Poison the Well
Versions


4.0
excellent

Review

by Tom USER (6 Reviews)
May 15th, 2010 | 9 replies | 4,016 views


Release Date: 2007 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A gigantic stylistic leap which is rewarding given the effort and time.

2 of 2 thought this review was well written

Poison the Well already made a fairly significant stylistic jump between Tear From The Red and You Come Before You, but this time the change is so drastic it almost doesn’t sound like the same band. Guitarist and primary songwriter Ryan Primack revealed in interviews that Versions is deliberately frustrating and for the first dozen or so listens, this is immediately obvious. In fact, it took me a whopping six months to come to terms with it but now that I have, the genius is obvious. Every song on here is dense with instrumentation and genre – a messy mixing pot of hardcore, country, metal and jazz. It boils together to create one of the most unique albums in core, yet somehow manages to make it flow in a way many other technical and eclectic bands should take note of.

While Poison the Well initially made a name for themselves with their trademark brutal to melodic song structures, Versions finds them expanding on the formula by making the transitions smoother and allowing entire songs to go by in one style or the other. Letter Thing explodes from the speakers kicking off the album in a highly energetic way, yet it’s also the weakest song overall (typically it’s also the only single, continuing their poor track record in that department). Fan favourite Prematurito El Baby is a better example of the more hardcore songs on the record, rocketing along with classic PTW drumbeat and an urgency unmatched anywhere else in the track listing. On the flip side of the coin there are songs like Slow Good Morning and Riverside which move forward at a leisurely pace, allowing the instruments and styles time to be heard and weave themselves into tight knots that take patience and a good set of earphones to unravel. As such, it is on tracks such as these where Versions truly excels if given the time to soak into your ears.

However, the album suffers from some serious flaws. Jeffrey Moreira’s lyrics are at a career low, largely unengaging and evidently suffering as he transitions from his old highly personal style to his new one of weaving unique and twisted stories through characters talking in first person. Lyrics to not completely ruin a record however and the majority of the blame must go to the production, which comes as a surprise since the legendary Eskil Lövström and Pelle Henricsson (of Refused’s The Shape of Punk To Come fame) were at the helm. It seems a full and evenly balanced sound was sacrificed in favour of instrumental complexity which unfortunately hurts the record tremendously. There is a significant lack of bass (not the instrument), but the treble is weirdly weak considering this. The worst affected are Moreira’s vocals as his usually bear-like harsh vocals are flattened and his cleans aren’t helped out either.

Despite the production problems however, Poison the Well succeeded in creating an incredibly intricate album that, while it will never be as hugely influential as their debut, proves that they are definitely not a one trick pony. They continue to push boundaries and bend genres, creating unique and innovative music.

Album Highlights:
Riverside
Slow Good Morning
Prematurito El Baby
Composer Meets Corpse



Recent reviews by this author
Walking With Mirrors Behind Closed DoorsEvermore Truth of the World: Welcome to the Show
Bloc Party A Weekend in the CityEditors An End Has A Start
Bullet For My Valentine Scream, Aim, Fire
user ratings (401)
Chart.
3.5
great
other reviews of this album
Understanding In a Crash (4)
A pleasant change. A new beginning (or ending?)....


Comments:Add a Comment 
Captain North
May 15th 2010



6743 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Shit, code fuck up. How do I edit again?

Captain North
May 15th 2010



6743 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Nevermind, fixed.

And I agree largely, however the sheer instrumental diversity and density isn't there on the Tropic Rot and there is more variation in pattern here.

Captain North
May 15th 2010



6743 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

^It took me 6 months to get past that stage. But ergh, Letter Thing is pretty boring.

AtavanHalen
May 15th 2010



17927 Comments


Dude, it's Italics for Album Names, not Underlining.

Captain North
May 15th 2010



6743 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Eh, well I was taught to do both for essays, I just couldn't fucked here and I wanted them to be different to the song titles.

But you know, thanks for the comment on the reviews quality.

AtavanHalen
May 15th 2010



17927 Comments


review is like my penis
long and hard

Piglet
May 15th 2010



4644 Comments


That was unnecessary.

Inveigh
May 15th 2010



24180 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I actually think this review ruled. That probably has a lot to do with the fact that I agree almost 100% with every point you make, I'm literally not sure if I could have said it better myself.

However, while I do think that this is Moreira's weakest album lyrically, I still don't think they're that bad. If I was rating the lyrics alone I'd probably give them a 3/5. The production is what makes this so hard to get into, and keeps it from being a classic in its own right. Well that, and the songwriting's a bit inaccessible at times.

Digging: Symptom - Caverns Of Katabasis

Captain North
May 15th 2010



6743 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks man. I dunno, I just can't get into the lyrics here at all. Yeah, they're not woeful but I can't keep myself interested in them for the whole album length like I can for their others albums.

And yeah, the whole thing is incredibly inaccessible but once it clicks the songwriting is flawless.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy