Queen
Sheer Heart Attack


5.0
classic

Review

by FrddyBrnRgrJhn USER (12 Reviews)
June 21st, 2005 | 34 replies | 15,664 views


Release Date: 1974 | Tracklist


4 of 10 thought this review was well written

Queen was already gaining popularity in the U.K. and Japan with the releases Queen and Queen II and the singles Keep Yourself Alive and Seven Seas of Rhye. America was blissfully unaware of the sensation soon to take rock 'n' roll music down a path of flamboyance and artfully crafted guitar solos. That was until Sheer Heart Attack, the masterpiece from long before A Night at the Opera, A Day at the Races, and News of the World would take the top 40 charts by storm with Bohemian Rhapsody, Tie Your Mother Down, and We Will Rock You/We Are the Champions. Killer Queen, the U.S. single off of Sheer Heart Attack showed an American audience still marveling over the wonder of rock legends Jimi Hendrix and Led Zeppelin that rock 'n' roll didn't have contain lengthy drum solos and experimental guitar tricks. Killer Queen, along with the rest of Sheer Heart Attack, showed the world that pre-metal glam rock could indeed be combined with artsy operatic songs focusing on piano and falsettos rather than lead guitar (although guitarist Brian May certainly got more than his fair share in the spotlight on early Queen recordings).

Brighton Rock - 5/5
A bright carnival introduction sets the stage for this 5 minute rock epic. We hear voices coming from the carousel no doubt, a man whistling, and chimey music that tells us we're located at the Brighton pier. And what's that building up in the background? Could it be? It is! Electric guitar! Among the fun and games of a seaside fair in Britain, rock 'n' roll remains supreme. The guitar intro settles into a nice rock beat, allowing drums and bass to join. But to add to the confusion, we hear the falsetto of Freddy Mercury playing the role of both the man and the woman in the story of Brighton Rock. The lyrics then go on to talk about a vacation affair in Brighton before dropping into a rocking chorus. But Freddy's outstanding vocals will have to wait for 2 or so minutes. Brian May then gets a majority of the song to show his abilities as one of the greatest rock 'n' roll guitarists of the 70s, along with his ability to create layered symphonies of guitar, creating breath-taking music only Queen could make. The song then slams back into the chorus before ending with a few more licks from Brian May and a rocking closing.

Killer Queen - 4.5/5
Queen figured out early on the one musical trick to catch people's ears and make them laugh: Juxtaposition. Killer Queen shows Freddy's choir of clones hitting notes no other man has the bragging rights (or embarrassment) of hitting. However, rock is still the central goal even in a pretentious ode to upper-class. Brian May's symphony of guitars comes roaring in for an electric solo mimicking the classical training Queen was no doubt brought up on before fading into a mix of rock, opera, classical, and pop.

Tenement Funster - 5/5
Brian May takes over the vocals on this tribute to glam rock legend and T. Rex front man Marc Bolan. With new purple shoes amazing the people next door and rock 'n' roll 45s that are enraging the folks on the lower floor, the funster of the tenement is living a life that just about everyone knows, at least every glam guitarist from Britain. This ode to the good times of listening to T. Rex and angering landlords makes for a nice rocker. Just give find him an open car and he'll make the speed of light out of that place. You would do the same if you were young, poor and crazy.

Flick of the Wrist - 4/5
This exploding intro of upbeat show tune rock shows the intricate piano work of Freddy Mercury and the all-out rock riffs of Brian May before turning into a cheesy, overdone song about Satan (most likely a metaphor for the music business as indicated by lines like ‘reduce you to a musak fake machine’). Whether Queen’s trying to give a jab to their record label or if they’re just trying to make a goofy song, they succeed both ways, but barely. Flick of the Wrist is a decent song, but definitely gets old, like many of the show tunes being imitated, if listened to enough.

Lily of the Valley – 4.5/5
Here’s a nice little ballad about mythological quests, much like the concepty Queen II. This mini-epic even seems to tie in with Queen II, taking place in the kingdom of Rhye and involving tyrannous leaders and frail princesses. The one downside of this (although this is not an issue when the album is listened to straight through) is the flow from Flick of the Wrist to Lily of the Valley. On the original vinyl release, the fact that the last line from Flick of the Wrist carried over into the piano intro of Lily of the Valley was no problem. When being transferred over to CD, however, Lily of the Valley has to start with a line referring to absolutely nothing in the song.

Now I’m Here – 5/5
One of the best songs Queen ever recorded (in my humble opinion), Now I’m Here brings every classic Queen element together in a show-stopping, pre-We Will Rock You arena rock classic, complete with nonsensical lyrics about Hoople, Peaches, and America’s new bride-to-be.

In the Lap of the Gods – 4/5
This song has three purposes:
1. Show Freddy Mercury’s vocal range with glass-shattering highs and sort-of low lows (hey, they’re low for Freddy)
2. Show the effects gained without synthesizers (like the very cool circling effect the vocal intro has)
3. Scare the crap out of the listener who has just gotten into a classic rock mood from Now I’m Here. I guarantee that the first time you hear In the Lap of the Gods, your heart will skip a beat from the immediate shrill vocals or your money back.

Stone Cold Crazy – 3.5/5
I don’t typically like referring people to a cover of a song instead of the original, but in this case I think I might just have to. Please listen to the Metallica version before dismissing this song as a lame attempt at metal. Also please remember that this came out in the early 70s when people considered Led Zeppelin’s Whole Lotta Love some of the heaviest music out. Stone Cold Crazy is a decent pre-metal rocker. What hurts this song is the vocals. Freddy Mercury has a good rock voice. Brian May has a better rock voice. Why then did they choose to switch Freddy’s vocal chords onto the “operatic" setting for one of the heaviest songs they ever recorded? This is why Metallica’s cover does justice to this. If they had chosen the scratchy blues-rock voice of May, I would have given this song 5 stars. Unfortunately they didn’t.

Dear Friends – 3/5
Queen definitely has the capability to do a slow piano ballad. They’ve proven so on every 70s release they did. Lily of the Valley was a decent piano ballad. They didn’t need a second one, especially one like this, especially since it’s a minute long. A minute barely gives time to set up a ballad. The song drops out before any guitar solo comes in, which is essential to just about every Queen ballad.

Misfire – 2.5/5
Misfire is one of the lowest points on Sheer Heart Attack. The music is half-decent, but it’s the lyrics that kill it. Oh yeah Freddy, like we didn’t know what you meant when you said “Fill me up." Thank god music videos weren’t popular in the 70s; I think we would’ve had a gay porno on our hands if they had attempted to do a music video. The one high point of the song is the horn solo, but that can’t even save it.

Bring Back That Leroy Brown – 5/5
This song is simple. You either love it or hate it. Being from a family both appreciative of novelty songs and jazz, I lean towards loving it. However, just about everyone I know cringes whenever I play this song. The lyrics are goofy. The singing is goofy. But the music is hot! Queen could’ve been a jazz group if they hadn’t had the ambition to be an unclassifiable pop group aiming to do every genre possible. Musically, Bring Back That Leroy Brown is amazing, featuring solos from every musician, and good solos at that. I guess some people can’t appreciate a wild, fun spirit in music.

She Makes Me (Stormtrooper in Stilettos) – 5/5
For a complete opposite to the wild energetic feel of Leroy Brown, Queen slows down to one of the best songs on the album. Brian May gets the microphone this time, and shows his ability to sing a slower song. Although repetitive, She Makes Me is a great song that can be enjoyed again and again without getting old.

In the Lap of the Gods… Revisited – 5/5
The first Lap of the Gods was sufficient, but this reprise is a much better take on the original theme. For a slow rocker, this is one of the better ones. It’s mellow, but it still rocks out with a great guitar line and a chorus of “La La La"s that will have you singing along, at least if you have a couple beers in you.

I feel kind of bad for giving this so many 5 stars, but it really does feel like the underrated classic of the 70s that was left behind in the dust once Bohemian Rhapsody blew the world away. If you’re a fan of Queen, classic rock, show tunes, or just good music, pick this up. It’s essential.



Recent reviews by this author
Bright Eyes Lifted or the Story is in the Soil...Sigur Ros ( )
Queens of the Stone Age Lullabies to ParalyzeFranz Ferdinand You Could Have It So Much Better
Fountains of Wayne Welcome Interstate ManagersNine Inch Nails Broken
user ratings (496)
Chart.
4.2
excellent
other reviews of this album
Patoivanfer (5)
Ladies and gentlemen, may I present you...the best Queen album. Also the only Queen album without fi...

Brendan Schroer (4)
Despite the second half being a tad weaker than the first, Sheer Heart Attack is still a special alb...

jamest33 (5)
Okay, here's a dare. Plug your headphones into your iPod, turn it up to full volume and then put on ...

gblackman (3)
So their third album Sheer Heart Attack can be described as the following… Goodbye long and pointl...


Comments:Add a Comment 
masada
June 21st 2005



2733 Comments


Good review, but I don't think the album is a 5/5 at all. More of a 3.5 to a 4/5.

BludgeonySteve
June 22nd 2005



558 Comments


^ That's just your opinion. It's atleast a 4.5 in my books.This Message Edited On 06.22.05This Message Edited On 06.22.05This Message Edited On 06.22.05

FrddyBrnRgrJhn
June 22nd 2005



81 Comments


yeah i love sheer heart attack, it's one of their best in my opinion. all of their work before news of the world ties for first place in my mind (queen, queen ii, sheer heart attack, a night at the opera, a day at the races)

mercury
December 20th 2005



22 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

A brilliant queen album, which shows a change in style from the amazing yet at time insane Queen 2.

mercury
December 22nd 2005



22 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

and roger taylor songs termenant funster not brian may and Misfire was written by john deacon the bassist who has 5 kids so theres no gay influence. Its also johns first song writting atempt for the band so it aint that bad and with the classics he worte laster on (you're my best freind, another one bites the dust) we can forgive him.

Remial4
May 9th 2006



99 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Brighton Rock is the best opener out of all the Queen albums. And mabye you haven't noticed but the man is acually whistling the end of "Seven Seas of Ryhe". The "I like to be beside the sea" bit. So its attached to my favorate album ever. Queen II kicked the azzes.

Aumgn
May 28th 2006



12 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

their very, very best album! the variety of styles can only be compared with The Beatles or The Kinks. Amazing album!!

Iluvatar
Staff Reviewer
May 29th 2006



16083 Comments


Yeah, this doesn't have Bohemian Rhapsody, do I don't care.
Brighton Rock is one of my more favoriter Queen songs though, so yay for me.

Patrick
July 13th 2006



1891 Comments


I agree with your review of Stone Cold Crazy. In The Lap Of The Gods rocks.

freudianslipknot
December 17th 2006



803 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Queen are remarkable band. Not a bad review - just a couple of factual errors. Some have been noted. Now I'm here is not a nonsensical song - it is about Queen's first tour of America where they played support for Mott the Hoople - you work out the rest. Also the really high screams and vocals on Queen albums are seldom done by Freddie Mercury but Roger Taylor - this is true of the vocals on in the lap of the Gods. But hey, I'm just being anal - I was a major Queen fan in the 70s, I think I've still got a couple of fanclub mags lying around from those days.

vnoir
April 1st 2007



1 Comments


Quite well written i thought but as someone else said, there are some factual errors. For example, Misfire was in fact written by John Deacon, not Freddie.

Altmer
February 6th 2008



5652 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

This album rules. One of Queen's best.

MasterSan
February 29th 2008



113 Comments


If this album is a 5, then the Pope is Muslim.

Sure, it's good and all, but it's not classic. Hell no.

And "Stone Cold Crazy" is amazing.

MrShadows
October 29th 2008



18 Comments


Another factual error, "Tenement Funster" is actually sung by Roger Taylor.

Good Review, save the factual errors, but I think you over rated this album. It's a 4.5 IMO but a 'Classic' isn't just a brilliant album. It's more than that. Maybe not too much more. Since this album is widely over looked it can't be a classic.

Mindtraveller
February 13th 2010



13 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah! That's it, "Tenement Funster" is sung by Roger Tylor.

LokitheTrickster
April 30th 2011



23 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

In response to what you wrote about Hoople being nonsensical, it's actually a reference to the group Mott the Hoople who toured with Queen around the time this album came out. Also, Tenement Funster is Roger's song, though I see that someone already beat me to it.

TheArchetype
May 4th 2011



34 Comments


Stone Cold Crazy is one of my favorite Queen songs


Weed
August 15th 2011



161 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

awsome y'all

Spec
March 18th 2012



27107 Comments


Great album. Legendary band.

Digging: Rinoa - An Age Among Them

pissbore
January 13th 2013



9935 Comments


rules hard



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy