The Nightwatchman
The Fabled City


2.0
poor

Review

by Dr Dave De Sylvia STAFF
October 6th, 2008 | 55 replies


Release Date: 2008 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Morello's second outing as a protest singer is marred by dreadful lyrics and inconsistent songwriting.

While the bulk of Tom Morello’s post-Rage Against The Machine political activism has taken place away from the microphone, with Axis Of Justice (an grass-roots alliance formed with System Of A Down’s Serj Tankian) and various other left-wing protest groups, he has in recent years cultivated a folk singer alter-ego under the alias The Nightwatchman. Perturbed by the United States’ endless fascination with electing conservatives, Morello took his creation out on the road in the run-up to the 2004 election, and when Audioslave finally stuttered to a halt in 2007 he took the persona a stage further and issued his debut solo album, One Man Revolution. Barely a year later, he’s returned with a fresh batch of songs and a full band: where One Man Revolution was essentially Morello and his trusty acoustic all the way, The Fabled City sees Morello and producer Brendan O’Brien incorporate a wide range of acoustic and electric instruments, delivering a much more dynamic production as a result.

Morello’s political views have come in for much scrutiny in the past (The Fabled City, like all of Morello’s previous releases, comes courtesy of a major label- Sony BMG subsidiary Epic Records), but it’s not necessarily the content of his message or his credibility as a left-wing activist that marrs The Fabled City- it’s the fact that, for the most part, it’s hard to decipher any real meaning at all from his lyrics. First things first, despite his obvious overtures to Woody Guthrie, Morello the performer is much more in the Dylan vein than Guthrie: his deep, monotone drawl is effective in places, but just as often he slurs his speech and his words are virtually unintelligible. Compounding this flaw, Morello is a painfully average lyricist, relying on vague imagery and lazy clichés to put forth his message. While phrases like the mocking “don’t do as I do, do as I say” and allusions to good old working-class structures like mines, fields and ramparts might well appeal to his fans and fellow radicals, his lyrics are hardly evocative and rarely thought-provoking.

‘The King Of Hell’ evokes Chuck Ragan’s ‘The Boat’ with aggressive strumming and wistful soundscape guitars, but it’s a lyrical trainwreck. His mantra ”the devil is not the king of hell” probably sounded more profound in his head, while his presumed target, Mr. Bush, is unlikely to be troubled by his characterisation. Nor will he be too worried about Morello’s pronouncement, in ‘Midnight In The City Of Destruction,’ that ”I pray that God himself will come and drown the President if the levees break again.” A low point on any album, the sinister race-baiting subtext (“now they’ve cut the faithful from the trees”) is pitifully executed. It’s easy, it’s crass and it’s thoughtless, and in that sense perfectly sums up Morello’s approach to the album's lyrics. Though it has the misfortune of being the album’s longest track at almost five minutes, it is Morello’s only real foray into mean-spirited, destructive politics. Perhaps he is better off being hopelessly vague after all.

While the lyrical front suggests plenty more work to be done, the music on offer is far more promising. The album opens with two highlights in the title track and ‘Whatever It Takes.’ ‘The Fabled City’ is reminiscent of early solo Neil Young-meets-‘Sunday Bloody Sunday,’ stacking aggressive acoustic guitar chords on top of a sledgehammer drumbeat and reasonable picturesque lyrics: ”I’ve seen the fabled city / its streets are paved with gold / but an iron fence runs around it / its iron gates are closed.” For all its vivid imagery, however, it’s never entirely clear what he’s talking about and it certainly doesn’t lend itself to interpretation. ‘Whatever It Takes,’ the album’s showpiece, picks up the tempo still further, a funky blues boogie that wouldn’t sound out of place as a Rage Against The Machine acoustic jam, albeit with Morello’s typically deadpan vocal delivery.

The album’s third golden moment involves Serj Tankian reprising a role he should be very familiar with by now- performing backing vocals for a guitarist who fancies himself a singer. ‘Lazarus On Down’ is one of several songs to invoke Biblical imagery and easily the least intelligible of the lot. But whereas solo acoustic tracks like ‘Rise To Power’ (yes, it does sound like something Zach De La Rocha would say) and ‘Midnight In The City Of Destruction’ crumble under the weight of their own bullshit, as the truly vacuous nature of Morello’s lyrics are revealed by his dour, robotic delivery (or is it the other way around?), ‘Lazarus On Down’ swims atop a genuinely beautiful arrangement, aching in its simplicity. With Morello picking out a simple minor key pattern on acoustic guitar, the sullen mood is gently elevated with poignant piano strokes as Tankian wails in the distance. Credit in this case must go to Morello and O’Brien, whose smart arrangements throughout the album are generally the most interesting part of any given track.

The Fabled City reveals a number of things about its author, some good and most bad. As a lyricist he’s dull and unimaginative and as a singer he’s extremely limited: both facts detract considerably from the obvious passion he exhibits elsewhere for his music and his politics. On the other hand, The Fabled City delivers a couple of unique spins on the generally conservative modern folk genre- most notably ‘Lazarus On Down’- enough to suggest that he’ll continue to deliver material of worth, even if it’s not quite worth digging for.



Recent reviews by this author
And So I Watch You From Afar GangsAll Time Low Dirty Work
Linkin Park A Thousand SunsAdebisi Shank This is the Second Album
AFI Crash Lovefun. Aim and Ignite
user ratings (60)
Chart.
2.8
good
other reviews of this album
valiant (3)
Fabled city, not such a fabled album...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Essence
October 6th 2008


3585 Comments


Not your best, but better than most (other reviewers). Keep up the good work.This Message Edited On 10.06.08

bastard
October 6th 2008


3435 Comments


ugggh

I almost expected this to be good.

He was hyping it really well at least.

ninjuice
October 6th 2008


6760 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

I almost expected this to be good.

I still do. I'll wait to hear it to make a judgment.

Essence
October 6th 2008


3585 Comments


It's a shame, Morello is such a good guitarist.

bastard
October 6th 2008


3435 Comments


There's a track on here featuring Serj Tankian, how ironic.

Essence
October 6th 2008


3585 Comments


Yeah, I was thinking the same thing man. lol

Essence
October 6th 2008


3585 Comments


Oh, because he just posted a Serj Tankian review.

Essence
October 6th 2008


3585 Comments


No you don't. No you don't.

AtavanHalen
October 6th 2008


17927 Comments


Well, these albums are sort of a blend of Johnny Cash and Bob Dylan.

Yeah, not really. Johnny Cash made country music, and The Nightwatchman ain't country.This Message Edited On 10.06.08

bastard
October 6th 2008


3435 Comments


I am talking about Mr. Morello's voice and lyrics honey. He tries to sound like a revolutionary Johnny Cash in his vocal styling, while his lyrics resemble an incompetent Bob Dylan.This Message Edited On 10.06.08

Essence
October 6th 2008


3585 Comments


Well, if the singer was a hick, it'd work just fine.

McP3000
October 6th 2008


3941 Comments


Tom Morello's opinions are horrible, and his guitar style has always been hit or miss.

bastard
October 6th 2008


3435 Comments


you know what sort of sad;

Everyone sort of bags on Rocha for being rather preachy, and not being a true talent like Tom Morello; and yet his albums are actually better than these Morello records.

One Day As A Lion >>>>> Tom Morello: The Nightwatchman

AtavanHalen
October 6th 2008


17927 Comments


I am talking about Mr. Morello's voice and lyrics honey. He tries to sound like a revolutionary Johnny Cash in his vocal styling, while his lyrics resemble an incompetent Bob Dylan.

Yeah, I still disagree. His vocals more resemble Nick Cave's baritone, with a bit of Jakob Dylan or Bruce Springsteen husk.

McP3000
October 6th 2008


3941 Comments


they're still bad so why compare them

Jim
October 6th 2008


5110 Comments


ugh tom morello. i just don't get it. i really don't

ClearTheLane
October 6th 2008


990 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Tom Morello's opinions are horrible

Horrible? I bet you don't know anything about politics so don't call someone's who is well educated and intelligent opinions "horrible"

ClearTheLane
October 6th 2008


990 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

And even if this album was poor, Tom is a legend, and will always be.

HighandDriving
October 6th 2008


3288 Comments


The singing on this is so bad, I can't bare it.

I second the One Day As A Lion>this.

Golgoroth
October 6th 2008


1084 Comments


Horrible? I bet you don't know anything about politics so don't call someone's who is well educated and intelligent opinions "horrible"


Well his delivery of his opinions IS, dare I say, horrible. His opinion of not liking Bush is fine. "I pray that God himself will drown the president" is just a bad lyric and is either trying too hard to be provocative or is just immature.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy