Solefald
The Circular Drain


2.0
poor

Review

by Trey Spencer STAFF
September 23rd, 2008 | 21 replies


Release Date: 2008 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Black metal shouldn't have techno remixes... who'd have thought?

If we had to title our reviews I would name this one I Blame Fear Factory. I blame them for causing other bands to think that it’s ok to release techno/industrial remixes of their songs. I blame Fear Factory because their first remix album, Fear is the Mindkiller, was actually really good. That quality gave other bands the false impression that their remixes would be good too, when in fact it’s generally not true. In my experience, of all the metal subgenres to suffer from horrible remixes none have been as horrendously bad as the ones released by black metal bands. Apparently that fact was missed by the duo that make up Solefald because after six full length albums they have decided to get into the remix trend with predictably mediocre results.

While Solefald isn’t your typical black metal band they share enough in common with them to suffer from the same problems. The main problem is that most black metal bands derive their power from their atmosphere and epic arrangements, and those two elements are always the first to go when remixed. That fact renders a song such as “Sun I Call” from Red For Fire weak and forgettable. The slow build up of the original is entirely lost in favor of an electronic beat that runs from start to finish without any dynamics to speak of. In addition, the vocals have been processed into a thin, reverb-filled shadow of their former self and the black metal finale is non-existent. This issue of ruining the atmosphere and appeal of the original track through a blatant disregard for anything that made the original interesting runs rampant throughout this album.

The second problem is that a majority of these remixes lack any originality. They simply take a techno beat, layer some synth and then endlessly loop a few random elements of the original song. That formula seems to be standard operating procedure for metal remixes and it definitely is for this album. The songs that do deviate from that formula do so only by forgoing any relation to the original song, and I don’t mean that in a good way. I mean that there are songs on this album that are related to the original track in name only. These tracks lack any real identifiable elements from the original song, which leaves us with generic techno songs that happen to fall under the Solefald moniker.

One song that suffers from that lack of identifying elements is “Fluorescent (The Total Orchestra)” from Neonism. The high speed black metal of the original has been replaced with beats that alternate between hip-hop and drum&bass, and none of the original’s sounds or melodies have found their way into this version. If nothing else, the remix of “Fluorescent” at least has some redeeming musical qualities even if it had nothing in common with the original, but “There is Need” doesn’t even have that. The remix for that song has taken the original’s screeching guitar noise and added additional white noise, a few useless samples and stretched it out for an agonizing five minutes. It’s boring, and worse than that is it’s simply noise in its worse form. The only thing that stops this album from being completely horrible is the fact that the band was kind of enough to include a remastered version of their Jernlov demo as well.

Those that have been into the band for awhile will already recognize two of the songs on this demo from their debut album, The Linear Scaffold. Other than a rawer sound and a bit more aggression there is not much difference between them and their higher quality counterparts. The main draw here is that the demo has been remastered and there are also two songs that cannot be found on any other release. The original demo suffered from a thin sound that rendered the drums hollow and the guitars nothing more than reverberating white noise most of the time, but the remastered version has fixed that. The riffs are now identifiable and the drums, while still sounding dull, are at least solid now. This better sound now allows the songs that previously couldn’t be found anywhere else to finally be listenable.

While the original demo displayed hints of quality through its thin production this remastered version has finally allowed them to shine. “Motmenneske” is a violent song where Cornelius Jakhelln’s screech sounds like it is going to rip his vocal chords apart. I’ve never heard him scream more viscerally than on that song. There is also a very fast, proggy bass run that goes through the opening moments of the song and displays the progressive nature that would run rampant in later releases. “Sivillisasjonens Sloer” is an epic seven minute song with many different sections ranging from subdued, clean guitar interludes to raging black metal screeches, but it is definitely a little underdeveloped which is probably why it didn’t make it to their debut album. Despite the improved sound of the demo songs they’re still basically raw and primal and aren’t going to appeal to anyone that isn’t simply a huge Solefald fan, and therein lays the problem.

The problem is that this release is basically an album of two halves for fans of the band and a complete waste of time for the average listener. While the demo songs do sound better than they used to, no one is going to care unless they’re really into the band. Unfortunately, those fans are also going to have to deal with an album full of remixes that ruin the original at best and sound nothing like them at worse. For the average listener there is nothing special about the demo songs (get their debut album instead and you’re not missing anything) and there’s even less special about listening to techno under the Solefald moniker. Basically, unless you really love the band and want to hear the two songs that aren’t found anywhere else, this album isn’t essential to you or anyone else.



Recent reviews by this author
Kenn Nardi Dancing With the PastSick of It All The Last Act of Defiance
Meshuggah I (Special Edition)Cannibal Corpse A Skeletal Domain
Rabbit Junk Pop That Pretty ThirtyAnathema Distant Satellites
user ratings (8)
Chart.
2.6
average

Comments:Add a Comment 
Willie
Moderator
September 23rd 2008


16149 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

As for the Fear Factory blame, I have no scientific data or whatever to back up my blame. This is just the first metal band that I can think of that did the remix album thing. Since Fear Factory isn't exactly known for their creativity I'm sure someone else did it before them or it at least wasn't their own idea, but I'm blaming them anyway.

Digging: Mors Principium Est - Dawn Of The 5th Era

BallsToTheWall
September 23rd 2008


44805 Comments


Good review but techno black metal seems interesting enough to download.

Essence
September 23rd 2008


3595 Comments


Balls, if you want techno black metal, check out Psyclon Nine.

Good review Willie.

Should I check out this band's normal material?

BallsToTheWall
September 23rd 2008


44805 Comments


The Linear Scaffold is pretty sick jacktiger. The guitarist and main songwriter of Solefald is in a prog metal band with Arcturus members called Age Of Silence who are pretty cool too.


Willie
Moderator
September 23rd 2008


16149 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

I agree with Balls. The Linear Scaffold is a great place to start. Unfortunately the only review for that album on this site is kind of dumb (I'd ask for it to be deleted if there was another review for it).
It's kind of cool that someone decided to post reviews for all the Muse albums all at once. That's my new favorite user.

P13
September 23rd 2008


1327 Comments


lol metal remixes.
Good review, willie!

Willie
Moderator
September 23rd 2008


16149 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

lol metal remixes.
Some are good such as Fear Factory's "Fear is the Mindkiller" album or most the songs on "Remanufacture". Black Metal remixes are horrible. Have you heard the bonus song remixes for Emperor or the remix album by Arcturus? They're horrible too.

rasputin
September 23rd 2008


14555 Comments


Fantastic review. Probably not my thing at all.

Hawks
September 23rd 2008


35837 Comments


Yeah most of the time techno and black metal mixed sucks really bad. Just look at The Kovenant. They were a good symphonic black metal band turned into a fucking terrible techno band with a little bit of black metal influence.

Willie
Moderator
September 23rd 2008


16149 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Probably not my thing at all.
Very perceptive ;)
Yeah most of the time techno and black metal mixed sucks really bad. Just look at The Kovenant.
I'm talking more remixes of songs that were originally just black metal (or close). There are a few bands that integrated it into their sound with a little bit of success... check out Samael's album "Passage" to see what I mean.

Essence
September 24th 2008


3595 Comments


[quote=WillieFisterbut]
It's kind of cool that someone decided to post reviews for all the Muse albums all at once. That's my new favorite user.
[/quote]
Wait, when did that happen, and how the fuck did I miss it?

Willie
Moderator
September 24th 2008


16149 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

I just know that I posted this review, got ready for work, drove to work, logged on at work and there were four substandard Muse reviews posted by the same person.
Are you going to check out The Linear Scaffold?

Essence
September 24th 2008


3595 Comments


I suppose. I still have 30+ albums that I have.... acquired, so to say... to digest. I still need to give Songs for Insects a few more listens, as well as countless other albums. But, if you wanna hook me up, go for it.

Willie
Moderator
September 24th 2008


16149 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

I'll hook you up if you want it. If not, it's no big deal. What's the first part of your e-mail (gmail saves e-mail addresses but I have no idea which one goes to what person).

Essence
September 24th 2008


3595 Comments


Family Guy (without the space and caps)

BallsToTheWall
August 20th 2009


44805 Comments


Holy shit.....Red For Fire: An Icelandic Odyssey Part 1 is a badass fucking album.

Willie
Moderator
August 20th 2009


16149 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Part II is better.

BallsToTheWall
August 20th 2009


44805 Comments


Will be sure to get that. I strolled upon 1 on some random guys blog.

Willie
Moderator
August 20th 2009


16149 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

When you have the time read my review for the new 16Volt album. Even if you don't check that one out, read the first comment for a link to get their first four albums for free. Try the one I reccomended there.

Voivod
Staff Reviewer
June 4th 2010


6340 Comments


666 International is a badass techno black album.

I should check this.

Digging: Madred - Supersonic Brainfuck Overdrive



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy