The Black Dahlia Murder
Unhallowed


3.5
great

Review

by rasputin USER (196 Reviews)
November 13th, 2007 | 25 replies | 6,489 views


Release Date: 2003 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A decent debut album that manages to overcome its array of flaws, to an extent.

3 of 3 thought this review was well written

The Black Dahlia Murder. Never have I had such a mixed bag of emotions revolving around a band. When I first heard of the band, the people that I associated with it were common scenesters who worshipped the likes of Parkway Drive, Unearth and As I Lay Dying. So before even listening to the music, I immediately filed the band away as generic garbage. This was short-lived however, because I got my hands on Unhallowed, and had a listen. I was instantly taken aback. Fast, furious, and in a way melodic, the album really got my attention. After a period of listening to it off and on, I concluded that although the album was initially good, and still provided a good listen, it did not have any real longevity or groundbreaking aspects to it. I still occasionally like to put on the album, but it isn’t in any danger of being worn out.

The first thing you’ll notice as the intro track ends and ‘Funeral Thirst’ begins, is that the music is very aggressive. Even so, the band still manages to incorporate a lot of melody in their songs whilst still sounding incredibly heavy. By melody though, do not expect there to be acoustic interludes, or mellow moments at all on this album. It is just straightforward beating your face into the ground, albeit in a melodic manner, similar to that of Slaughter of the Soul. What I liked most about the album was the dark and brooding feel it had. Even though it was void of atmosphere, it still managed to portray a sense of evil through the music.

Musically, the album has its highs and lows. A lot of the riffs are very good, and I really enjoyed a lot of the songs on here due to the catchy yet heavy riffing. The solos, on the other hand, are really simple. Other than adding a little more melody to the songs, the solos are not really anything spectacular. The bass, like far too much metal these days, doesn’t really do anything but add to the guitars. You can’t really hear it at all. All you’ll notice is how it makes the guitars and drums sound a lot deeper, and heavier. Finally, the drums are one of the good points of the album. I’m no expert on drums, but I was generally impressed with all of the drumming. Relentless blast beats, quick fills, it was definitely a major factor for me in liking this album. However, while the drumming is good, the vocals are a very hot topic. I’ve had many discussions with friends about the vocals, and there is a lot of variation in opinion of the vocals.

Trevor Strnad is the vocalist, and he has a unique approach to harsh vocals. He continuously switches between high pitched screaming and a very low growl throughout each song. To be honest, Unhallowed’s vocals will either make or break the album for you. A lot of people are put off the band because of the slightly different vocal formula, while others like it. Objectively, Strnad is decent enough, but there are definitely flaws with his voice. His high-pitched screaming seems to break every now and then, like on the track ‘Elder Misanthropy’ (during the chorus I think it was). However, other than the occasional break, the high pitch works well with the music. The real flaw though is with the low voice. I do not really mind it, and it isn’t so bad, but it really lacks any sort of grunt behind it. Compared to any other established death metal vocalist, the growls on this album are very weak.

In terms of the songs, there aren’t any real shockers on the album. Most of them are good, with a select few rising above the rest. The two songs I enjoyed the most were ‘The Blackest Incarnation’ and ‘Thy Horror Cosmic’. The only flaw about the songs overall is that it’s hard to distinguish between them. Before I had become reasonably acquainted with the album, I would not be able to tell which track I was listening to just from the song. So in that respect, you could say that the entire album is a hit or a miss. If you do not like a particular song on the album, you’ll most probably not like any of the others. Conversely, if you like a song, you’ll probably like the rest.

Overall, the album is definitely an enjoyable listen, and a good effort for a debut LP. I do think that this album is better than both of the following albums, Miasma and Nocturnal. In light of that, it probably isn’t a good sign to see that the band’s albums are getting progressively worse. Nonetheless, I enjoyed this album and I do recommend it.

Pros:
- Nice balance between aggression and melody
- Not really any ‘filler’ songs
- Unique vocal style

Cons:
- Solos aren’t anything special
- The vocals have prominent flaws
- It doesn’t hold interest for very long

Recommended Tracks:
The Blackest Incarnation
Thy Horror Cosmic
Contagion
When the Last Grave Has Emptied



Recent reviews by this author
Hoax HoaxHakaristi Hakaristi
Burial Invocation Rituals of the GrotesqueEibon Entering Darkness
Abe Sada / Sub Ordnance Redux / Organ GrinderIron Lung/Mind Eraser/HS/Scapegoat Brutal Supremacy
user ratings (875)
Chart.
3.7
great
other reviews of this album
Robinanimate (4.5)
Anniversary of a modern metal milestone...

SiKPsyko (5)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
rasputin
November 13th 2007



14516 Comments


I have been writing this review for over a week; I just couldn’t get it to a point where I liked it. I took breaks from it and wrote other reviews, and it’s slowly evolved to what it is now, but I’m still not completely satisfied with it. However, I feel there is nothing more I can add to it, so it’s going up.

Willie
Moderator
November 13th 2007



15877 Comments


That's funny... that's pretty much exactly what I wrote as a comment on the Abagail's Ghost review I just posted.

I'll vote...

Digging: Emperor - In The Nightside Eclipse - 20th Year Anniversary

Jim
November 13th 2007



5110 Comments


don't worry dude it's a nice review

rasputin
November 13th 2007



14516 Comments


haha, I just read it and it is exactly the same! :S
and no, I didn't copy it

but thanks guys, i don't feel as bad about it anymore.

Willie
Moderator
November 13th 2007



15877 Comments


I didn't include the part about taking a break and writing other reviews... but I did take a break and write my Bad Religion review... oh well, you're being too hard on yourself, the review is fine ;)

rasputin
November 13th 2007



14516 Comments


yeah, still bothers me slightly. I think my mind hasn't been set on it, becuase I'm just finishing off exams. oh well

Confessed2005
November 13th 2007



3314 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Funeral Thirst is the best thing on the album I reckon. That melodic solo is perfect.

LifeInABox
November 17th 2007



3708 Comments


...This Message Edited On 11.17.07

LifeInABox
November 17th 2007



3708 Comments


Funeral Thirst is the best thing on the album I reckon. That melodic solo is perfect.
Closed Casket Requiem and Thy Horror Cosmic are both better.

IMO this is their best cd, I know a lot would disagree. I really like the vocals on this album as well, much better than now. Good review nonetheless.
Everyone thinks this is their best album, so no, you aren't special.
Nocturnal is far better.

rasputin
November 17th 2007



14516 Comments


Nocturnal is far better
.
I disagree. I think that each album has gotten worse as they ahve been released (as I state in the review). Strnad's highs sound so bad on Nocturnal.

LifeInABox
November 17th 2007



3708 Comments


Nocturnal > Unhallowed > Miasma

rasputin
November 17th 2007



14516 Comments


No way. Unhallowed has so many better songs, and definitely a better sound overall. The intro to Thy Horror Cosmic is my favourite BDM moment.

TrojanWhore
December 11th 2008



752 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I'm with rasputin on this being their best, although I do enjoy Miasma and Nocturnal.

Phantom
December 11th 2008



8930 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Definitely the band's best album. Favourite tracks are Eldre Misanthropy, Thy Horror Cosmic, When The Last Grave Has Emptied and The Blackest Incarnation. Good review but I think its worth more than a 3.5

Hawks
December 11th 2008



34450 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I have to disagree with you guys. This is really good, but I think its worse than Miasma and Nocturnal.

Digging: Equilibrium - Erdentempel

withintention
December 11th 2008



297 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

this album is fucking nasty

Hawks
December 11th 2008



34450 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Check out Noctural too if you haven't already. It's easily their best IMO.

rasputin
December 11th 2008



14516 Comments


Trevor's vocals on Nocturnal are really annoying, and the album is really formulaic. This is far more flowing.

fireaboveicebelow
December 11th 2008



6837 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

yeah this is as good as they get

Hawks
December 11th 2008



34450 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Trevor's vocals on Nocturnal are really annoying

Trevor's vocals are pretty much the reason why I love Nocturnal as much as I do.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy