Pink Floyd
A Saucerful of Secrets


3.5
great

Review

by ValiumMan USER (17 Reviews)
February 5th, 2007 | 19 replies | 2,849 views


Release Date: 1968 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Syd half-gone, Dave half-in and no one really wanting to take over the main songwriting duties. The Floyd's 1968 sophomore album is a disjointed mess, but a good one at that.

4 of 5 thought this review was well written

You know the story. Syd Barrett, Pink Floyd's eccentric mainman went insane on acid and had to semi-leave the band in 1968, which forced the Floyd to recruit prettyboy (at the time) axeman Dave Gilmour as a backup, and ultimately replacement. With this bizarre lineup they, against all odds, recorded a followup to '67's psych-pop masterpiece The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, called A Saucerful Of Secrets. And it turned out way better than it likely could have, the band, now decentralized in terms of songwriting, trying out a variety of stlyes new and old, but succeeding for the most part, especially considering the circumstances. So no 60's equivalent of The Doors Of The 21st Century here, folks, but an extremely talented group of young musicmakers in search of direction (I wonder how today's Floyd would sound if they replaced Waters with Sting... yeah.)

A cool, drivin' bassline, some reverbed drums and a jazzy organ start out the album's first track, Let There Be More Light. Trust me, that thing really grooves acid-trance-remix-worthily for about a minute, before it unexpectly slows down and transforms into a considerably dark, trippy rocker, one of the new directions pursued on this album, and the one the band would largely settle on later. Until Dark Side Of The Moon, that is.

Track two, Remember A Day is keyboardist Rick Wright attempting to emulate Syd's trademark psych-pop style. It's quite a pleasant, mellowishly dreamy song, but it never reaches the eccentric playfulness of a Barrett original. This is actually one of the parts where the album coulda sucked major ass, but didn't at all, which is one of the things I find amazing about it, as I said.

Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun, the third song on 'ere, is my personal album favorite. Another dark, trippy number, but almost ridiculously mysterious and introverted this time, written by Roger Waters. Dark, fluent bassline, spacey organ, tribal drumming by Nick Mason (a criminally underrated drummer, BTW), almost whispered vocal, and Syd's there too, playing a jerky, wah-wah drenched guitar. Real nice. It's got all sorts of weird bells and various other spacey LSD noises in the background too, which makes it even nicer. There's live versions of this that are better (by which I mean freakier) than this studio recording (check out the version on the Ummagumma live disc), but it still kicks yo mama's dirty white ass.

The following song, Corporal Clegg, is the second worst on the album though. The first of Waters' many "I-hate-the-army-cos-my-daddy-who-I-didn't-even-know-died-in-WWII" songs. Seriously, can someone stop this guy from whining? Clegg is a "comical" attempt at the whole thing though. The song has a dumb military-kinda-beat and some hilarious marching band bits. Waters tries out a "bitterly comical" sorta vocal, but terribly fails and Gilmour does a half-decent Jimi Hendrix impersonation on his amplifed six-string instrument. Other than that, the lame "repeat till fade" outro is dragged out way too long. Uhmmm... thanks, ol' Rog.

When the title track comes in after that, you notice how disjointed this album is. I mean, why on earth would you want to follow up a ***ty-ass faux marching song with an 11-minute avant jazz inspired dark psych suite of doom? I have no idea, but the song kicks, that's fer sure. It opens up with some dissonant organ and strange reverbed noises that sound like Sun Ra. After a couple a minutes, a tribal drumbeat and dissonant piano come in and the thing still sounds like Sun Ra (is that guy an acknowledged influence on the Floyd, cos I wouldn't wonder if he was...). If I'm not mistaken, Syd lays down some cool noise guitar here aswell. It ponders along that way for some time, repetitive tribal drumming and occasional outbursts of guitar/piano, before diminishes into a single bass-laden, delayed noise, which transforms into some churchy organ chords. Seems as if Rick Wright is kinda the leadman here. A (fake?) choir emerges from the depths of sound too, giving it an even more churchy feel. It ends aprubtly, which is the only downside of it. If they included some cool outro and slow fadeout or something, I would've liked it even more.

Unfortunately, the next track is the album's absolute low point. See-Saw, another psych-pop song by Rick Wright, but horribly pretentious this time. It feels like he wanted the song to switch between several different sections or something, but it never really goes anywhere. Instead, it frustratingly jerks around between several boring melodies and very goofy-sounding noise sections. Come on, Pink Floyd, you just proved you could make really cool avantgarde noise in the last track, and now that? Upon listening to this album as a whole for the review, I was glad when it was over, despite its relatively short length of only four-and-a-half mins.

Saucerful ends with Jugband Blues, Syd Barrett's last officially released song (if I remember correctly) for the Floyd. Sounds a lot like his solo stuff in terms of melancholy and insane lyrics, but it's more elaborately arranged with whistles and flutes and the like and a Yellow Submarine-esque, extremely weird horn section. The ending almost makes me cry. You can really feel how he's on the verge of nervous breakdown and acid-induced insanity. Oh well, there goes a coulda-been genius.

After all, A Saucerful Of Secrets is a very inconsistent and disjointed, but surprisingly good album, that's worth a spin every once in a while.



Recent reviews by this author
Om PilgrimageKing Crimson Larks' Tongues in Aspic
Fennesz Endless SummerBattles Mirrored
John Coltrane Interstellar SpaceFaust Faust So Far
user ratings (999)
Chart.
3.7
great
other reviews of this album
necroscope86 (2.5)
One of the few instances in their career where Floyd truly were just average....

Hernan M. Campbell STAFF (4.5)
"Remember when you were young, you shone like the sun."...

Rocksta71 (4.5)
...

guitarded_chuck (4)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Electric City
Staff Reviewer
February 5th 2007



15690 Comments


NOT FALL OUT BOY NEG!

Digging: Nmesh - Dream Sequins® [AMDISCS]

ValiumMan
February 5th 2007



493 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

LOL.

Patrick
February 5th 2007



1891 Comments


Good job. With Floyd being one of my all-time favorites I feel guilty not owning this.

MrKite
February 5th 2007



5020 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I want this and Piper really bad.
Great review, too.

Zebra
Moderator
February 5th 2007



2647 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Jugband Blues is the greatest Pink Floyd song in existance. This album definitely has its boring moments but it's still got some great stuff on it.
Nice work on the review, you basically summed up my opinions.

Intransit
February 5th 2007



2797 Comments


Pink Floyd has always bored me. Good work.

mynameischan
Staff Reviewer
February 5th 2007



17911 Comments


good review

Danger Bird
February 6th 2007



54 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I love this album. The last few minutes of the title track are sublime.This Message Edited On 02.05.07

Metalhead312
February 6th 2007



2 Comments


sorry forgot to say good review ( not sorry about fall out boy they are crap )

Jim
February 6th 2007



5110 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

You have this ability to describe songs very well, and not many people can do that. I struggle, to be honest.
To me, this is what Sputnikmusic's about. It's not necessarily about perfectly conceived reviews, and an eye to stand alongside professional music sites in terms of content, but rather a community driven site where the reviews are written by fellow members for fellow members, with their own unique humour and style, which is what truly makes it stand out against others.
I said more than I really wanted too =/
[quote=review]but it still kicks yo mama's dirty white ***[/quote]
:lol: You won't see that on Allmusic :thumb:
/votes

ValiumMan
February 6th 2007



493 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

A big thanks to everyone here, especially bahamut. Looks like you got a (whole) lotta love for me and I appreciate it. I guess I'll be sticking around this site for some time more.

Anyway, that thing about Fall Out Boy sucks. I didn't even know their new album came out the day I wrote (and submitted) this review here. Seriously, I couldn't care less about all those new pop-punk/emo/post hardcore bands. Hell, punk got really shitty as of late.
But what can you do?

any14doomsday
February 6th 2007



678 Comments


good review, each one you do seems to get better. I dont have this album, but I have been meaning to get it I think I have the incentive to now.

ValiumMan
February 6th 2007



493 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Oh well, I'm still learning how to do this stuff, but I found a style I like now and I'm exploring it a bit more with every review I write and I feel a lot more secure now than when I wrote my first few.

Actually, my, like, first 4 reviews on this site are utter crap. Hell, I feel kinda ashamed for them now, but whatever. :D

Anway, thanks a bunch for the positive feedback (once again).

AnyColour74
February 6th 2007



1054 Comments


For the most part (except for the Corporal Clegg hating), this was a good review. This was another one of those on my hit list, but you've summed up my feelings about the album well. Nice work

Jim
February 7th 2007



5110 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Remember a Day is my favourite here :smoke:

MrKite
January 25th 2008



5020 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Man, Jugband Blues is good. Looks like I have to look into Syd's solo stuff.

CoRpSeSlAyEr
January 25th 2008



855 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I might as well, all of his songs while in PF were just amazing.

KILL5
October 27th 2011



429 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

best album ever?

KILL
April 24th 2012



67023 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

y cant we reach the sun

Digging: Picchio dal Pozzo - Picchio dal Pozzo



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy