Pain of Salvation
Be


3.5
great

Review

by Med57 EMERITUS
April 24th, 2005 | 39 replies | 16,677 views


Release Date: 2004 | Tracklist


The Band: Daniel Gildenlöw (Lead vocals, Acoustic guitar)
Frederik Hermannson (Grand piano, Harpsichord )
Johan Langell (Drums, Percussion, Vocals)
Kristoffer Gildenlöw (Acoustic basses, Cello)
Johan Hallgren (Guitar, Vocals)

Released: 2004 (Inside Out)

Pretentious. Overblown. Genius. Unclassifiable. All of those words have been used to describe this album, the fifth studio offering from Swedish progressive metal band Pain Of Salvation, and quite frankly, all of them have their merits when used to describe this. Everything that makes prog fans drool, and prog haters reach for the off button is present on this album, from the Latin song names, through the incredibly dense concept, to the music which changes time signatures almost as often as it changes style. If anything, it’s this musical variation that really marks out this album. On their previous releases, Pain Of Salvation has been nearly unanimously classified as simply a progressive metal band, and rapidly developed a large following among fans of the genre. With this album though, which includes elements of folk, rock, metal, crazy amounts of effects, and sounds that simply sound as if they came from another planet, Pain Of Salvation took the step forward away from stereotype, and towards far greater respect.

The concept alone is so complicated that virtually nobody can categorically claim to know exactly what’s going on. The general idea though is this; God creates humanity in order to be able to understand himself, having gone through something of an existential crisis on the first song. Things immediately start going downhill from this point, with mankind rapidly seeking to take over everything it approaches, while characters are introduced who reflect all that is worst about materialistic popular culture. Forgetting their origins, God despairs of them, saying that he has no choice but to leave them to their own devices. Of course, the fact that he created mankind to understand himself, and then mankind greatly disappointed him, reflects on the role of God, as portrayed on this album. If you’re not confused by this point, then you’re about to be. After God abandons earth, and seemingly fades away completely, the world descends into chaos, culminating in a drop of the world’s population to 1.2 million people. The formerly materialistic “Mr Money" re-emerges, saying ironically that he’s reached his goal of being top of the hierarchy, only to realise there is no-one left for him to be above. As humanity fades away, the album ends with the seeming re-emergence of God, implying, in true progressive rock fashion, that everything’s involved in a never ending cycle. That’s the simplified version of my interpretation of the concept, which is actually told in such a way that makes The Mars Volta’s lyrics look comprehensible.

Anyway, now that we’ve got the basic details about the story of this album out of the way, how about we move onto the music? Opening track Animae Partus is a purely spoken word piece, with distorted voices (both male and female) representing God wondering how and when he was created. The final words of the song, “I will spend the rest of forever trying to figure out who I am", mirrors the uncertainty present all the way through the album, as well as the obvious: if God has no idea what he’s doing, then does humanity even have a chance? Deus Nova contains keyboards and distorted guitars playing under a mechanical voice counting down years and the numbers of people in the world at each of these years. Stopping at the year 2000 AD, the song then continues with far calmer vocals talking over ambient effects, saying that the world was created as an image of God’s mind, in order to teach him something. The first “real" song on the album is Imago (Hominus Partus), which has a surprisingly folksy sort of feel, with the lyrics initially being about the beauty of the earth, before lines such as “Give me of the forest, give me of the trees,
Give me anything as long as it's for me" show the nature of mankind taking over. The music for this song is very beautiful, and borderline medieval in nature, thanks to flutes and percussion that adds more layers to the music, allowing the building of a real atmosphere. Pluvius Aestivus is a five minute instrumental, based heavily around Hermannson’s keyboard playing, although the string section in the background increases the air of melancholy again, perhaps reflecting the disillusionment of God in seeing his creation already going wrong, in spite of his best efforts. Both very relaxing and beautiful, this is one of the easiest songs to get into on the album, with the climax where other instruments enter the music being even more remarkable.

Lilium Cruentus (Deus Nova) is definitely the angriest song so far, and reflects the fact that Pain Of Salvation has their influences firmly rooted in metal over any other genre. The drumming is clearly to the fore here, along with a chorus that is rapped more than anything over very punchy guitar riffing. The lyrics seem to reflect man now mourning on the brevity of life, and it’s probably telling that anger is the dominant emotion, rather than grief or something similar. As with a lot of progressive music, voices in the background with spoken word interludes add even more drama to the song, which makes it one of the most majestic on the album. After the anger of this song comes a chant, with deep voices pleading with the lord to help them over the sparsest of acoustic guitars which drifts along, never really leading the song. This is highly hypnotic, continuing for nearly four minutes, before the appearance of “Mr Money", and a girl. In a spoken word dialogue he first gets her name wrong, and then tries to get her to perform various “indiscreet" acts on him while he drives his car. It’s a crude pastiche of a certain type of businessman, but nevertheless allows the concept to continue flowing.

Dea Pecuniae serves as the centre point of the album in the eyes of many fans, weighing in at over 10 minutes long, and has a funk influenced intro leading into a slow, moody instrumental section while vocal interplay continues between Mr. Money and Miss Mediocrity over more vocals about his wealth. Something that should be noted about this album is the quality throughout of the lyrics. While a lot of progressive music relies on instrumental interludes, the lyrics on this album are undeniably the most important part of the music, including savage attacks on modern life. Just looking at lines such as “I Could have bought a Third World country, with the riches that I've spent. But hey, all modern economics claim that I deserved every single cent", it’s clear what the point which the band is trying to make is. That’s not to say the music loses anything though, as Dea Pecuniae has squealing guitars, and at times sounds as if it belongs on Broadway, so great is the drama that it conveys. The song also contains Mr Money looking at his isolation over dissident keyboards before the return of his self-glorification set over sheer musical jubilation. It’s a prog song that has everything, and as such is a clear high point of the album. Vocari Dei is a simple instrumental with spoken vocals from many people reflecting on their relationship with God, in the form of answerphone messages left for him. Again, it sounds like it could be very corny and overdone, but like so much of the music here, it’s strangely touching and effective. Maybe it’s because of the themes reflected are so regularly argued today, “Why did the two towers have to fall?", but this song is undeniably thought provoking, and another brilliant interlude.

With Diffidentia, the drama returns in full force. An opening heavy riff leads into more Patton-esque vocals with humanity seeming to renounce God, in lines condemning his “golden cage", while more of Pain Of Salvation’s roots come up with crunching metal riffs that would be worthy of some of metal’s biggest names. The whole atmosphere is one of drama and doom, before the voice of God comes in over a gorgeous piano part, wistfully singing about “drifting away" and pleading for help. The juxtaposition of the violent destructiveness of humanity and the simple elegance of God is a poignant one, and as the song continues to build, with string sections, soaring guitars and pure bitterness all being in the mix, it seems as if pure aural drama is coming out of your speakers. The final words of God (“I failed…we failed") ends the song, and with it a portion of the album. Nihil Morari is hugely introspective with another brilliant string section allowing more time for reflection after the majesty of the previous song. Reflections on what humanity has done, and how they have now run out of resources dominate the lyrics, before more massive riffing breaks in after about 2 minutes. The vocals become increasingly furious and desperate, as the narrator realises that humanity has grown too much, and that while people think they have attained a higher plane of being, most of the world can’t do the most simple things to ensure our own survival. As the music enters what sounds like a realm of pure chaos, a final countdown of the growth of mankind begins, culminating in 9 billion people by the year 2050. For the last minute and a half of the song, the singer repeatedly apologises for man’s lack of ability to see what the consequences of his actions would be, and for what they have done to the world. The implication is clear; some great disaster has struck humanity, ending life as we know it today.

Latertius Valete is largely instrumental, with one line of “2,060 AD: 1.2 million people" leading into hugely powerful music which owes more to Wagnerian opera than anything else. Omni then begins, with what sounds like news anchors discussing the horrific tragedy of what has happened to humanity over a funereal organ. This becomes continually more discordant while mourning voices pray for some sort of intervention, now that the worst has happened. In an ironic moment, Mr Money then returns, singing about how he’s at the top of the world, only to see life has rejected his species. Iter Impius is a very confused song, as you can imagine, with lush piano harmonies belying the content of the song, which is dazed, hurt and horrified. After previously talking about how all he needed was himself to prosper, Mr Money now seems to see that he is truly alone, and suddenly there is nothing he can do about it. It’s something of a wake up call, and leaves him resigned to his fate, accepting that he has nothing left to look forward to except accepting his role as the “ruler of ruin". It’s a point I’ve made before, but this song sounds like the penultimate act of an opera, rather than a song near the end of a rock album, and it says something that even by the standards of this album, this song vies for the most dramatic moment.

At this point though the album becomes still more complex. Military style drumming leads into Martius/Nauticus II, in which a character seems to assume the role of divinity, in the line “I am all, omni, BE!". This line leads into heavily syncopated drumming over an eerie sounding choir, making the music suddenly uncomfortable, as if pondering this latest development. A version of the folksy refrain from Imago then celebrates the absolute power of this character, singing jovially, “I am every forest, I am every tree", in what is a complete U-turn on basically everything that has gone before. The final track, Animae Partus II doesn’t clarify this in the slightest, with one ghostly female voice saying “I am", before a long pause ending in the voice of a young girl saying “there’s room for all people in God’s kingdom. Right by the mashed potato." Quite what you’re meant to make of this is anyone’s guess, but I’ll leave it to you to interpret.

This is not an album which you should get as an introduction to progressive music. This is not an album which you should get immediately after getting into progressive music. What it is though is not so much an album as a philosophy on life set to music. While that may sound pretentious, this CD refers to themes which people think of all the time, but yet remains vague enough to allow any listener to interpret it. The ending could mean many things; humanity rebuilds itself in the form that God wished, humanity rebuilds only to fail again, or even that humanity is rebuilt, only in the role of Gods ourselves. Having looked into this quite extensively I can’t categorically say which one, if any of these, it is, and it seems that no-one else on the Internet can either. The album has its flaws, such as at times it seems to be perhaps too dense, and there are moments that grate on it, but it’s definitely something that you need to hear if you like progressive music. It was criminally unnoticed by the mainstream media last year, but as soon as Broadway buys the rights to this, it’s no exaggeration to say we could have a musical more dramatic than anything Lloyd Webber has ever thought of on our hands.

Lyrics for the album can be found [URL=http://www.darklyrics.com/lyrics/painofsalvation/be.html]here[/URL].



Recent reviews by this author
Guns N' Roses Appetite for DestructionHanoi Rocks Two Steps From The Move
Savage Garden AffirmationTool 10,000 Days
Scott Walker TiltThe Pogues Rum Sodomy & the Lash
user ratings (286)
Chart.
4
excellent
other reviews of this album
OmairSh (4)
Pain of Salvation doing what it does best, throwing the progressive metal rule book out the window....

Jazzmaster (3.5)
Trop de concept, pas assez de musique......


Comments:Add a Comment 
br3ad_man
Emeritus
April 25th 2005



2125 Comments


Good band. I've only heard their debut but it's good stuff.

br3ad_man
Emeritus
April 25th 2005



2125 Comments


Since I can't edit, realy good review too man.

EdwardTheGreat
April 25th 2005



57 Comments


Great review, one of those that makes you want to buy the album, so in that sense, perfect review. I would have said its too long, but its a prog album, so its alright, as your explaining it.

Happymeal
April 26th 2005



330 Comments


I've been really curious about this album. I've never really heard anything from the band though. Good review, I will check them out soon enough.

Zmev
May 9th 2005



983 Comments


I'm listening to it, pretty good thus far, cheesy but so is all prog.

Dancin' Man
May 9th 2005



719 Comments


I've yet to hear this. I've heard some of their early albums and they're alright but not really my bag. Nice review as well.

kas_ofi
June 1st 2005



6 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Wow I ve just found that someone reviewed this prog Masterpiece. Congratulations Med for your awsome review. This album is a MUST HAVE as well as all other Pain of Salvation albums. Daniel is a very well educated person (he has studied more than 5 different "philosoph-ish" courses).

Distorted Vision
June 25th 2005



184 Comments


Good review. Love the album.

masada
June 25th 2005



2733 Comments


One of the best review I have ever read. Will you marry me?

I'm really now quite intrigued by this band... I need this now.


StormRider VS IronMan
August 29th 2005



6 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Honestly it is one of the best reviews I ve ever read of one of the best albums I ve ever heard.
Iter Impus is a stuning song.

TemperamentalGoat
November 12th 2005



87 Comments


I think genius is an apt description. I could say if evaluated based purely on the music, this would not rank so high. It would struggle to get a 4 from my perspective - so Med's 3.5 rating is pretty accurate by my count. However, upon reading the lyrics this has been *the* most engaging concept in an album that I've ever hit. And from the perspective of the album telling a tale, it is flawless. Most noticeable is the way the songs are "connected". i.e. Some riffs make a brief cameo appearance in more than one song, and the riff is shared between appropriately matching songs.

Anyway, it's one of my most played albums and gets a huge thumbs up.

halfdeadhippo
December 28th 2005



52 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

My comparison is that, musically, this album is similar to The Wall, in that it's not very strong or consistant at most parts, but that the lyrics more than make up for the other less complexities. Few songs stand out on their own, and you need to listen to the entire album all at once, while reading the lyrics, to fully appreciate it. I listened to it for the first time last night, while reading the lyrics, and it moved me. A lot of people would rate such an album a lot lower, simply because they're only looking for some cheap entertainment. I'm rating this album a 5, because it moved me on an individual level.

JamJar
April 9th 2006



16 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Amazing review of an amazing album. I personally love what the orchrestra adds to the music and the way it doesn't do a 'Metallica' and be primarily band based music but with an orchrestra, but Pain Of Salvation manage to make it an integral, important part of the music which makes tracks such as Martius/Nauticus II so amazingly musically dense. I really love this album and it is probably my favourite by PoS

eug008
November 11th 2006



97 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

At first I honestly didn't like this album, but after listening to it properly again, I'm really digging this abum. Can't wait to get the DVD, incredible album.

MeowMeow
June 19th 2007



662 Comments


I actually prefer this over TPE Part 1. Both a great albums, though.

jrowa001
October 5th 2007



8750 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

im listening to this right now and it has reminded me why i love this album so much. theres so many different emotions portrayed on this album thats mixed beautiful pieces of music and heavy parts. i think this is Daniel's best vocal performance

Altmer
June 20th 2008



5652 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

This isn't an album. This is a motherfucking thesis.

TheGreatD17
June 21st 2008



1141 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

This album is much more enjoyable if one imagines it's Mike Patton making fun of prog and doing a great job of it. This album highlights everything that is bad about a genre I love. The most important of which is that the quality of the music made should never be sacrificed in order to present some silly theme.

username345
June 21st 2008



594 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

I agree with TheGreatD17.
This is the most pretentious album of all time.This Message Edited On 06.21.08

FlawedPerfection
Emeritus
June 21st 2008



2806 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

This isn't good.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy