Botch
An Anthology of Dead Ends


4.5
superb

Review

by Adam Turner-Heffer USER (38 Reviews)
July 27th, 2005 | 276 replies


Release Date: 2002 | Tracklist


Botch were the last great inspirators. Like At the drive-in, Refused, Godspeed you! Black Emperor and many more before them, no one knew who the hell they were until their demise. However, since ending, aformentioned bands went on to much more recognition. Botch, 3 years after this, their swansong e.p, still remain a very untouched apon band. Even though half are now creating the same metal genious within clever pop songs with Minus the Bear, Botch are still a very unheard of band.

Botch were creative wizards. As a result they are the proud fathers of "Math-Metal" where bands like Dillinger Escape Plan have now taken over. Where alot of bands kept topping their works each time, At the drive-in, Refused, Botch, although following the same path, had TWO records that changed everything. Their second and final album "We are the Romans" is what showed everybody why they were such an important band and how they switched from, mis-understood noise merchants to creative geniouses.

However, this, their final e.p, topped up everything they stood for in 21 minutes. It showed their abilites to create, minmalistcally ('Spaim'), how to create noise within acceptable pop boundaries ('Japam'), create haunting ballands ('Afghamistam') and how to top it all off with one huge agressive jam session ('Micaragua').

Botch were also a band who always wanted to come up with creative song titles. Previous albums saw them make songs like "John Woo" and "Saint Mathew Returns to the Womb". But this time, the idea was to make one word titles which still fit the obscure sound of Botch. The result, six tracks taking the names of countries and replacing the "M"s with "N"s.

Just remember, this is not an immediate album, mainly because Botch were never an immediate band, that was partly the point of their existance, to change things.

The Songs.

Spaim [0:14] 4/5

The e.p opens with a very odd sounding guitar riff. It's recording technices sounds very dated, which fits perfectly with the wierd, minimalism of the slid, harmoniced guitar riff which repeats itself 4 times. It is in fact, an intro to 'Japam'

Japam [2:57] 5/5

Now this is more like it. Japam is a perfect example of the bands ability to creative soundscaped, technical guitar riffs, in fairly simple songs and to effortlessly change its direction whenever it desired. At first listen, you're not entirely sure if you like this, then you find your self at the chorus and it's killer riff, it just draws you in closer and closer from that point. The breakdown? A simple slowed up version of the chorus with a clean guitar and drums, until it comes back into a huge cresendo of all instruments doing their best to make conventional noise, a task rarely achieved until this point.

Framce [3:40] 4/5

Once again at this point, you're not entirely sure if your liking it. The first half of this song is based around a repeating guitar sound, and riffs being played around it, this is all apart of the plan as it seems. It soon kicks into a heavy, almost death esq riff and then suddenly flies back into the more spacey sounds it was at before. It then returns with guitar riffs being slid from on end to the other, pushing the boundaries further and further like they always did best.

Vietmam [3:59] 4/5

Another song that starts of with top heavy riffs, making plenty of textures to make your mouth water. it's not until the breakdown and the scream along lyrics of "So show me your strength!" where it turns into from a good song to a great song. It turns into a spaced out, riff heavy, almost stoner-metal collision. As one guitar plays, slow, heavy, churned out riffs, the other sliding it's strings to keep you alert. Then it's suddenly buliding up and up again. A fairly simple riff gets louder, drums accompany it as it reaches its way to the top until. Stop. And it's back to a palm muted version of where you began. This is music that keeps you on your toes, and all the better for it. You can't help but imagine the experiance of this band would be like.

Afgamistam [6:56} 5/5

Now this is special. After the last 10 minutes or so of constant riffage, suddenly, the album is turned completly on it's head by this, Afgamistam, a 7 minute journey through a fairly mellon collie sound, which again just keeps building. It starts with a fairly simple Guitar and Bass line, slow and sad. The vocals are also much more conventional here, screaming is all but banished from this song, as this emotional exploration of music takes place. You can't help but wonder where this is going when you lsiten either, after teh rest of the album being a fairly apt representation of the word 'heavy' suddenly, we're almost in a sad ballad. Even the lead guitar on this song plays fairly simple lines that fit perfectly with what we're hearing. Suddenly though. The song just turns to cutting out all expected instruments, and it turns into a piano, synth and violin instrumental, later layers with samples of a man describing a story. Eventually the sound is drowned out by a muffled alarm and the sound that surrounds it. Suddenly a distorted guitar kicks straight back in making as much nosie as possible. Suddenly...

Micaragua [3:58] 5/5

...kicks in and about about 50 seconds of guiatr noise, The drums start a huge drum solo to kick this song off. Soon the drum solo ends, and we are left to enjoy, or rather hate, a very bitter, guitar heavy, thrash song. The guitar basically spends it time ringing out very low power chords, then changing them to high distored notes. Sometimes lyrcis weave in and out of the guitars, however the lyrics are fairly minimal in this song. It is, if nothing else a total head-*** rush, particuarly after the deep soul of the previous song, and was the only way Botch could bow out.

This is a stunning piece of work. To cram so much into an e.p is a task simply too tough for most, which is probably why Botch decided to end it this way. A special album by a special band who changed everything, wether you understand it or not is totally upto you.



Recent reviews by this author
British Sea Power Do You Like Rock Music?November Coming Fire Dungeness
Interpol Turn on the Bright LightsGodspeed You! Black Emperor Lift Your Skinny Fists Like Antennas...
AVAST! FaultlinesFucked Up Hidden World
user ratings (622)
Chart.
4.2
excellent
other reviews of this album
Braden378 (4.5)
Another great album from a great band...

hitman (4.5)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Electric Ocean
July 27th 2005


16 Comments


Haha, I like the song titles. The only thing I have by Botch is We Are The Romans and it's an awesome album , I've been meaning to check some more of their stuff out though and this sounds like it'll be awesome. Nice review too, by the way.

Justanothernimrod
July 27th 2005


478 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah, go for this its just as, maybe better than We are the romans.

cbmartinez
July 27th 2005


2525 Comments


"Framce" is such an awesome song.

Dancin' Man
September 1st 2005


719 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Great album. My only complaint - Math metal doesn't exist.

Justanothernimrod
September 4th 2005


478 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

ooh, interesting point :D

Arrakakaka
October 23rd 2005


685 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Just call it "technical metalcore".

Lil_Fraunk
February 15th 2006


5 Comments


So this is metal core...hmm

Justanothernimrod
April 19th 2006


478 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

if you like converge, dillinger escape plan or mastodon, then really this is up your street as none of those bands would have been the same without Botch.

Jack Wilson
November 12th 2006


313 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

this ep blows my mind. great review.

Cadaveric
December 10th 2006


152 Comments


Afghamistam has become one of my favorite songs ever. This ep is amazing. You can definetely still hear its influence in tons of modern bands

Confessed2005
June 17th 2007


3314 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

That and Japam are two of the band's best songs.

Justanothernimrod
June 17th 2007


478 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

maaan, I hate reading my old reviews back now a days.

This band are still amazing though.

And yes, aplogies they are a hardcore band who play technical metal, making them the original "metalcore" along with Converge, Poison the Well and Dillinger xoxo

Confessed2005
June 17th 2007


3314 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

True metalcore bands are amazing.

I'd classify the newer movement as Modern American Metalcore. Because tbh, most of those shitty metalcore acts are from America.

Some are very good however; look at Unearth.

Justanothernimrod
June 17th 2007


478 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah, "Modern Metalcore" definitely seems the most approrpriate these days, AND THERE IS SO MUCH OF IT!

Can't say I enjoy it as much but there's the occasional good egg.

canadapantsman
July 28th 2007


236 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

This is probably my favorite Botch material. Framce is amazing. its all amazing. plus, the vox are probably the most defined on this EP out of all their other stuff.

Cravinov13
July 28th 2007


3854 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I need to get this.

ForeverComesCrashing
December 12th 2007


15 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I definitely need to get this CD, only track I have heard is Aphgamistam, is it really as good as We Are The Romans?

IsItLuck?
Emeritus
December 12th 2007


4927 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Well some say it is, but I say it's not as epic. Like this is really good by itself, but I don't really compare it to We Are The Romans.

ForeverComesCrashing
December 12th 2007


15 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Honestly I loved We Are The Romans so much I can't imagine Botch making a better CD, none the less I'm still gonna go out and try to find this album somewhere

SynGates
December 12th 2007


2467 Comments


Some are very good however; look at Unearth.
Indeed.

I still need to check these guys out.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy