seen the boys as the final destination on a number of occasions. Everyone has that band that they’ve grown up with; you know, that scrappy little underdog that managed to grab you just as puberty started misfiring unnecessary amounts of emotion through your system, sucked you in because they spoke directly to you, and made every song an anthem just for you. 36CF are that band for me; I matured as they did, suffered all of life’s little oddities and dilemmas as they did, and shared late nights and long bus rides with them. The boys always had time to give, always had a word or a line that always suited the occasion, be it uplifting or at the very least, accommodating and understanding. Bitterness The Star was my shield for the longest of times, only really ever replaced by the crisp sleekness of their follow up, A Snow Capped Romance. I wore those albums to death, turned them inside out, studied them intricately and learned every part. But you know, we all grow up sometime, and while I’ve managed to finally thrown on a pair of man pants and move on, they’ll always manage to be “that band” to me; and just as they defended me for so long, so too would I (at great length) do the same for them. Collisions and Castaways has robbed me of the ability to do that properly now.

Perhaps it was a stab at a bigger spotlight that saw the band adopt their now common place Killswitch-isms during the recording of Rest Inside The Flames, because god knows the fists have gone criminally overlooked for pretty much the whole length of their 16 year career. It wasn’t a full overhaul in the blueprint of their music, but a distinct change was registered and noted. It was an aesthetic more toyed with than fully embraced though, a breakdown scattered intermittently throughout the cacophony designed to interrupt rather than to carry. The Tide and Its Takers cranked it all up a few notches more, and introduced a new vocal delivery that perhaps served as the biggest deterrent. 36CF shamelessly sold their vocalist as their biggest drawing point simply because it was warranted, the man had pipes (and to a degree still does). So when your shining star goes guttural, a solid musical backing better be the least you can muster. Well while they spiraled down with their last record, Collisions & Castaways plumbs new depths that I didn’t think could exist within this group. Yes, its energizing and sure, when I listen to this it makes me want to get all rowdy and fight and *** (I don’t recall ever having those particular reactions before), but for every inspired idea, every interesting guitar lick, faults arise that just shouldn’t exist, simply because every other “modern metalcore” band has them as well.

But this is 36 Crazyfists, and even though this is music done to death by a staggering amount of other groups, they’re still a band that does manage to do it better than most. The most noticeable difference on offer here is Steve Holt’s increased comfortableness around his guitar. Every cut features wall of sound guitars, double tracked so as to come across as constantly in turmoil; riffs are stacked on top of riffs, changing on a dime, shifting effortlessly between standard fare chug and swelling burst of chord progressions. Noonan’s drumming has sadly fared worse; whereas Rest Inside The Flames was filled with quirky and varied drum fills, here he resorts to standard patterns and an over reliance in double pedal action. The running joke of bass in a metalcore album continues, albeit in a slightly more subdued fashion. It’s noticeable in every track, but I could put money on that being uber-mixer Andy Sneap’s deft touch at work. And Brock does hit great poignant moments when he jumps into “clean” mode, revealing just how toothless some of his peers really are, but goddamn if those gutturals aren’t a slap in the face to what he’s actually capable of.

So while ‘In The Midnights’ is a promising and alluring introduction, and ‘The Deserter’ reveals a level of harshness previously unheard of by these four Anchorage lads, the tedium, ultimately, prevails more than I’d really like to admit. Collisions and Castaways is the sound of a once hugely promising band starting to give up.

"If this was the end of the band, this record is exactly what I wanted our band to do at one time, Maybe a lot of people will think we're just metalcore, but it's so much more than that. It's a heavy record with some big choruses and everything we've been about for a long time with a cool metal feel to it that I've been wanting."

Take me back to 2004 when everything about this band was fresh and invigorating. I mean come on guys, I’ll regress if you will as well.



Recent reviews by this author
Burial Rival DealerDeadmau5 > album title goes here <
Mala Mala In CubaFour Tet Pink
Shed The KillerTNGHT TNGHT
user ratings (157)
Chart.
3
good
other reviews of this album
UO910 (2)
36 Crazyfists' sloppy and mistake-prone behavior demeans Collisions and Castaways to a bottom feeder...

Dan H. CONTRIBUTOR (3.5)
Does brutality and a change of tact rid 36 Crazyfists of the mistakes of old? Yes, but only for the ...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
July 23rd 2010



30297 Comments


Streaming: http://tunelab.com/2010/07/23/album-stream-36-crazyfists/

Digging: L'Orange - The Orchid Days

Ponton
Emeritus
July 23rd 2010



5775 Comments


hmmm, liked the route you went with this review

Collisions and Castaways has robbed me of the ability to do that properly now.


nice

Digging: Mimicking Birds - Mimicking Birds

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
July 23rd 2010



30297 Comments


I actually feel like this ties in nicely with my review for Bitterness The Star, which was absurdly long winded

Cheers, as usual, Jared

Ponton
Emeritus
July 23rd 2010



5775 Comments


This is one of those bands that I never got around too when I was on a binge for this kind of stuff. I remember hearing a snow capped romance was pretty good

pizzamachine
July 23rd 2010



12568 Comments


Collisions and Castaways has robbed me of the ability to do that properly now.

Dang, that is sadly convincing.

fromtheinside
July 23rd 2010



16385 Comments


i thought they started giving up a long time ago. nice review i'm thinking around the 2 range, you have a history with this band dev?

Digging: Lord Mantis - Death Mask

dr2den
July 23rd 2010



1342 Comments


theres a town an hour away from me and all the kids there worship this band and 5 finger death punch. i hate thoes kids so much.

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
July 23rd 2010



30297 Comments


You should definitely look into A Snow Capped Romance, and even Bitterness The Star to a lesser degree, which is a great nu metal album that has aged quite nicely

ThePalestMexican
July 23rd 2010



2816 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Wow, I was working on a review for this
Might finish and post it, might not, probably can't beat this either way.

Awesome review Deviant

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
July 23rd 2010



30297 Comments


i thought they started giving up a long time ago. nice review i'm thinking around the 2 range, you have a history with this band dev?

Depends on your thoughts for their last two albums I guess

Thx Mexi-can

bloc
July 23rd 2010



34499 Comments


Band has never been good.

But nice one Jason, glad to see you reviewing metal.

Digging: He Is Legend - I Am Hollywood

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
July 23rd 2010



30297 Comments


Cheers Ali, it won't last though

bloc
July 23rd 2010



34499 Comments


Yeah, I knew this would be nothing more than 7 minutes in heaven...

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
July 23rd 2010



30297 Comments


Well the review is, the album not so much

DDconjoined
July 23rd 2010



326 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Im not sure what to do, I have all their albums.. but I don't want to waste money on a 2.5er

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
July 23rd 2010



30297 Comments


Here's an idea - listen to the stream

DDconjoined
July 23rd 2010



326 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

yeah that wasn't what I was talking about..I have downloaded it also.. I meant actually puchasing it, as I have done with all their albums, some people still do that man.

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
July 24th 2010



30297 Comments


Well, listen to it and work out just how you feel about this album

DDconjoined
July 24th 2010



326 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

yeah I reckon your review was very well done, but I think its a lot better than that.. 4/5

BrahTheSunGod
July 24th 2010



1279 Comments


Great review; amen to your entire first paragraph. A Snow Capped Romance is such a sentimental favorite for me that it's ridiculous.

To me, this band started going downhill the less Brock sang (loovvveee his vocal delivery, probably just because I'm a sucker for Palumbo-esque, emotion-packed warbles) and the more he screamed and tried to be heavy. It went from using screaming tastefully as a logical complement to emotional parts of the song, to being overused as a simple substitute for singing. Same with the guitars; as soon as they started to chug I started to cringe.

That said, this is still better than most. I'm at about a 3-3.5 now; we'll see if it grows or falls with another listen.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy