Sum 41
Chuck


4.0
excellent

Review

by Fox83 USER (9 Reviews)
May 3rd, 2005 | 265 replies


Release Date: 2004 | Tracklist


Who hasn't heard of Sum 41? Fat Lip was probably one of the biggest punk-rock singles of 2001. It had it all: Sneering lyrics of rebellion and humor, versus which could have been yanked from Mike D's sock drawer, a memorable chorus which attracted any pop punk fan skeptical of the new incarnation, and a hilarious video to wipe TRL's ass. Nothing Sum 41 has done since has quite compared with the success of Fat Lip - which only means one thing: they've gotten better. Their third release (yes, third - I will never dismiss "Half Hour of Power" as their first album), "Does This Look Infected" showcased Sum 41 putting more metal into the mix. More serious tones led to their pushing of the pop-punk lines to its limits musically. "Still Waiting," was the first single, and the catchiness prevailed. Gone was their smirky rapping and their immaturity only reached their home video collection, yet the MTV crowd picked up over half a million copies to date. Overall, "Infected" was a better album, but Sum 41 was still a work-in-progress.

Now comes "Chuck," a (suprise surprise) politically driven album which stays its ground in its ambiguity. For those of you that enjoy the perks of a backstory to their listening experience: The Canadian pop-punk quartet named their album in honor of United Nations peacekeeper Chuck Pelletier, who escorted Sum 41 safely to a U.N. compound when gunfire erupted outside their hotel during their humanitarian visit to the Congo in late May of 2004. Deryck told Chuck if they made it out alive, they would name the album after him. I'm sure it was inaudible girlish shrieking to Chuck's ears, and he is probably unaware at this time of his tribute, but nonetheless it's a pretty interesting concept. "How is the album, Andrew?" you may ask. "I need your opinion of the album because I cannot rely on the inconsistencies of my own musical tastes, Andrew!" you may declare. Relax...In advance, I give you Sum 41's "Chuck."

1. Intro - Slow guitar chords are strummed while layered with more intricate picking. As much as I would like to grade an intro, I refuse to let the rest of the album sway in my rating by letting a 46 second clip get included. I will incorporate this into "No Reason." So my rating for "Intro" will be declared N/A.

2. No Reason - The intro leads well into hard punching power chords and shouting by Deryck Whibley, "All of us believe/ That this is not up to you/ The fact of the matter is/ That it's up to me." "Hey, hey, hey's" line a decent drum pattern and a rhythm which could definetly be impressive live as well. The song is essentially placing responsibility on the population for making change when things are the way we would like. The chorus, I'll just say, is catchy as all hell. A great intro with nothing but what is expected of a hard rock/pop/metal/punk band like Sum 41. Driving verses build up to a chorus which you're humming to yourself after the first listen regardless of the fact that you can't quite remember the words. Sum 41 in a nutshell, my friends. It's a great song, and perhaps all that it lacks is ingenuity and the extra kick the boys need to progress to the next level. This is only the start of "Chuck," though, and it's quite the start. A-

3. We're All to Blame - The first single off of "Chuck" is an agressive thrash at our own faults for the American tragedy. Impressive approach lyrically, and the change ups from metal riffs and vocals into a soft, slow-tempo chorus. The chorus starts out with a simple guitar effect in parallel with Deryck's vocals into an anthemic, soaring composition of harmonies and rhythm. Extremely catchy, but borderline rip off. If System of a Down's "Chop Suey" had never been released then this could be leaning on originality. The change ups and tempos are very similar toward's Serj's and the boy's first big hit. Aside from these irritations, "We're All to Blame" is a great effort, and deserves its place on "Chuck." B

4. Angels With Dirty Faces - Deryck begins with somber vocals behind slow guitar strumming. Of course, this changes within the first 20 seconds. "Angels" is a song which attacks the corruption within oneself. "Obsession had begun/ Possessed by destruction," Whibley shouts. Short, hard, slightly different from what Sum 41 has done in the past due to the fact that there are quick pauses in which Whibley sings in utter silence for 4 seconds before the Steve-O and Dave pound into another fast-paced section. Much like "Asshole" off of their last album and "Never Wake Up" off its previous, "Angels" is their hard, relentless two minute song which always winds up within the first four tracks of a Sum 41 album. Call it filler, call it a developed pattern, but it manages to stand on its own. B-

5. Some Say - Deryck begins singing with a mid-tempo recording reversed (ala Somewhere I Belong - Linkin Park). When hearing this song, I'm reminded of "Handle This," off of All Killer No Filler. Same rhythm and structure, particularly in the chorus, with a few extra touches such as the verse arrangements. Unique effects and rhythm accompany Deryck's vocals, seperating it from its comparisons to past work. The funny thing is that it's also taking a similar tone lyrically as "Handle This," except instead of the chorus saying "Cause I will bring you down/ I don't wanna miss/ I don't think you can handle this," Sum 41 is declaring, "Think before you make up your mind/ You don't seem to realize/ I can do this on my own." Perhaps Sum could have taken a note from Metallica and called it Handle This 2, but if they did that they would have to call their album "St. Chuck," and actually suck balls. It's risky territory, and I'm ranting way too much. More than filler, less than exceptional, entirely acceptable. B

6. The Bitter End - Great intro. They've really got the metal influence shining through the beginning of this song. Fast foot work by Steve-O compliments the thrashing riffs of Dave. There's even some decent solo work by Dave throughout the entire song. This is a perfect example of why Sum 41 is one of the most popular punk rock bands, yet they are highly underrated. Coming and going before overstaying its welcome, "The Bitter End" grabs a hearty B

7. Open Your Eyes - This song began without taking me off guard. It was almost hard to discern the beginning of this track from a continuation from "The Bitter End," but Sum 41 decided to step it up. Deryck thrusts quick lyrics in a bouncy verse arrangement - almost reminiscent of Fat Lip but much, much harder. The chorus is, of course, simple and catchy enough you can just picture a Deryck Whibley head bouncing along the lyrics in a Karaoke bar. It's a hard-driven catchy peice of work. It's Sum 41. B+

8. Slipping Away - Very interesting and long overdue: Sum 41 has gone acoustic. Deryck's vocals are distorted in the intro which can be best compared to the Deftones. The chorus even bring strings into the picture. Catchy, somber, and it's different to say the least. A great effort by the band, but a little on the short side. Clocking in at about 2:30, the songs ends before it starts. It's as if the boys want to try something soft, but not enough to make a dent in their set list. Based on this song, that's a potential shame. B+

9. I'm Not the One - The verses made me nervous in this song. Deryck's vocals reminded me of the verse of Limp Bizkit's "Nookie," but of course there a driving, punk-like chorus which dismisses any notion of Sum 41 ripping off another genre (slight sarcasm). Decent effort, but nothing to bring up while playing poker with the guys. B-

10. Welcome to Hell - Quick punching song which leans more on the side of some of Sum's punk counterparts like NOFX, Lagwagon, or Pennywise. I was surprised to hear some quick finger-picking by Cone on the bass, and of course it's nice to hear a pure punk effort on this album. Short of noteworthy, yet packs a decent offering into this album. B

11. Peices - Another power ballad by the group. Surprisingly, some of the bands slower efforts on "Chuck," are the ones which have shined the most. "Peices" has some half-assed rhymes in it, but the simplicity of their catchy chorus is more concentrated by a new approach by the band, as well as some decent verses lyrically. Overall a commendable little number. B+

12. There's No Solution - Hearty filler in the guise of Linkin Park's "Numb." C+

13. 88 - Creative change ups and catchy everything. This is a preferred direction for Sum 41. Try and avoid nodding your head at the bridge. They accomplish a mainstream appeal while trying something totally different. Sounds a tad bittersweet, but entirely enjoyable. Great way to end the album, especially due to the jam at the end. This is a song which keeps me buying Sum 41 albums upon each release. A



Recent reviews by this author
Zebrahead Broadcast to the WorldEve 6 It's All In Your Head
Zebrahead MFZBLit Lit
MxPx PanicSystem of a Down Mezmerize
user ratings (1120)
Chart.
3.6
great
other reviews of this album
Acey (4)
Sum 41 can be a fun loving pop-punk band until you hear this CD. It is a side that some have never ...

punkbass0327 (3.5)
This album is certainly not your typical Sum 41 or pop-punk album. Despite taking on a heavier soun...

(4)
...

stke22 (3.5)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
bubs102
May 3rd 2005


2 Comments


ya, good ol' sums

slippedonknot
May 3rd 2005


1 Comments


as a metallica fan there is one way to see this album.
they have taken metallica and watered it down for teenagers listening pleasure, have you heard bitter end sounds an awful lot like master of uppets


insearchofsomething11
May 4th 2005


8 Comments


have you heard that no one cares?

Fox83
May 4th 2005


24 Comments


The beauty of the whole thing is that Sum 41 know they aren't Metallica. Listen to All Killer No Filler and compare to Chuck. Tell me which one you appreciate more. Out of that context, consider it a tribute. They know who the real metal figures are in the industry. You make a good point, but Sum 41 is what it is and that's how I'll judge their music.

gordie
May 4th 2005


1 Comments


bitter end sounds more like battery if you ask me

NEDM
May 5th 2005


1113 Comments


OMG they stole every good thing from metallica. The ripped the bitter end chord-for-chord from battery. its rediculous that sum41 can expect to make money. but i guess there are a lot of rock noobs out there.

ilovesk8ting
May 5th 2005


28 Comments


dude shut up they only sound like them on one fu ckin song, Sum's a good band and lets see you make it bigger than them


94_Hours
May 5th 2005


73 Comments


i really couldn't stand all killer no filler, but from what i heard off this album, i like it, except for Perfect or whatever it's called. Whenever i see that video i dont even wait long enough to see the song introduction

Society Sellout
May 6th 2005


292 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Average album from a band with potiential who doesn't use it.

Slash04
May 18th 2005


5 Comments


Blimey... Its spelt Pieces... Not Peices...

rustysurf84
May 21st 2005


327 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

personally, i think 88 is awesome along wit angels wit dirty faces.. overall good review and good cd

blinkrock182
June 8th 2005


4 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

this album rocks i think!

masada
June 18th 2005


2733 Comments


It was a decent review. This album is nothing more than decent.

lets see you make it bigger than them


I see comments like this all the time. Hey, maybe we don't want to push boring, cliched pop-punk into the world.

canadianrocker4
June 18th 2005


3 Comments


This is an awesome cd. Sum 41 is one of the best bands in the world. And they are Canadian! Its worth the money. BUY IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

(>dragon~guitarist<)
July 6th 2005


243 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

The biggest surprise album, I never heard it was coming out until I saw it in the store. Listened to it once and was actually surprised at their direction more towards metal. It was evident that metal influences were in DTLI, but in this one it is apparent. It really shows off their guitar skills too, listen to "The Bitter End", great song! Good review, like this album alot.

MultipliX
July 10th 2005


1 Comments


This is a very good album actually. I like their move from a punk "pop" band to a punk "rock". And also, this allows Dave to really show off his guitar skills. There are some songs I don't like though, like on their previous album. These songs though I doubt were ever meant to really be liked, but more of a piece of work to fill up remaining cd space. Tracks like No Reason and Noots still show their punk side, while The Bitter End and 88 show more of a metal style. Also, softer ballads like Pieces and Some Say show that even punks and rockers can be soft. Lol, great album overall.

NiGht/maRe
July 19th 2005


6 Comments


The song "No reason" is the best song of Sum 41 ever.

Damrod
Moderator
July 19th 2005


1093 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

This is not THAT much out of the ordinary, but for Sum41 this is quite a big and good step compared to their older material IMO. To hear through it over and over again this is not my cup of tea, but some songs are quite enjoyable.

I would say: 3.5/5 from me. A step above average, but not excellent or outstanding.

maun
July 19th 2005


2 Comments


@fox83
YOU'RE SO DAMN RIGHT ABOUT COMPARING WE'RE ALL TO BLAME TO CHOP SUEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
that issue was what made me stop listening to it ,it's pretty sad,but i can't take the song seriously...
(i haven't read the whole review,though,sorry)


AmericnZero02
August 6th 2005


3360 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

good album. best by sum41 i think. this is their first real "rock" and not "pop-punk" album. i think theyve really changed their sound. a lot better guitar and lyrics. Much more serious stuff being sung about. Even though the music isnt really catchy like the tracks off "All killer no filler" thats completely fine with me. as long as their making good tunes.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy