Cake
Prolonging The Magic


3.5
great

Review

by Chris Jackson USER (177 Reviews)
September 4th, 2005 | 16 replies | 10,979 views


Release Date: 1998 | Tracklist


2 of 2 thought this review was well written

Cake has been around since 1994 when they released Motorcade of Genorosity. There next album Fashion Nugget was a big hit with songs such as "The Distance" and "I Will Survive". Next came Prolonging The Magic.

Members : John McCrea - vocals, guitar, organ, moog
Vincent Di Fiore - trumpet, backing vocals
Gabriel Nelson - bass guitar, mandolin, piano
Todd Roper - drums. percussion, backing vocals

Special Guests : Jim Campilongo - electric guitar
Richard Lyman - musical saw
David Palmer - keyboard
Xan McCurdy - electric guitar
Ben Morss - piano
Chuck Prophet - electric guitar
Greg Vincent - pedal steel guitar
Rusty Miller - Electric guitar
Tyler Pope - electric guitar

Cake is a very unique alternative rock band. The lead singer, John McCrea doesn't actually sing. He has a monotone voice and sort of speaks the lyrics. This may turn some listeners off, but certainly not me. Cake has sort of a relaxed feel, they also have clever lyrics and the music mixes well. There is a variety of instruments used throughout the cd and there are also nine special guests.

Satan is my Motor 3:12
Cake starts off with a slow steady song. The guitar is very addicting and catchy. This is one of those songs you can just sit back and sing along to. This is probably one of the catchiest songs on the album, but I still don't know why they are singing about Satan and cars. At the end of the song the trumpet comes in and then the song slowly closes.
4/5

Mexico 3:26
After the catchy tune Mexico comes in. This is a lazy country tune dominated by a twangy acoustic line. Don't get me wrong I can't stand country music and I love this song. This song features some clever lyrics and is quite depressing. The trumpet comes in toward the middle of the song, then the lazy country part comes in and closes out the song
4/5

Never There 2:44
Wow, we are getting quite a variety from Cake. McCrea sings the lyrics in this song and you might find yourself dancing because this song is funky and farily quick paced. Towards the middle of the song there is a groovy jazz influenced trumpet solo. The lyrics are quite intense and when you combine this with funk you get Cake at its best!
5/5

Guitar 3:40
There really isn't anything special about this track. The song has some good lyrcis and it's a little catchy, but overall there isn't anything special. This is mainly a guitar driven track but overall it doesn't really go anywhere. Note: this is the only song on the album that features the musical saw.
2.5/5

[b]You Turn The Screws[b] 4:00
This song opens with a nice piano part followed by a trumpet. After this 21 second intro the song turns into a hip/hoppish song. The lyrics are angry and are a rant about the music business. This is some catchy stuff but I think it goes on a little to long.
4/5

Walk On By 3:46
This is another depressing track. McCrea sings the lyrics on this one and it isn't pritty. The guitar playing is extremely simple and stripped down while the percussion delivers a formulaic rhythm. If your into depressing love songs than this is for you, unfortunately this is not my cup of tea.
2/5

Sheep Go To Heaven 3:48
This is one of my favorite songs of all time. The song starts out with McCrea singing about not being happy. The lyrics are very interesting and it just gets you pumped up. The vocals are lazy yet intense at the same time. The song goes into a mesh of a guitar, trumpet and an organ, then it's back to McCrea singing. The song fades out with McCrea chanting "Sheep go to heaven, goats go the hell."
5/5

When You Sleep 3:58
The song starts off slow and smooth. The lyrics are at there best on this song. The soothing smooth rythm mixes great with the lyrics. The backing vocals also add catchiness to this song and make it more fun to sing along to. This is a very interesting and cool feeling song.
4/5

Hem of your Garmet 3:35
This song rivals "Never There" for the most danceable song on the album. Unfortunately this song loses. The lyrics are as angry as they get on the album. There is a funky guitar part which is probably the best guitar feature on the album. The song is funky fun and has great harsh lyrics.
4.5/5

Alpha Beta Parking Lot 3:30
This song is "Guitars" twin. You will find yourself singing along but you will get more tired of this song each time you listen to it. Theres a catchy guitar and trumpet riff played in the middle of the song but it doesn't save the song from being a bore.
2/5

Let Me Go 3:29
Ah yes the cool fun beat of this song is very addicting. This songs lyrics are about plea for freedom within a relationship. Although the lyrics are sort of depressing this is song is extremely upbeat and features a very nice guitar line. The song ends with McCrea saying "Let me go" in a whimsical voice.
4/5

Cool Blue Reason 3:27
This song has depressing lyrics and has a depressing sound. Although I don't usually like demening Cake songs this one is quite good. After McCrea monotones there is a brief guitar solo with a mandolin playing in the backround. Then at around 2:50 some cool sounding instrument comes in(i'm not sure what it is) it sounds like and electronic moog. Although this isn't a very happy track I still think its interesting and I enjoy it.
3/5

Where Would I Be? 3:53
McCrea sings most of the time on this song. This is a very sad song. The lyrics are decent but the song isn't strong. The instruments seem to blend together well, but there is no instrument that stands out. Where would I be finally ends with a blend of guitar playing and mandolin strumming. I think this was a bad way to end the album.
2/5

Overall Cake didn't do a bad job. This is no Fashion Nugget or Comfort Eagle but this album does stand out well on its own. If Cake would of worked harder on a few tracks then this would of been great. If you are new to cake then I would check out the album Comfort Eagle but if you are a Cake fan and you don't have this than I would recomend this.

PROS:
Some good catchy tunes with good lyrics
Original cool sound
Is good to listen to when you want to relax or sing along to something

CONS:
To many bad or depressing tracks
Isn't good to listen to all the way through

3.5/5



Recent reviews by this author
The Dead C Secret EarthJohn Coltrane Lush Life
Crystal Castles Crystal CastlesUlaan Khol I
Four Tet RingerHarmonia Musik von Harmonia
user ratings (160)
Chart.
3.7
great

Comments:Add a Comment 
Zebra
Moderator
September 5th 2005



2647 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Since I forgot to add it onto the review the album art has a picture of a gray pig on the front and above the pig in big letters it says Cake.

Anyway any replies? This is my first review so give me some constructive criticism because I need it.

NEDM
September 6th 2005



1113 Comments


Dude, this was a pretty good review for a first. Maybe a little more info on each track and thats about it.

Great job man! :thumb:

Zebra
Moderator
September 6th 2005



2647 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Thanks for the feedback.

NEDM
September 6th 2005



1113 Comments


no prob, i felt kind of bad that you had no comments.

joey...
May 4th 2006



6 Comments


i could listen to cake all day (and eat it)

The Door Mouse
November 21st 2006



2092 Comments


I'm either gonna get this or comfort eagle

ihatemybass
February 3rd 2007



34 Comments


found this at the thrift store. Its preety great.

descendents1
June 25th 2007



702 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Ironic because that's how I got hold of my first Cake album about 9 years ago now. Actually, my first album.

CrazyFool84
January 5th 2010



1080 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

not a huge fan of the track/track but it didn't make it hard to read here or anything, so props. Really dig this band, see them almost like an avant-gardeish alt-rock band...might be a little extreame but I loved how this band really didnt seem to give much of a fuck and continued to throw whatever influence they could come up with into their music.

WatchItExplode
January 7th 2010



3227 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Cake fucking rules.

WatchItExplode
July 29th 2010



3227 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Band rules.

random
June 30th 2011



2261 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Cake is good.

xxm
March 10th 2014



205 Comments


@random Certainly

mryrtmrnfoxxxy
March 12th 2014



13003 Comments


satan is my motor

Digging: Electric Wurms - Musik Die Schwer Zu Twerk

WatchItExplode
March 12th 2014



3227 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Best Cake btw...

lyrics to When You Sleep are so random

When you sleep...where do your fingers go?
Do they play guitar in a latin bar?
Are they strangers or lovers, do they drive your car?



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy