Dream Theater
Metropolis Pt. 2: Scenes from a Memory


5.0
classic

Review

by Kaden USER (7 Reviews)
January 14th, 2005 | 302 replies | 47,591 views


Release Date: 1999 | Tracklist


20 of 28 thought this review was well written

Dream Theater-Scenes From a Memory

This is a concept album. It tells a story the whole way through, and the story is actually fairly intricate. However, I'm only gonna outline the basics of the story, if you want more details, listen to the album yourself.

1. Regression: Definitely a good opener. It starts with a Hypnotherapist putting the main character Nicholas into a trance. Eventually, acoustic guitar fades in. The music is simple, short, and to the point. Only acoustic guitar and vocals on this one, and it works great. 5/5

2. Overture 1928: The first instrumental song on the album. It has a really cool groove, and awesome solos. Not amazing and flashy solos, but cool nonetheless. If you don't know what an overture is, it contains musical themes from every song on the album, kind of like a table of contents. 5/5

3. Strange Deja vu: This song is pretty pop-friendly by DT standards, no real blazing solos, and it's only about 4 or 5 minutes long. It's really cool how it goes directly from Overture 1928. This song talks about Nicholas being hypnotized and whatnot. SDV is more of a straight-forward rockin' song than anything else, and I like it a great deal. 5/5

4 and 5. Through My Words/Fatal Tragedy: I'm gonna review these together, 'cause they're basically the same song. It starts off with a quiet piano/vocals melody, and then explodes into the hard-rockin' madness that is fatal tragedy. In this song, Nicholas learns about Victoria, his past life who was murdered. Fatal Tragedy is a totally groovy song, and it's got an amazing solo section. Actually it's the first trademark DT solo section on the album. 5/5 And it's amazing how it transitions into:

6. Beyond This Life: This song is more metal than anything so far. Its got a pretty cool riff that repeats through most of the song. The chorus and whatnot is far quieter and more calm than the metal fury found in the rest of this tune. The solo section is awesome, in this one they pull off solos that sound reminiscent of classic rock. This song deals with the murder mystery of Victoria. 4/5

7. Through Her Eyes: This is a ballad. It tells about how sad Nicholas is to hear of Victoria's death. It's slow, and it has a pretty melody, but not anything too special. 3/5

8. Home: This is a major METALRIFFIC song. It has an Egyptian deal going on at first, then it goes into heavy riffage that the whole family can enjoy. It tells about Victoria's love affair. It's extremely cool, however, I feel that the solo section drags on a bit, so I'll give it a 4/5

9. Dance of Eternity: This is the second and last instrumental song on this here cd. I really love it. It's completely random, and it has no structure at all. Jordan Ruddess pulls off a great 20's ragtime solo, and there's a mindblowing bass solo. This is one of the few DT songs where Petrucci takes the back seat (Even though his playing is still top notch) 5/5

10. One Last Time: This is the only song that leaves no lasting impression on me whatsoever. The lyrics don't seem to fit with the story as much. The music is good, but not as good as most of the stuff on here. It's short, and quickly moves on to the next song. I'd say this is more of a filler track. 3/5

11. The Spirit Carries On: This is probably my favorite song on the cd. It's completely orgasmic, and it has one of my favorite guitar solos ever. The lyrics are about the concept of reincarnation, which plays a major role in the album. I love it, and so should you:thumb: For all of its greatness and emotion, it gets a 5/5

12. Finally Free: The last song on the album is one of the longest, and one of the best. It wraps up the story very well (I won't ruin it for you) and all musicians are in top notch here. This song is pretty orgasmic, and I never grow tired of it. After a while, the music stops and you hear Nicholas, and the story ends with what happens when no music is playing. 5/5

This is probably my favorite album of all time. It's truly an experience to listen to it from start to finish. You have to read the booklet to understand the story, though. The soloing gets out of hand at several points, but besides that, it's amazing and mind-blowing. Everyone with ears must own this.

6/5



Recent reviews by this author
Dream Theater Falling into InfinityThe Dillinger Escape Plan Calculating Infinity
Dream Theater Six Degrees of Inner TurbulenceNine Inch Nails The Downward Spiral
Dream Theater Images and WordsYes Relayer
user ratings (2432)
Chart.
4.4
superb
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
Bartender
Emeritus
February 15th 2004



826 Comments


Excellent review man, and an excellent disc. A lot of people think DT are overly teachnical for the sake of being technical, but I just love them anyway.

3074326
February 15th 2004



20 Comments


I agree completely with the review. The only downside is the soloing.

One of my favorite albums. :thumb:

Bartender
Emeritus
February 15th 2004



826 Comments


In what way do you think the soloing is a downside? Theres too much of it, or its not very good or what?

3074326
February 15th 2004



20 Comments


[QUOTE=Bartender]In what way do you think the soloing is a downside? Theres too much of it, or its not very good or what?[/QUOTE]

Too much of it, it's awesome, but I think it takes away from the music in some places.

Kaden
February 15th 2004



222 Comments


[QUOTE=Bartender]Excellent review man, and an excellent disc. A lot of people think DT are overly teachnical for the sake of being technical, but I just love them anyway.[/QUOTE]
I don't think they are, in this album particularly they restrain their talent alot. There are too many solos in certain places, but they don't require as much shredding and whatnot as the others.

Bartender
Emeritus
February 15th 2004



826 Comments


[QUOTE=Kaden]I don't think they are, in this album particularly they restrain their talent alot. There are too many solos in certain places, but they don't require as much shredding and whatnot as the others.[/QUOTE]

I don't think they are either, but I remember coypu in particular used to say that although they were talented, they often went to too much trouble proving it.

Littlejohn
February 15th 2004



7 Comments


Very good review man. I love that album so friggin much.

Probably my favorite Dream Theater album. :thumb: :chug:

sting-ray
February 16th 2004



92 Comments


this is an absolutely amazing album.

4.5/5

stitches115
February 16th 2004



3 Comments


a personal favourite...

BirdsOfFires
February 16th 2004



92 Comments


One of my personal worst albums ever. Just can't simply see the appeal in it. Absolutely terrible album.

1/5

Littlejohn
February 16th 2004



7 Comments


[QUOTE=BirdsOfFires]One of my personal worst albums ever. Just can't simply see the appeal in it. Absolutely terrible album.

1/5[/QUOTE]

what is there not to like? Please do not say it is too technical, because they almost restrain their talent in this album so that it could possibly get some air time for all the little kiddies...

Kaden
February 16th 2004



222 Comments


[QUOTE=BirdsOfFires]One of my personal worst albums ever.[/QUOTE]
Come on, even if you hate it, I bet you can think of alot worse albums than this.

sting-ray
February 16th 2004



92 Comments


guys, an opinion is an opinion.

Littlejohn
February 16th 2004



7 Comments


[QUOTE=sting-ray]guys, an opinion is an opinion.[/QUOTE]

So if someone states their opinion, is it wrong to question them to explain it?

sting-ray
February 16th 2004



92 Comments


this is not a debate forum. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. You can reason with them, but keep in mind that this is NOT a debate forum.

BirdsOfFires
February 16th 2004



92 Comments


Yeah, I do have an opinion concerning this album.

I don't ask you to back up why you like Dream Theater, you've done that plenty well in your review. Just remember, it doesn't mean I'm closed minded or dumb because I don't like Dream Theater. I just find this album to be extremely processed, repetitive, and overall, frankly, completely devoid of any meaning or emotion whatsoever. LeBrie's vocals are so painful at times ("Strange DejaVu") that his lyrics lose any emotion they once carried. As theater theorist Kristin Linklater once said, "let the words have their own meaning", and Dream Theater could not be farther from this. Their complete devotion to technical wankery and "perfect" music has destroyed any connection they once had with their music, and in turn destroyed all emotion and meaning in their songs.

BirdsOfFires
February 16th 2004



92 Comments


And you ask if I could come up with worse albums? Oh, I'm sure I could. However, it's a pity to see 4 excellent musicians flounder like this. I'm sure they could either get someone to compose for them or find a job in a studio.

originalripoff
February 17th 2004



6 Comments


excellent review :thumb:
but how can you rate regression higher than Beyond This life"?

sting-ray
February 17th 2004



92 Comments


finally free is the best song on that cd IMO

savarious
February 17th 2004



14 Comments


nice review, probably my favorite album as well.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy