Secret And Whisper
Great White Whale


4.0
excellent

Review

by Mike Stagno EMERITUS
May 17th, 2008 | 96 replies


Release Date: 2008 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Great White Whale sounds somewhat like Stutterfly, but luckily, the vocals have improved tenfold.

There's something about Secret and Whisper, and I can't quite place it. The music sometimes feels as though it's been heard somewhere else (Saosin comes to mind), and there are definitely more impressive bands. Yet somehow the Kelowna based band manages to get the job done. Forming in 2006 when vocalist Charles Furney replaced ex-Stutterfly frontman Chris Stickney, the band changed its name to Secret and Whisper to differentiate the sound which the new group hoped to perform from that heard on Stutterfly albums, And We Are The Bled of Color and Broken In Pieces. Ultimately, Secret and Whisper's debut album, Great White Whale, isn't all that different from the material recorded with Stutterfly, but it's rather clear that the band has improved in several areas.

In an almost complete 180 from Stutterfly, Great White Whale's greatest asset is vocalist Charles Furney. Where Furney's predecessor was on the generic, whiney side, Charles adds a dimension to the music that didn't exist before. Furney's falsetto, resembling the talents of Saosin singer Cove Reber and at times, Darron Sudderth of Fair to Midland fame, is the most distinct aspect of the band's sound. Though Furney doesn't really experiment with his singing and usually stays within his niche, his powerful range dictates the direction in which the song takes, particularly in cuts such as "Vanishings" or "XOXOXO". That Furney's wails largely dominate the mix mean that Great White Whale's sound that is somewhat solemn, yet strangely soothing all the same.

Musically, though the melodic, poppy songs like "Vanishings" and "Spider Besider" are highly enjoyable, the most impressive songs on Great White Whale are the slower, more emotive tracks. "Werewolves" starts off in with a soft piano passage, before morphing into an organic, intimate electronic section which brings Templar's "Here We Go" to mind (speaking of which, what ever happened to Templar?). The song is completely chill, and gives the album a relaxing change in pace from offerings like the upbeat "You Are Familiar" or the metallic "Attacker". "My Actress", Great White Whale's other token ballad, is also makes use of some of the electronic ambience of "Werewolves" sporadically, but is more of a straightforward listen, and would likely make a decent single. Lyrically, both songs are a little on the iffy side, particularly in the last verse of "The Actress", which reads "Just for one nigh / You are my only / Just for one night / I won’t be lonely / You are my life / Your star burns bright", but even though they don't top some of "Spider Besider"'s (especially the chorus - "Iachoku, Iachoku / I'm not as sweet as I've lead you") each song makes for a rather enjoyable listen.

Great White Whale was a rather pleasant surprise for me. Having never heard either Secret and Whisper or Stutterfly prior to the album, I wasn't sure what to expect. But the Kelowna quintet has definitely delivered an excellent album, which holds up to some of the other stalwarts of 2008. The majority of the album's songs are melodic, up tempo alternative rock cuts, and manage to express a sound that, while gloomy, remains uplifting all the same. And while the same can be said for a variety of artists mulling around lately, not too many are as tight, interesting or as fun to listen to as Secret and Whisper. Props for that, guys.



Recent reviews by this author
Funeral for a Friend ConduitPropagandhi Failed States
Tycho DiveMegadeth Th1rt3en
Fair to Midland Arrows and AnchorsArch Enemy Khaos Legions
user ratings (318)
Chart.
3.6
great
other reviews of this album
David James Young (2)
The sincerest form of flattery....


Comments:Add a Comment 
PlayaHater24
June 4th 2008


24 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

This album was really good, I preferred the up tempo songs to the chill however. Also, who cares if the lyrics are retarded.

AmericnZero02
June 4th 2008


3343 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Probably my favorite album of 2008 so far.

DaveyBoy
Staff Reviewer
June 4th 2008


20857 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Canadian quintet Secret and Whisper have achieved a nice balance of post-hardcore, alt-rock & something a bit heavier on their immaculately produced debut LP 'Great White Whale'. Rapid-fire drums & an intricate dual guitar attack impressively back Charles Furney's captivating vocals, which lend a sense of mystery & anticipation to some cryptic lyrics. Some slower & more ambient tracks are more hit & miss, but are well-placed to lend this consistent LP a sense of cohesion. If anything, the major concern with SaW is their likeness to Saosin. Recommended Tracks: XOXOXO, Attacker, Vanishings & Great White Whale.

G3LLISTER
September 26th 2008


74 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

This is one of those album's in the vein of Saosin's S/T. It may not have much screaming (there's like two instances in the background) but it just feels so gosh dang hard with the guitar work. The entire album just oozes awesomeness... and stutterfly sucked (that's why they made S&W instead). I have like five favorite songs on here. XOXOXO, You Are Familiar, Spider Besider, Lovers, Great White Whale. This is one of those albums that stays strong throughout. Not perfect but damn near close.

xNintendoCorex
November 4th 2008


1272 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

i didnt dig this that much
it was a quick fix if anything, no lasting power

AtavanHalen
November 4th 2008


17927 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

I deleted the whole thing except for Spider and XO

Samwyze55
March 18th 2009


83 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

i love this album...but i agree, and lets face it, this album is nothing spectacular. it was great at making a first impression however. some of the songs on this record just meld together in a way that they don't stand out as well alone. and YES they sound a little unoriginal at times hahaha

but i think all these guys need to do is take the best aspects of their sound and explore it to its full potential. im still really looking foreward to their next album, cuz i think they have the potential to do way better.

treos
March 26th 2009


35 Comments


this band sounds so much like saosin that when a friend played it for me without telling me who it was, i was convinced that it was in fact saosin. the singer needs to find his own identity

Waior
March 26th 2009


11452 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Right, treos. The singer should have been born with a different voice.

Take it up with his genetics.

xNintendoCorex
March 26th 2009


1272 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

haha

treos
March 27th 2009


35 Comments


wow waior you obviously don't get what i'm saying at all... i'm saying he needs to find his own original style rather than use someone elses... guess that was over your headThis Message Edited On 03.27.09

Sunshinedust22
April 7th 2009


1 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

he doesn't sound like the Saosin singer at ALL, he's much too poppy. Furney sounds to me like a distressed wailing vocalist... it's very different and pretty epic.

I loved this album. I'm just going to go out on a limb and say it reminds me of Anberlin - mainly because of the high-pitched vocals.

Waior
April 7th 2009


11452 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Treos, dude, that's what his voice sounds like. He can't get a new voice. Is that over your head, or will I have to repeat that over again?

And Sunshine, this is a better album then I give credit for. I actually like it a lot. It's just painfully unoriginal.

MentalityOfA
April 30th 2009


1213 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I like the guitars in XOXO.

Dainslayer
May 6th 2009


9 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Absoloutly awsome band! Who cares if the lyrics arnt all that long, the drumming, guitaring and everything else in this album is wicked! When my mate downloaded this, i went out and brought it, im supporting them all the way, XO, You are familiar, Anchors, god i might as well write them all down, all wicked songs. ROCK ON DUDES!!!

Dainslayer
May 6th 2009


9 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Also i dont know why you say they sound like stutterfly either, cuz in my opinion they sound completely new. Stutterfly was more, dunno if heavyer describes it, but the fact there is no screaming/roars/etc (except for Great white whale) changes lots. The guitaring is definatly not the same (Im a guitarist 2), drums also have a new sound to them too, but still going hard on the double-kick to my taste.

cjgone
June 4th 2009


766 Comments


God.. xoxoxo is so damn catchy. :{

This song ruins my purely progressive music playlist. :o

Masochist
September 3rd 2009


8039 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Obviously not Uhhkris, but yeah...I think I'm a bigger fan of Stutterfly. Still, XOXOXO is to Secret & Whisper as September or Bitter Taste is to Spoken (who I would recommend to anyone who enjoys this band).

BrahTheSunGod
September 19th 2009


1279 Comments


end of "Great White Whale" gives me chills.

love the verses in "XOXOXO"

PanasonicYouth
October 1st 2009


7411 Comments


did not notice that anyone was talking to me
but uh
yeah
this is pretty good stuff
3.5 territory



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy