AFI
AFI


3.5
great

Review

by Buzz Killington USER (10 Reviews)
July 18th, 2007 | 9 replies


Release Date: 2004 | Tracklist


After releasing AFI’s spectacle of an album, Sing the Sorrow, the band felt they had to introduce their newer listeners their old sound and have their older listeners reflect upon the prominence of it. Even though they left out a handful of magnificent tracks, this is still a decent overview of AFI back in the Nitro days.

Quote:
Originally Posted by AFI
While we're really proud of our history and accomplishments we feel our career is really just getting started and feel slightly embarrassed by anything that hints at retrospect. There's plenty of time for that later when we're old. We'd rather move forward....
Odd thing to say, considering that it’s the albums like Black Sails in the Sunset and The Art of Drowning that virtually made their career.

Anyways, the retrospective opens up with a great song known as The Lost Souls from The Art of Drowning. It’s good, since it goes straight to the good music instead of having to listen to that pointless opener known as Initiation. Starts off with nice bass lines, with high-string guitar playing appearing and then it gets as speedy as hell. The next song following this one is another epic song from The Art of Drowning known as Days of the Phoenix. Though it’s not as fast-paced as the last song, it is still one of the best songs off of that album, even though it has some weird lyrics.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Days of the Phoenix
The figure on the bed, all dressed up in roses, calling… beckoning to sleep… offering a dream. Those words were mystical as purring animals…
Hmmm… so far, so good. The third song, A Winter’s Tale, is off of an EP that was released after The Art of Drowning, which was The Days of the Phoenix EP. At first, this song didn’t thrill me a whole lot, but then I decided to keep on listening to see the significance of this song. There is excellent backing vocals in the chorus as always. I don’t know why, but I admire the chorus.

Quote:
Originally Posted by A Winter’s Tale
Forever walking through December. Forever longing for a sign of life, a bringer of light. Forever wandering together through a world of violets.
And the song after that, which is not only an essential AFI song, but is also one of my all time favorite AFI songs, Totalimmortal. This song and Fall Children were from All Hallow’s EP. Fall Children starts off with a haunting guitar intro, but then becomes as fast as the first song.

One of the weakest songs off this album easily was The Prayer Position. No matter how catchy it may be, it is still one of the weaker ones off of this collection. This song could easily be replaced with Malleus Maleficarum. The place for weakest song hands down is tied between Lower It, A Single Second and Perfect Fit. I Want a Mohawk (But Mom Won’t Let Me Get One) is also one of the worst ones. It’s not lethal, but it’s really pushing it.
The funniest song would have to be Rolling Balls. As the title suggests, it is about, a guy who wants to bowl. He tries to join the men’s team, but he isn’t very good, so he tries to join the women’s team, but he has to… well, I guess that one shouldn’t be hard to figure out. This song is also one of the first ones they’ve ever written.

Overall

What’s appealing?

- Features classic AFI songs from the “Nitro” days.
- Great songwriting and musicianship (in several songs)
- A couple of songs are sort of comical (primarily rolling balls)

What’s appalling?

-Also features rather boring AFI songs that should’ve been replaced to represent old AFI better
-Could’ve been a better representation of old AFI



Recent reviews by this author
Cannibal Corpse The BleedingNovembers Doom The Novella Reservoir
Metallica Some Kind of MonsterOur Lady Peace A Decade
Opeth Ghost ReveriesAFI The Days of the Phoenix
user ratings (169)
Chart.
3.8
excellent
other reviews of this album
Robby Roark (The Sludge) (4)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
muchtallerthanu
July 18th 2007


648 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I should stop reviewing AFI, but I couldn't think of anything else to review.

emogangstascotty
July 18th 2007


472 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

This record is great. It highlights everything A Fire Inside has done before..the
commerical days. But I cant but help but feel let down. There are way too many
overlooked AFI songs, I wanted The Despair Factor especially. Coudnt they of thrown in
a free DVD? Would it hurt? I thought Days Of The Phoneix way a great flim clip, even
though it look very Janes Addiction "Just Because". But I still love it , a near future best
of, perhaps Davey?

A Winter's Tale and The Lost Souls are the best song here. A Single Second isnt bad,
eitherThis Message Edited On 07.18.07

muchtallerthanu
July 18th 2007


648 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Now that I read it, the review isn't that great. But my next one will be WAAAAYYY better! I swear!

plane
Staff Reviewer
July 18th 2007


6094 Comments


The quotes are awkward and make this review seem longer than it is. The review is just too short to justify much. You don't really describe some songs at all.

emogangstascotty
July 18th 2007


472 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Plus one of the songs, you wont be able to find on the older records. So this is like a rarities collection too (Who Said You Could Touch Me Anyway? is a special track off an earlier EP, Vinyl Only release!) So why isnt there more?!

muchtallerthanu
July 18th 2007


648 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

The quotes are awkward and make this review seem longer than it is. The review is just too short to justify much. You don't really describe some songs at all.

You're right.

and emogangstascotty, I recall WSYCTM? being on Very Proud of Ya as well as behind the Times.


emogangstascotty
July 18th 2007


472 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Oh. My mistake. But I wanted to hear Mini Trucks Suck as well on this record

tom79
July 18th 2007


3376 Comments


I thought this was FatPete for a sec with that avatar. Review was okay, basically what Planewreq said.

Digging: Wil Wagner - Laika

Cesar
July 18th 2007


2732 Comments


Totalimmortal is one of my all time AFi fav songs.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy