Silverstein
A Shipwreck in the Sand


2.0
poor

Review

by ThyCrossAwaits USER (46 Reviews)
July 24th, 2009 | 8 replies | 3,024 views


Release Date: 2009 | Tracklist

Review Summary: No amount of duct tape can fix this broken album.

2 of 6 thought this review was well written

Silverstein will never be a truly respected band. Their pop-punk, post-hardcore sound makes them more of a communal guilty pleasure, which is why I unashamedly purchased their latest output A Shipwreck In the Sand at my nearest Wal-Mart. I snapped the disc in my CD player and this is what I heard:

#1: Silverstein are trying to be dark. Opener “A Great Fire” opens with somber piano before leading into a talentless screaming verse. The song oozes angst the band should have outgrown, like a four-year-old trying to act serious. This is what you’d expect from the band, and it’s easy to ignore for the sake of a decent song. The first single, “Vices,” is similar in style; lyrically shallow yet catchy enough to enjoy.

#2: I awkwardly enjoyed Silverstein’s last two albums, which surprised me. Being now jaded, however, I walked right into this album. Shipwreck even snared me for a moment with the promising first tracks, but afterwards comes off its opening high and…flat-lines. Starting immediately with “Broken Stars” and persisting to the final track is a blandness. The choruses are drained of any shred of worth, and the sorry screams add none of the intended maturity. Even on the anti-war cut “Born Dead,” I find that featured vocalist Scott Wade (formerly of Comeback Kid) detracts rather than adds to the music. His “punk” shouts are whiny and annoying, overshadowing Silverstein frontman Shane Told’s decent singing. On songs like “Their Lips Sink Ships” and the title track, the band makes an attempt at a As Cities Burn-like ambience, which comes off clumsily between heavier songs like “I Am the Arsonist.”

Silverstein have always been able to hide their post-hardcore mediocrity with quaint catchiness, but now that that has evaporated, the band’s weaknesses are exposed. Told’s singing is decent, but his screams are amateurish and overused. The guitars are simple and weak, and ultimately all merit to the band has dissipated. Believe me, I listened to the entire disc but no redemption materialized after “Vices.” I foolishly still held hope for the final song, “The End,” hoping for something similar to Anberlin’s brilliant “(*Fin).” But alas, it didn’t hold the same magic. So to me, it seems Silverstein have hit their stride. It’s mildly sad, but no tragedy.



Recent reviews by this author
Swans The SeerDarkosis Darkosis
Dragged Into Sunlight WidowMakerThe Killers Battle Born
Om Advaitic SongsGrinning Death's Head Golden Dawn
user ratings (601)
Chart.
3.6
great
other reviews of this album
Hogan CONTRIBUTOR (3)
A bitter and crisp divorce....

Kronzo (3.5)
It’s safe to say that this album will really surprise you after all of the negative hype. A Shipw...

mmbernie (4.5)
"Diversity really drives this concept album and keeps the music interesting and the story relevant."...

Michael Roberts (3.5)
Evidently broken is easily fixed....


Comments:Add a Comment 
ThyCrossAwaits
July 24th 2009



3051 Comments


wow, it didn't look this short when i wrote it...hopefully it gets the point across that this really wasn't good.

shindip
July 24th 2009



3536 Comments


Decent review. Sums up your opinion fairly well, although it could be a bit longer. Im not sure whether it is worth giving this a listen or not...

ThyCrossAwaits
July 24th 2009



3051 Comments


first two are good, actually. the rest is just boring as hell.

ThyCrossAwaits
July 24th 2009



3051 Comments


awww. I haven't gotten a neg in forever...

ninjuice
July 24th 2009



6760 Comments


I thought it was good.
I wouldn't do a review this short unless you have the neg protection of staff. (or you're really popular like a certain Office fan)
And no offense to Mike, but this is the kind of band that I expect to have fans riot/mass neg.

Douglas
July 24th 2009



9097 Comments


(or you're really popular like a certain Office fan)


lol ninjuice

Digging: James Vincent McMorrow - Post Tropical

Douglas
July 24th 2009



9097 Comments


Review is not neg worthy also

Comatorium.
July 24th 2009



4106 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I completely disagree with you on this, this is Silverstein's most focused and cohesive album yet. But to each his own i suppose. Decent review. Could be longer.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy