Elliott Smith
From a Basement on the Hill


4.0
excellent

Review

by Andrew H. EMERITUS
January 15th, 2005 | 257 replies | 27,355 views


Release Date: 2004 | Tracklist


Elliott Smith - From A Basement On The Hill

Elliott Smith is a man who needs no introduction. From his work on the Good Will Hunting Soundtrack, to his first two albums, to the brilliance of "Either/Or" and "XO", Elliott has always delivered solid records. Elliott's music has never been groundbreaking, nor does it try to be. Instead, Elliott delivers honest, from the heart music that never shows off and always pays tribute to his influences.

There are two types of records that can be released from an artist after they die. Firstly, there are the collections of rare songs that just seem to pop out of nowher. Secondly, there are the albums that the artist was working on before they die (eg Jeff Buckley's "Sketches For My Sweetheart The Drunk"). This record is the latter. While Elliott didn't completely finish this record, it still feels finished, as if he were still alive today. This album is very good and is up there with his best. However, this album is a lot more electric than "Either/Or" or "XO"

Coast To Coast - The track starts out with some nice sounding strings, although if the track is at low volume, they just sound like noise. Then the drums and guitar enter in with a catchy riff. Elliott plays electric for this track. There is also a piano in here. Elliott's voice is excellent along with the guitar and piano work. The song is a good, solid, straight foward pop song. Excellent lyrics too, a great line from the song is "I'll never be good enough for you". A great way to open the album and although not one of the best of the album, still very good.
4.1/5

Lets Get Lost - Starts out with just a high acoustic riff, Nick Drake style. The bass comes in and out throughout the song. It's a great track, very poppy and catchy, Elliott's voice is the highlight of the song. The track's lyrics are also excellent, the most memorable line is "to find some beautiful place to get lost". The song is pretty much entirely acoustic and that's exactly the way is should be. A very well done track, probably one of the album's best tracks.
4.5/5

Pretty (Ugly Before) - The best track of the album so far. It's a slow, fairly emotional track. The verse trades off between Elliott singing and some country style licks on the electric guitar. This may be one of the first really great Elliott tracks where his vocals actually aren't the highlight. The best part of the song is when Elliott sings "I felt so ugly before, didn't know what to do" and then a pretty little piano riff comes in. Excellent stuff.
5/5

Don't Go Down - The verses of this song are pretty cool. They include some drums and arpeggios on a distorted electric guitar. The best part of the song is when everything cuts back to just a light sound and Elliott is left singing "don't go down, stay with me". A good song, not really one of the best tracks on the album, but still a good track nonetheless. It's pretty slow but quite loud, especially in contrast to the previous song.
4/5

Strung Out Again - This song is kind of strange sounding, while not being strange at all. The verses are quiet with some electric guitar and Elliott singing some pretty high parts. The choruses go loud with a descending distorted slide from the electric guitar. Not bad, but it doesn't really suit Elliott's voice. This song would be better if it was just acoustic.
3.7/5

Fond Farewell - Very catchy song and one of the best on the album yet. Elliott sings the song extremely well. The verses include acoustic guitar with some clean electric leads. The best part of the song is the chorus where Elliott sings "it's just a fond farewell to a friend". Very catchy with some extremely good melodies. Very good guitar work as well. Elliott recorded some very nice vocal harmonies with himself for this song. A true highlight.
5/5

King's Crossing - The song essentially starts with some very good chordal work on the piano. The piano then cuts out and then some wierd sounding electric parts come in along with some vocals doing "oohhhs", and of course Elliott's voice. The verse is really not all that special, but the chorus is amazing. Elliott's voice is the best part but all the music fits in around it and makes it something extremely special. Very catchy and inspirational at the same time. This is an absolutely breath taking song, the instrumentation and the vocals just work together in perfect harmony. The verse is good as what it is because it makes the chorus even more special. The song ends with Elliott singing "don't let me get carried away".
5/5

Ostriches and Chirping - Pretty random. Just the sound of some birds (surprise!) chriping. It should have just been added onto the last song as it doesn't really do anything. It just feels odd.

Twilight - This is arguably the best song on the album. It's also arguably the best song Elliott has ever done and it's definitely one of the best songs released in 2004. The song uses a simple chord progression and it's the raw emotion in Elliott's voice that really makes the song. During the song, some very nice strings come in. The song has the best lyrics of the album so far, with great lines such as "she's a sight to see, and she's good to me, but i'm already somebody's baby". Just a brilliant song. Absolutely amazing.
5/5

A Passing Feeling - It would have been next to impossible to follow "Twilight", but this song still isn't bad. Elliott's vocals are good, especially his falsetto parts. The guitar riffing in it is nice, but the nicest part is the piano. The drummer does some nice fills in this track as well. The outro is quite good with some good instrumentation. The song isn't bad, but maybe wasn't the best choice to follow "Twilight".
3.9/5

Last Hour - A stripped down song with just Elliott and an acoustic guitar. Elliott's vocals are beautiful and the guitar riff is very nice as well. Elliott does some excellent falsettos and the high guitar parts are amazing. Great stuff, one of the best tracks on the whole album.
5/5

Shooting Star The song starts with a Muse type sound and a guitar part that sounds like "Minerva" by the Deftones. This song is a much more electric song than the last few. It has an electric guitar riff as the main riff and some fairly loud drumming. There are some nice piano parts in the song but the bass line is the best part. It's just very fitting. The piano is probably the second best part. Elliott's voice is good but it doesn't suit this type of song as much as it suits slow acoustic stuff or acoustic rock.
3.7/5

Memory Lane - A cute little song, it sounds like something you'd expect to hear on a children's program. The guitar riff is very nice along with Elliott's vocals. He has some very good parts on this song. The tempo is quite fast, with some excellent lyrics, the most memorable being "your little house on memory lane". Great stuff, one of the best songs on the album. It's only Elliott's voice and acoustic guitar but it's very, very good.
5/5

Little One - Lovely song. Starts out with Elliott vocals and piano, then some acoustic leads come in. There are also some strange effects in the background. The song is pretty slow without much other instrumentation which makes it excellent. The song stays pretty much the same all the way through without much instrumentation added at all through it.
4.5/5<

A Distorted Reality Is Now A Nessecity To Be Free - This is probably the best of the really electric songs on the album and a great way to end the album. The song starts with an almost jazzy sounding riff. The first parts of the song are just acoustic, but then it gets into a more electric sound. The lead riff of the song is very good. Elliott's vocals are again the highlight of the song though. It's quite happy and an excellent way to close the album, by leaving it on a high note. A funny part of the song is where Elliott sings "...don't give a fu*k" and then a really high falsetto echoes "fu*k" in an airy and happy sound.
4.7

Wow. What a great way to end Elliott's careear! His death was a tragic shock for so many people, but this album celebrate's Elliott's life in a way that's better than anyone could have expected. The packaging is excellent, the art is wonderful and the songs are absolutely amazing. They may not be up to the standard of "Either/Or" or "XO", but remember that Elliott didn't actually finish the album before he did. This is a wonderful way to say goodbye to Elliott.

Goodbye Elliott, we love you and we miss you. RIP.

FINAL RATING: 4/5



Recent reviews by this author
White Suns Waking in the ReservoirPurplene Purplene
Quiet Steps Think AloudGrinderman Grinderman 2
Jakob DominionNorma Jean Meridional
user ratings (560)
Chart.
4
excellent
other reviews of this album
Chris Maziejka (5)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
br3ad_man
Emeritus
October 23rd 2004



2125 Comments


Sorry about the huge picture of the album cover.

Kaden
October 23rd 2004



222 Comments


Awesome review. I just bought this yesterday (along with Mastodon's Remission) and it's the only Elliot Smith album I have, so I haven't gotten much chance to listen to it yet. I expect good things now.

And if I don't hear good things....I'm coming for you Brad.

lilsolsman
October 23rd 2004



14 Comments


Nice Nice review.. but i don't agree on everything..
i think Strung Out Again deserves a higher rating.. especially because he sings the line 'i know my place, i hate my face' so so pretty..

i wouldn't give Fond Farewell that high.. mainly because i don't like the intro.. but that's my opinion apart from that song you did a perfect job rating 5/5's

and i laughed when you said Memory Lane was a 'cute little song' .. that might be the most depressed song on the album.. sentences like 'isolation pushes past self hatred, guilt and shame' or 'i do what people say, and lie in bed all day, Absolutely horrified, I hope you're satisfied' make it a not so cute little song..

apart from those minor points i agree with your review totally.. nice review.. album defintly deserves 4.5/5 or higher...

lilsolsman
October 23rd 2004



14 Comments


[QUOTE=br3ad_man]Sorry about the huge picture of the album cover.[/QUOTE]

i like that huge picture

OrbDragon
October 23rd 2004



152 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I'm going to get this soon...I vastly enjoy his other material...so this should be no disappointed. I just have to wait till something goes wrong...because I'm too upbeat these days to absorb new Elliott material...I'll buy this on the next sh*tty day to come.

The man was really really talented...it seems the great ones always die too soon.

mabba
October 23rd 2004



7 Comments


ah, I really wanted to d a review on this one. But, yours will suffice. This is one of the best albums I've heard this year.

RollerQueen
October 23rd 2004



209 Comments


Got it with JEW, love it. Favourite: "King's Crossing". I like it more than "Twilight". Excellent review and the rating is fine. Either/Or is still my pick of the ES lot (unless Roman Candle is better - it's the only one I don't have yet) but this is a mighty fine album.

Iai
Emeritus
October 23rd 2004



3553 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I don't have any Elliot Smith albums. :upset: Just a mish-mash of mp3s.

Excellent review. I should be picking this up when I get paid - hopefully, Either/Or and XO will be on sale by that point.

pixiesfanyo
October 23rd 2004



1222 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

The best part for me personally is when he brings up "The White Lady" in King's Crossing. It's a great reference to his S/T. Nice review.

br3ad_man
Emeritus
October 23rd 2004



2125 Comments


[QUOTE=Kaden]Awesome review. I just bought this yesterday (along with Mastodon's Remission) and it's the only Elliot Smith album I have, so I haven't gotten much chance to listen to it yet. I expect good things now.

And if I don't hear good things....I'm coming for you Brad.[/QUOTE]

It's BREAD!!!! :evil:

...and very good purchases

[QUOTE=-Lilsolisman-]Nice Nice review.. but i don't agree on everything..
i think Strung Out Again deserves a higher rating.. especially because he sings the line 'i know my place, i hate my face' so so pretty..

i wouldn't give Fond Farewell that high.. mainly because i don't like the intro.. but that's my opinion apart from that song you did a perfect job rating 5/5's

and i laughed when you said Memory Lane was a 'cute little song' .. that might be the most depressed song on the album.. sentences like 'isolation pushes past self hatred, guilt and shame' or 'i do what people say, and lie in bed all day, Absolutely horrified, I hope you're satisfied' make it a not so cute little song..

apart from those minor points i agree with your review totally.. nice review.. album defintly deserves 4.5/5 or higher...[/QUOTE]

Fair points.

Iai
Emeritus
October 23rd 2004



3553 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

....the name on that second quote through me off there. :confused:

Check all the posters in this thread. It might as well be in Alt/Indie. :lol:

Happymeal
October 23rd 2004



330 Comments


Twilight is a beautiful, beautiful song. But as with other albums I want to buy, I'm still saving for them:p

Great review bread:thumb:

Tapeworm
October 24th 2004



118 Comments


I still haven't got my copy. It's tearing me apart.

Anyway, I have heard King's Crossing, Twilight and Memory Lane. You were saying about the verses in King's Crossing. I think they are simplified as well to bring out the lyrics. That song has some of my favourite lyrics ever:

"I can't prepare for death anymore than I already have."

"All I wanna do now is inject my ex-wife."

Crazy. I will post again when I get the album.

Great review too Brad. :p

Tangy zizzle
October 24th 2004



253 Comments


Great review Andy, a real tribute.

I stick by my declaration that Twilight is the song of the year. I must hear the rest of this album.

br3ad_man
Emeritus
October 24th 2004



2125 Comments


I agree with Twilight. Thanks for all the nice comments.

I love you Tapey ;)

lilsolsman
October 24th 2004



14 Comments


[QUOTE=br3ad_man]Originally Posted by -Lilsolisman-[/QUOTE]

it's funny cause it's -LilSolsman- :D

Tapeworm
October 24th 2004



118 Comments


[QUOTE=br3ad_man]I agree with Twilight. Thanks for all the nice comments.

I love you Tapey ;)[/QUOTE]
giggle giggle giggle giggle giggle!!!!!

Ditto ND. :wave:

The Ashtray Girl
October 24th 2004



108 Comments


Wonderful review, but just makes me jealous because I probably won't be able to get this album for a while. :upset:

br3ad_man
Emeritus
October 25th 2004



2125 Comments


[QUOTE=-LilSolsman-]it's funny cause it's -LilSolsman- :D[/QUOTE]

:upset:

Kaden
October 25th 2004



222 Comments


Excellent album.

That's all I'm saying at this point, as I'm still becoming accustomed to it.

The only downside is, mine skips on one of the songs! really bad!



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy