Edison Glass
A Burn or a Shiver



by Vegeta of Nazareth USER (21 Reviews)
August 21st, 2009 | 13 replies

Release Date: 2006 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A surprising and often overlooked feat.

While the popularity of Christian indie rock bands continues to mount from over these past few years, there is (at least) one group that seems to have gotten overlooked. Through all that hullabaloo, Edison Glass rode just below the surface trying to mark their impression. I'm sure the concept of an indie rock band formatting songs with the help from divine intervention may be tired by now, but with hooks choking out of every song while bantering with edgier influences, they manage to find a sound all their own while also throwing a minor switchup into the batch of Christian groups. Still on the underside of recognition, their fourth album A Burn Or A Shiver remains to be an advantageous and inspirative breakthrough for a band worth keeping an eye on.

Edison Glass’ general sound is not a foreign one in any sense. There lies within recognizably borrowed elements from fellow acts whether it be the shrilling background falsettos that can be traced back to Copeland, or the energetic poignancy exposed in the lyrics, related closely to Anberlin. Yet, they branch off just enough to have a distinguished sound by adding genres that have room for more technicality (they even throw in an occasional progressive riff). Through sing-along choruses following math-pop verses, even Silverberg's faint voice can hook you and steal you away from the jumpy beats. Prompting the math rock takeoff, the crashing drums and braided guitars introduce you to Edison Glass' lively and catchy ways in "My Fair One". Joshua Silverberg's voice is a nice compliment to the urgent sound being calm and collective but the background vocals give in having a more dramatic effect carrying over to the semi-peaceful chorus.

James Usher takes the more demanding route in his guitar playing by handling meandering guitar riffs over places where he could've easily slacked if he wanted, for instance over the snare drum flams in the intro of "Forever". The song cycles through a variety of styles from punky pre-verses and ska-like verses, but the chorus might be the spot that needs getting used to. Joshua Silverberg's frail voice can appear too flimsy for a listener that isn't as acquainted to this sort of style as others. Usher has the vital ability to entice you with different cries of his guitar lines. One moment, he can sound crooked spinning around in knotted patterns, and others he can literally glow. While the silvery blinks are revolved around in the finely built "Starlight", the transition is demonstrated mostly in the compelling glitz of a personal favorite, "In Such A State". The vocal lines double-team you while being threaded over signaling guitars which later turns into a colorful sparkle.

The melodies found on the album are easily consumed and flavorful for the most part. The members stay tight with each other but also have sufficient space to make things interesting. "The River" steadies itself leisurely, giving plenty of leeway for drummer Joe Morin to exercise his accuracy in more complex rhythm segments. This sort of feel isn't too far away from the one bands such as Minus the Bear have justified.
Joshua's voice is pretty dependable when harmoniously quivering, but as you will find every so often throughout the album, it will become almost too screechy when trying to kick up the drama. All is forgiven come the album's swan song, "When All We Have Is Taken". Joshua proves his skilled set of pipes by giving an emotive performance in the same wave of Usher's final guitar solo.

A Burn Or A Shiver is one great breakout album from a doubtlessly talented band. It sums up Edison Glass' motivational outlets in both the poetic realm and the musical realm. A bit edgier than indie pop but a bit friendlier than normal math rock, the band simultaneously cements their sound and their most beneficial album to date. For skeptics and atheists alike, don't let the Christian label put you off - though the lyrical theme is obviously binded in religious ropes, it comes open to anyone in a suggestive manner.

Recent reviews by this author
Shiner The EggBilly Boy On Poison Drama Junkie Queen
Sole and the Skyrider Band PlastiqueBear in Heaven Beast Rest Forth Mouth
Halford Halford III - Winter SongsJack Penate Everything Is New
user ratings (40)

Comments:Add a Comment 
August 21st 2009


i wanted to check these guys out a long time ago but i never did

August 21st 2009


You're putting out some great reviews Puddles.

This looks interesting as well *adds to huge list*

August 22nd 2009


Hayley Williams says to check Edison Glass out y'all

so obviously you know they have to be awesome

August 22nd 2009


Album Rating: 3.5

Thanks Dougie!

Indie, Stan, you should check 'em out. They're pretty solid

If you like Anberlin or The Myriad, you'll like these guys

If you like this, you'll probably love Time is Fiction

August 23rd 2009


Album Rating: 4.0

Dude, your review is great!

I first heard of these guys a couple years ago when my friend's band opened for them. They're fantastic. And you're so right - Edison Glass is WAY overlooked.

Once again, great review.

August 24th 2009


Album Rating: 4.0

Good record

August 24th 2009


Album Rating: 3.5

Yeah this is pretty great

Thanks theo, what's your friend's band called?

August 25th 2009


Well I like Anberlin, so I will probably love this.

September 25th 2009


i remember hearing these guys a while back and liking it, but never following it up >

July 24th 2010


Album Rating: 4.5

good review man. dude i bought this for 7 bux at a christian bookstore and yeah its better than i thought. totally wasnt expecting it lol

sounds sorta like envy on the coast with a little circa survive and some consider the thief.

October 1st 2010


Album Rating: 4.0

When All We Have is Taken is incredible.

June 20th 2011


Album Rating: 4.0

Bumping this because I still really like this album.

January 4th 2014


Album Rating: 3.5

criminally underrated

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy