Poison the Well
You Come Before You


4.5
superb

Review

by poisonthewell242 USER (2 Reviews)
May 23rd, 2009 | 14 replies


Release Date: 2003 | Tracklist

Review Summary: As a result of their innovative instrumentation and solid vocals, PTW have created an album which will interest those who are looking for new ideas in the limited genre of hardcore.

Jeffrey Moreira - Vocals
Chris Hornbrook - Drums
Ryan Primack- Guitar
Derek Miller- Guitar
Geoff Bergman- Bass

As solid proof of a band that can mature and develop with every album they make, Poison the Well stands tall with their release of You Come Before You. Releasing the same mediocre or ordinary hardcore album may satisfy some bands, PTW has decided to keep a distance from competitors. They have decided to widen the hardcore genre and make a work of their own with touches of true originality.

From the beginning to end, PTW delivers an innovative sound of heaviness and melody that can take the listener away from the ordinary "first listen heaviness". The first noticeable difference on this album is the sound quality and mixing. Everything is heard, even the bass (for the most part). The guitars also have a sound you find on many other hardcore albums. The two guitarists work in a imaginative way creating a result that is there own. With a much more complex and highly developed tone, the execution of the guitars is much more effective. However, at some points the chaotic guitar bashing can come off as cluttered and messy, but only in a few points in the album. The bass could use some work with its potency, but at least it is audible throughout the album. The bass has some simple, but memorable and efficient moments despite its lack of vitality.

The drums are impressive as well. Chris proves that double bass is not always needed to create a heavier beat. He plays what matches the song and he is not trying to prove he is the best musician in the band. Whatever blends with the other instruments is what will make the album sound good as a whole. I’m sure Chris is capable in playing his instrument very well on the side, but he has decided to make sure he doesn’t steal the show by being too ostentatious.

To coat all the instrumentation, the vocals have progressed as well. The lyrics have become improved in the aspect of intensity and profundity in songs such as “Ghostchant” and “Meeting Again For the First Time”. The lyrics are backed up with Jeff’s true emotions, delivered appropriately for the content. The lyrics can be “emo” without sounding overdone or overdramatic. Jeff’s style of emotional lyrics is believable and adds significance to almost every song (besides “The Opinionated…” which contains no lyrics). The screaming from Jeff roars though the speakers and reaps all the sentiments from whoever is listening. His scream is not too strained and does not get too grating or annoying, depending on the listener’s taste. His actual singing is also a plus because it has definitely has gotten better since Tear From the Red. Fans of PTW will enjoy Jeff’s deeper style yells and polished voice on this album.

As a result of their innovative instrumentation and solid vocals, PTW have created an album which will interest those who are looking for new ideas in the limited genre of hardcore. An open minded album such as this can even reach out to those who don’t listen to hardcore music, which is why I would say it is a superb album. It has a few flaws, but they barely affect the greatness of this album.

Recommended Tracks:
Ghostchant
For A Bandaged Iris
Meeting Again For the First Time
The Realist
Zombies Are Good For Your Health
Crystal Lake


user ratings (1012)
4.1
excellent
other reviews of this album
korn_field (4.5)
...

Confessed2005 (4.5)
An album that breathes originality and demonstrates a band that, through experimentation, have produ...



Comments:Add a Comment 
KYZAR
May 24th 2009


513 Comments


Pretty short review but whatever good descriptions. Prob will get.

PanasonicYouth
May 24th 2009


7413 Comments


Biased much?

Waior
May 24th 2009


11778 Comments


Your username implied that this review would be much worse than it is.

Pos, for a first.

Phantom
May 24th 2009


9010 Comments


Biased much?

lolol

I only have The Opposite Of December and I haven't listened to it much, so I can't really comment.

PanasonicYouth
May 24th 2009


7413 Comments


I couldn't get into this much. Versions was much easier to listen to. But that was before I got an ear for harsh vocals. Might have to listen to this again.

Yazz_Flute
May 24th 2009


19174 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

How does this compare to The Opposite of December?

Si1v3RfaNg
May 24th 2009


823 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

opposite of december is like 10 times better in every way...

Asiatic667
May 24th 2009


4651 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Some cool tracks on this one

xNintendoCorex
May 24th 2009


1269 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

opposite of december is raw and abrasive, this is a much more complex and polished work. theyre almost by 2 completely different bands.



this is way better.



waior; someone could submit a review with just the name of the band and album, and you'd probably pos it.

scyther
May 24th 2009


1606 Comments


The summary is good, he agrees about hardcore's trap, a Neanderthal-esque fallacy.

Asiatic667
May 24th 2009


4651 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I sit acoss from you. why are we even here?

scyther
May 24th 2009


1606 Comments


The hardcore genre cannot be a progressive one without growing backwards into previous genres, as hardcore itself is actually a boundary rather than a core, the ultimatum of punk itself, and if punk went any further it would be metal.

poisonthewell242
May 24th 2009


12 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

sorry, i realized this review did come off extremely biased, but i was thinking of what would be a band that is suitable for a first review. i didnt know which album to pick, so i just went with poison the well. They are not my favorite band even if my name implies it. but, this is the first review and i appreciate the feedback.

and what i meant with progressive is that ptw is just experimenting with their genre and making new sounds by mixing other genres with hardcore

alachlahol
May 25th 2009


7593 Comments


the vocalist makes my ears itch.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy