Porcupine Tree
Lightbulb Sun


4.5
superb

Review

by IvortheEngineDriver USER (3 Reviews)
September 22nd, 2005 | 250 replies


Release Date: 2000 | Tracklist


It’s been a while since I’ve done one of these, so bear with me. Porcupine Tree is one of those bands that is a gem in a field of rocks. They have been there for a long time, since 1989, under the radar. With Deadwing, they have gained some more recognition, but more for their name (people are constantly telling me “what a stupid name") and the hard-rock edge of “Shallow" that is even played here in Arkansas, where I live. But if you look at the history of the band, you will see that they started off with heavy prog influences and then, as they progressed as a band and especially Steven Wilson, they have grown into a band with powerful songs and great lyrics, compared to their early days of more ambient sounds and instrumentals. To see them progress from On the Sunday Side of Life to Deadwing, its really amazing. With Stupid Dream, they turned towards the format they are using to this day.

Lightbulb Sun is the band truly polishing this format and is an amazing prelude to the greatness of In Absentia. They produced some of the greatest songs ever written and truly show their talent on this album. Everyone in the band is on the mark, especially Steven Wilson, who really shined on this, in my opinion. His playing is great and even better, his voice is truly beautiful and his lyrics are right on the mark. Why this album didn’t get the success it deserved is beyond me. This is original drummer Chris Maitland’s last outing before leaving the band and being replaced by Gavin Harrison. Chris really does a great job on this album as do Richard and Colin. Steven is really the most honest with himself and is on the top of his game.

The2Stranger summed it up in his review of Stupid Dream: Porcupine tree was founded in 1987 by vocalist/ multi instrumentalist Steven Wilson.
It was his own made up project to explore psychedelic and progressive music.
After gaining more success, Steven Wilson decided to replace the drum computer with a real drummer, and that he would give the bass guitar out of hand and most of the synthesizer and keyboard parts to his new keyboardist.
Steven focused on guitar, vocals and lyrics, but is still the thriving force behind Porcupine Tree.

Anyway, on to the review.

Porcupine Tree is:

Richard Barbieri: Analogue Synthesizers, Hammond organ, Mellotron.
Colin Edwin: Bass Guitar.
Chris Maitland: Drums and Percussion.
Steven Wilson: Vocals, Guitars, Piano.

Now on to this amazing album:

1.Lightbulb Sun – The title track is a great start. Some soft acoustic work that is a great riff, then breaks into a harder rock with a strong bass line by Colin. The song is about being sick and trying to feel better. It has one of the best chorus’ “My head beats a better way/Tomorrow’s a better day". Great song, one of my fave’s. Steven’s voice on it is really awesome. 5/5

2.How is Your Life Today? – Quite a contrast from Lightbulb Sun. No rhythm section…pretty much all Barbieri. Heavy piano, with some ambient noise later on. I can’t really describe this song unless to say its very British, if that makes any sense :). I think Steven’s voice is really beautiful on this track, but it doesn’t really measure up to the rest of the album, or really fit in. I give it a 3/5

3.Four Chords that Made a Million – A great song that I overlooked when I first got this album. Its really rocking with some weird effects on the guitar. The Indian drums in the beginning are really great. The song is one of the more rocking tracks, more like something you want to hear live. I think it’s a great song. 4/5

4.She’s Moved On – This is one of those songs that is really weird, but it draws you in. I think the thing that stands out most for me is Steven’s vocal pattern and how it matches the guitar very well on the verses. I love the harmonies on the Chorus and through the whole song. You want to hear Steven singing amazing, check this song out. I love his guitar as well, great solo. 4/5

5.Last Chance to Evacuate Planet Earth Before It is Recycled – An interesting track. It’s a 2 parter, the first part is called “Winding Shot". It reminds me of a CSN song a lot. Some great banjo playing and a strange sound on the bass, perhaps he is playing on a stand up. My favorite line is “It's just you and me alone/Not grown ups but not kids/You kissed me on the lips". The rest on the song sounds more like just a jam song. Different but I like it! 3.5/5

6.Rest Will Flow – This is my favorite song on the album and the most poppy. I think the symphonic sounds Barbieri uses and Chris’ drums I find really tight. I love the line “Stay with me my angel/I found you/Now I don’t Feel Low". A catchy love song that really just resonates with me very well. Very catchy, I think it’s a must for anyone listening to the album. 5/5

7.Hatesong – Great opening bassline by Colin, really carries the whole song. The harmonics and ascending scales are great fills. Drums come in brilliantly and Steven’s lament is purely…well, Steven. I think it’s a great song and kinda just cool to listen to. 4/5

8.Where We Would Be – The Coldplay track, what I like to call it. An awesome love song with great some echoing percussion. Steven’s voice is really just beautiful on this track with a powerful guitar solo which, I think is great, but I kinda wish they just kept it with the acoustic. But, still, its well placed and heart-felt, like a solo should. Another one of my favorites. 5/5

9.Russia on Ice – The longest track on the album at 13:02. The most prog-ish track on the album. I love the lines “Can't stop myself drinking/Can't stop being me/If I call will you come and will you save me ?" I really like it, but I think the end part of the song, like Last Chance is an instrumental and kinda drags out for my liking. Its still pretty rocking though, it’s a good listen. Another one of them just jamming, which I really like. I give it a 4/5

10.Feel So Low – A simple song with nothing really special. The worst song on the album, almost filler, but I really like how honest and powerful Steven’s words. Anyone whose ever been brushed off would appreciate the song, but its nothing like the rest of the album. I give a 2.5/5

Overall, I think it’s an amazing album and for me, it is up there with In Absentia for their best work. Definately a 4.5/5 if not perfect.The band is really tight and Steven’s vocals are just simply beautiful. I love having this album on all the time and I hope this review has made you want to go listen to it again or for the first time. Thank You :)


user ratings (1227)
Chart.
4.1
excellent
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
IvortheEngineDriver
September 23rd 2005


164 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Hey guys, sorry about the format, first time I submitted a review through Sputnik, so I apologize for anyone who finds this hard to read.

Damn it, I want to edit some shit, anyone know how?This Message Edited On 09.22.05

Med57
Moderator
September 23rd 2005


1001 Comments


I put gaps between the individual track reviews just now, but I'll leave any other editing for you. This is an OK album...not as good as their best, but still a solid listen.

Killtacular
September 23rd 2005


1314 Comments


I think you rated a few songs too low to make for a 4.5.

Kage
September 23rd 2005


1172 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Russia on Ice is the best PT song ever written. How could you give it a 4/5?

Other than that, good review. It seems some PT fans live and die by this, while others say it's just another great album.This Message Edited On 09.23.05

pulseczar
September 23rd 2005


2385 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

this album is brilliant. btw you're track reviews dont match with your final rating.

the2stranger
September 28th 2005


130 Comments


good to see a part of my review could be of help to you

well good review for a good album
Russia On Ice is the gem od this album, and How I s Your Life Today is such fun to play.

there is one think you can change, you wrote She's Moved On instead of the real title Shesmovedon.
it's nothing big, I just noticed it
fanboy++

I would like to see you doing more reviews.
as you're IA review was ace too

Mr. M, Man of Muzak
December 23rd 2005


8 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I've really been digging this album lately. I think I like this more than Deadwing. I still need to check out In Absentia.

Zebra
Moderator
December 23rd 2005


2647 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I really enjoy this album but I think that there are to many tracks.

I think that if there were one or two less tracks than I would listen to this a lot more often.

The first three tracks are my favorites and then things increasingly go down hill after that.

pulseczar
January 18th 2006


2385 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

This is probably the most consistent PT album, if it had their earlier innovative style it would probably be a 5 for me. But some things, particularly the distorted guitars, are a bit too generic.

Dr. Jake Destructo
April 9th 2006


86 Comments


Such an album.

Hebrew Hammer
May 6th 2006


37 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Lightbulb Sun and Russia On Ice are my favorites on the album. I just recently came across this compilation, and I must say it's well done and one of their best. Good review btw, keep it up.

Kingofdudes
May 18th 2006


294 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

The first three tracks are my favorites and then things increasingly go down hill after that.

Really? I think the album really takes off after the first three actually.

kingsoby1
Emeritus
October 15th 2006


4950 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Track reviews are kind of a poor choice for formatting. I would rather hear about the album as a whole... instead of whether or not every other track is vaguely "great".

The review is ok I guess, just not something I would base my opinion about purchasing on; on amazon, I skip over reviews like this.

That said, I feel this is an excellent album and agree that Russia On Ice is one of the best Porcupine Tree songs.

XSebbyMcMuffinX
May 19th 2007


339 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

This album is a complete classic for me. The only things that might throw it slightly off for me are tracks 1 and 3, but that's only the slightest bit.

Altmer
July 28th 2007


5652 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I completely disagree with your Feel So Low rating. That is probably the best song on here, and I find the slow, melodic, acoustic guitars, and the dreary atmosphere so incredibly awesome to revel in. I can't stop listening to it.

This is a great album, but of their post-Stupid Dream work (including that album), it's probably the worst. That doesn't really say anything though since it's still a killer album and Steven Wilson is a genius.

Thank god for PT.

paco999
August 6th 2007


5 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Lightbulb sun is such a sad song. But I still love it and basically the rest of the album. I think this one is tied for my favorite one along with Deadwing and Up the Staircase.

Geedrummer
September 22nd 2007


607 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

is this album relly rare in the UK or someting. the cheapest iv found it is £39. wtf is up with that

FR33L0RD
September 24th 2007


1464 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

"Deadwing" (4/5)
"In Absentia" (4/5)
"Stupid Dream" (4.5/5)
are much better than this album, IMO.

but i must confess that "Russia On Ice" track is really good.This Message Edited On 09.24.07

astrel
October 28th 2007


2614 Comments


It is neat to know of another person who lives Arkansas on this website. I should get some Porcupine Tree albums.This Message Edited On 10.28.07

botb
November 24th 2007


9686 Comments


hatesong is a great listen imo.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy