Emmure
The Respect Issue


1.5
very poor

Review

by Kronzo USER (43 Reviews)
December 28th, 2009 | 12 replies | 2,710 views


Release Date: 2008 | Tracklist


1 of 1 thought this review was well written

The Respect Issue is the second full length album by metalcore band Emmure. In all honesty, what can I say about this album that I didn’t already say about the other ones I’ve reviewed? This is probably the most by-the-book metalcore album I have ever heard in my life. In fact, this is probably the most generic one in their entire discography. The notes played on this album are almost exclusively open notes and diminished ones, it still has way too many breakdowns for its own good, the bassist is missing in action (meh), the vocalist is still bland at best, and there is barely any notable instrumental work that might help the songs stand out more instead of blurring together like a big stale metalcore mess. Hell, I’m pretty sure the album is even structured almost exactly the same as their last one.

The album opens up with “Young, Rich, And Out Of Control”. This song is basically in the same vein of their other album openers (“A Ticket for the Paralyzer” and “Second Hand Smoke”) in which it is just a short breakdown designed to “pump” the excited Emmure fan up for his next unmeasured dosage of breakdowns, chugs, and shouts. It sounds exactly the same as the last two opening tracks, featuring some diminished and open chords chugging along with double bass pedals. When reviewing an album, you have to do your best to be objective and not let your opinions on a band’s other albums force a biased stance against them, but it really can be daunting for a listener when they are hard pressed to note many differences between the three openers.

Do I really need to give examples of breakdowns on this record? “Sound Wave Superior” is basically a breakdown for the entire song, there isn’t even a moment where they pick up the funeral doom pace found on “I Only Mean Half Of What I Don’t Say”, and “False Love In Real Life” is more or less a bunch of slightly varied breakdowns with really badly paced high pitched diminished chords and a sloppy guitar lead that lasts about 2 seconds. That’s right; almost a third of the album is 90% breakdowns. The rest of the album doesn’t decrease in breakdown-abundance or increase in quality much either.

Frankie, the vocalist, is pretty much your cliché brocore vocalist. He layers his screams with different kinds of screams sometimes to create really crappy “brutal” screams. His high pitched screams are pretty weak to be frank. For example, he ruined what could have been an almost half-decent song on “Chicago’s Finest”. When the guitarists finally decide to stop chugging and play a recycled melody instead, Frankie spoils it with his terrible wails. His low end isn’t anything spectacular either, it’s extremely monotone. In “Tales From The Burg”, he actually sounds like a dog when he uses his low end scream. The gang vocals in that song are also pretty weak. The only other trick he has up his sleeve is his clean vocals. His clean vocals mainly consist of cliché spoken word parts and a few shouts. They don’t detract from already subpar metal songs but they aren’t all that fantastic either. They have improved a bit from the previous records.

There are a few alright moments on this album. As an example, “I Only Mean Half of What I Say” has one breakdown with a mildly interesting drumming pattern. However, it doesn’t last very long before we get back to the usual drivel. Also, “Dry Ice” is a half-decent instrumental placed near the end of the album. It is nothing spectacular but it manages to be the best song on here by not having a misplaced breakdown or two (or five) in the middle of it even though I was half expecting one. Songs like “Dry Ice” have been done to death in metal albums though. “Chicago’s Finest” is one of the few tracks on here that seems like it could have been composed in a day instead of a bunch of half baked chugging patterns made up on the spot in the studio. Near the end of the song, the guitarist actually displays a bit of talent and plays a short solo that I would have liked to hear more of. However, “Chicago’s Finest” also just sounds like a slightly slower version of a song from their last album “Rusted Over Wet Dreams” at times because they both share a strikingly similar guitar melody.

Overall, this is probably the most generic album Emmure has made, and that’s saying a lot. There isn’t anything on here that they or other metalcore bands haven’t already done. With a few okay moments comes relentless chugging, bad screaming, and at least 50 breakdowns pissing on your intelligence every song. Although if you actually bought this album expecting some decent music, I’d say you don’t have much to lose anyways so you might as well do these hacks a favor and pop their CD of For The Fallen Dreams b-side tracks into your player. Don’t say I didn’t warn you though.

SUMMARY:

PROS:
- Guitar solo in “Chicago’s Finest”
- Dry Ice isn’t a bad track.

CONS:
- Way too many crappy breakdowns.
- Frankie is a crappy vocalist.
- Too many open and diminished chords (too much chugging).
- Barely any interesting drum moments.
- The bassist doesn’t do anything.
- Most of the songs sound the same.

OVERALL RATING: 1.5/5



Recent reviews by this author
Buckethead 3 Foot ClearanceBuckethead Empty Space
Buckethead It's AliveGlass Cloud Perfect War Forever
Eminem The Marshall Mathers LP 2Protest the Hero Volition
user ratings (685)
Chart.
2
poor
other reviews of this album
KilltheSwitch (1)
Listening to this is like aborting babies with your bare hands....

Brent Stephenson (1.5)
If you thought the only thing metalcore needed was more breakdowns, then boy has Emmure got an album...


Comments:Add a Comment 
sXeMOSHCOREhXc
December 28th 2009



21 Comments


how dare you. this is one of the greatest albums ever. gtfo.

sXeMOSHCOREhXc
December 28th 2009



21 Comments


i meant to press no but i hit the wrong button

sXeMOSHCOREhXc
December 28th 2009



21 Comments


you say its jeneric. how is it jeneric if there are ltos of breakdown huh? the braekdowns in this band are pretty original i think,.

Kronzo
December 28th 2009



991 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

: sometimes I worry about people...

TheSpirit
December 28th 2009



17626 Comments


lol jeneric

Digging: Venus Star - Nigredo Expulsion

shortone323
December 28th 2009



883 Comments


lol obviois troll

Kronzo
December 28th 2009



991 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

what an idiot... :S oh well. any thoughts on the review?

ToWhatEnd
December 28th 2009



3172 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

Holy crap Mewcopa your avatar is amazing! Albums sucks and lol @ jeneric.

burnafterbreeding
December 28th 2009



1466 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

So sick of trolls on this fucking site. Driving me nuts.

Great review though.

Homewrecker
December 29th 2009



231 Comments


I think Emmure bashing is the new making bands that suck lists.

Kronzo
December 29th 2009



991 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

thanks guys. They should maybe ban lists from new users till they post like 15 times or something. might cut down on the trolling? Just my thoughts.

Jaskolkaaa
January 12th 2010



330 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

...FTFD B-sides? aha, I don't get it.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy