Where the hell is Kanye?

not one metal album. what a travesty.

booooo

What tomr said.

Who... cares? It's Q magazine.

Ive never even heard of Q Magazine tbh.

q is a british magazine which means it probably prides itself on its homoeroticisms

Is anyone shocked that list sucked?

British Lol

The Suburbs was so boring. There was no energy in Butler's voice.

fuck this list 5 is terrible compared to their s/t

Digging: Sabertooth Zombie - Midnight Venom

"The Suburbs was so boring. There was no energy in Butler's voice."

Did we listen to the same album?

List kind of sucks, no way KOL and Interpol's piece of shit should be higher than Halcyon, but the Suburbs is probably my number one, so whatev.

The Suburbs is good, but not that good. 38 deserves that spot.

2 of these will be in my top 10

Digging: Queens of the Stone Age - ...Like Clockwork

let me guess

7 and 38?

no kanye? fckin hipsters

Was wondering when these would start

No, 29 and 47

lol

Ive seen worse lists, few of these will be on mine. Don't know what Skream's doing here though

Digging: Calibre - Spill

Needs more metal.

[IMG]http://i128.photobucket.com/albums/p190/X3ni/Ualuealualeualueale.gif[/IMG]

Actually 11 of these will be on mine so Q's taste is improving

Or your taste is deteriorating

All Indie and no futurepop makes Bloc a dull boy

I've heard of like 3 of these bands, so yeah. Even then, no Iron Maiden? They're British, wtf. So
much for national loyalty and all that shit.

Digging: Streetlight Manifesto - The Hands That Thieve

Honestly, you can't make a real best of 2010 with out How to Dress Well.

even as a "top 50 indie/pop albums" this list is utter shit

lolololol

haha this list is a funny joke; i think i'll tell it to a friend sometime

Anyone who seriously thinks that Q will have even heard of How To Dress Well needs to get real. I'm not saying it shouldn't be there but it's a mainstream magazine ffs. Also it gives metal practically zero coverage so there's not gonna be any Iron Maiden here.

Any Top 50 list that completely snubs Kanye AND Titus Andronicus is so wrong it doesn't even bear thinking about.

25. Kings Of Leon - Come Around Sundown

I'll take 27, 16, and 8. Other than that, what a boring list.

They published it too fucking early to include Kanye

List is lolbad.

Well that's their fault then, Ali, really. You can only really justify publishing a 2010 list at the end of November if nothing that comes out afterwards would break the top 50...

Yeah, publishing a list this early is just ridiculous, especially when there's a months worth of albums still to come.

hahahahahaha Q.

Q sucks anyway, got it once and it was awful.

Pure shit.

Digging: Kurt Vile - Smoke Ring For My Halo

Really bad list.

Cool list.

Digging: Om - Conference of the Birds

A lot of pretty good stuff but plenty of meh to counterbalance. I'm sure there will be worse mainstream music lists by the end of the year.

this list is.. really, really, really awful..

no BMTH, the fuck is this

Hot Chip was not high enough. also, this list would make all the hipsters in my school wet themselves

lol, vampire weekend higher than the national.

Digging: The Delicious Bread Collection - Equals Hitler

list sucks cock

No Menomena or Sufjan Stevens = epic fail. That Robert Plant album is pure dad rock, doesn't belong anywhere on here.

The Black Keys and Foals should've been higher.

meh, sputnik's will be better

I've downloaded every available album on the list. Now I'm gonna listen to all of them and then bitch about how the list sucks.

worst list ever.

a few good albums but overall pretty mediocre. some of the higher choices are ridiculous.

it's just a list

Digging: Faith No More - The Real Thing

well thats not typical at all. a fuck load of indie shit and ignore everything else.

Any list with Take That on it cannot be taken seriously.

the dear hunter> deerhunter

far Q list

"worst list ever."
you must not have seen many top ___ lists in the past then...

the greatest metal bands of all time was pretty bad tbh.

Q needs to get its party on

List is predictably shit.

Before viewing the list there are two things you can pretty much expect to be there without even looking.

New Arcade Fire, New Kings of Leon.

Predictable..

predictable hipster is predictable

Digging: John Frusciante - Niandra LaDes and Usually Just a T-Shirt

published it's its top 50 albums...

Cool that Tricky got on this.

list is shitty and predictable. the new mgmt? really?

I agree with 6 of them which is around average I'd think.

mgmt has cool music videos. just saying.

What the fuck? Terrible, shitty, inaccurate, distasteful list. Where the fuck is Deftones, Dillinger Escape Plan etc? I'm disgusted

the top 10 are lol-worthy

Would be awesome if people from these mags actually listened to at least a little metal. Shame, some great albums this year. And no, that does not mean Deftones or Dillinger Escape Plan at all.

Also, How to Dress Well is just really not that good. Wayyyy too much hype.

The top 50 are lol-worthy

I like the fact that Avi Buffalo, Villagers and Janelle Monae but the order in which they are placed is stupid.

I mean, behind Kings Of Leon and MGMT? WHAT?!
This isn't opinion, it's stupidity.

Just goes to show with bands guys and groups like 'brandon flowers, vampire weekend..' british music is quite easily said, dead or dying. Downhill track since the 2000's id say... music is dying here and something drastic needs to happen, what a poor list, even weller and a few others arn't that good anymore...wheres the originality gone from england??....

Oh yeah!! Arcade Fire

ust goes to show with bands guys and groups like 'brandon flowers, vampire weekend..' british music is quite easily said, dead or dying.

Lol Q

the Foals should be in the top 5 ..ehh list is quiet bad

Black Keys are tight.

What the fuck? Terrible, shitty, inaccurate, distasteful list. Where the fuck is Deftones

I dont feel The Drums should be there at all.
I get that England would like them but they aren't a universaly fantastic band...quite bad actually. :/

Not totally distasteful, at least it has some cool LPs like Suburbs, Come Around Sundown and Total Life Forever. But sure lacks some very important Records like: High Violet, Diamond Eyes or Wild Hunt. And it has some very crappy stuff in it like fucking Take That or the epic fail which is the second MGMT Record.

Holy scene.

Holy cow Grimward, I didn't even realise, neither Wild Hunt or High Violet is on the list. That's nuts. :/
The Wild Hunt is one of my fave records this year.

Screw this mainstream bullshit!

Actually unless you've listened to the new Take That album I don't think you should slag it off. It's definitely not the worst thing on this list.

And High Violet is on this list you fucking idiots.

I don't getting 2/50 right is very good, Knott.

I agree, I'm not defending the list, I already said it's pretty shit. But when mongs are saying "HIGH VIOLET ISN'T ON THIS LIST!!!!11111" and it IS... just feel the need to point it out, is all.

49, 39, 16, 8, 1 would be in my top 50.

I will never understand the love for Arcade Fire, I just can't get into any of their stuff.

Oh and the list needs more indie.

what a fuckin joke. Awful.

Digging: Erlen Meyer - Erlen Meyer

OMG WHERE's MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE

Digging: The Dillinger Escape Plan - One of Us Is the Killer

Indie of course.

Needs more Edwin McCain.

I mean, behind Kings Of Leon and MGMT? WHAT?!
This isn't opinion, it's stupidity.

Sorry Titan50, I didn't think it was.
And even if you thought it was, a majority of people either didn't like it or felt that there were better albums this year.

So yes, I am implying that Congratulations is not one of the best albums this year. It's rather a 50-50 argument. Some love it, some hate it.

the arcade fire thing they did with andy samberg and snl shorts was pretty hilarious tbh.

In Take That's defense they probably aren't the worst thing on the list.

Truthfully, I think Robert Plant at number 2 bothers me more. I know taste is subjective but that album is not Top 3 material.

not enough OF

#41 - excellent choice

#38 - good choice, if a wee bit overrated

#21, 22 - good choices

#8, #4 - excellent choices

#1 - I liked it a lot more than the other AF albums. Good choice.

Won't look like my list (many critics' lists don't,) but has some solid choices.

Just goes to show with bands guys and groups like 'brandon flowers, vampire weekend..' british music is quite easily said, dead or dying

Nice to see Tricky on there, but the majority of the list is head-scratch worthy.

kinda surprised the new circa isn't somewhere on this list. I know it went a bit too mainstream for the hipsters, but still

god I love that avatar massiveattack

1, 23 (maybe), 32, and 49...and that's it for me. no kanye/titus/high on fire/women/odd future/whatever else i just thought of equals disagreement from me. not that i expect it from q, so take it or leave it

Are people still complaining about lack of (insert genre here) on a list from a magazine that has its own tastes like every other publication? God we do this every fucking year. That's like going to a metal magazine's year end list and saying "where's all the Vampire Weekend or LCD Soundsystem?" Some of you are so stupid sometimes...

having said this, I'm meh towards this list because I've been meh towards most Q related things.

123lan

With only having the suburbs in number one, they get all the list right.

...no

Are people still complaining about lack of (insert genre here) on a list from a magazine that has its own tastes like every other publication? God we do this every fucking year. That's like going to a metal magazine's year end list and saying "where's all the Vampire Weekend or LCD Soundsystem?" Some of you are so stupid sometimes...

16 and 10 are the only ones I really know of. They're both awesome though.

Digging: The Dillinger Escape Plan - One of Us Is the Killer

Funny once releasing this list in November, Q. And where IN THE NAME OF EVERYTHING RIGHTEOUS is Titus Andronicus you bastards?!

This. Metalheads are way too ignorant to other music on Sputnik. They seem to be forgetting that, in this day and age, metal is mostly irrelevant. Deal with it.

pretty sure the same thing can be said of indie kids and mainstream faggots like yourself

This. Metalheads are way too ignorant to other music on Sputnik. They seem to be forgetting that, in this day and age, metal is mostly irrelevant. Deal with it.

i'm disappointed... i expected it to be worse

what a list

Is this a hipster magazine or something?
Seriously, 5 and 1 that high?

WHERE THE FUCK IS NOTHING RHYMES WITH DAVID AND CALEB MCALPINE

LIST SUCKS

" This. Metalheads are way too ignorant to other music on Sputnik. They seem to be forgetting that, in this day and age, metal is mostly irrelevant. Deal with it. "

what a fucking retarded thing to say [2]

Suburbs was great and all but certainly not THAT great.

Digging: The Ocean - Pelagial

circa survive?

what the hell? this is freaking awful...

Lack of Big Boi is disturbing.

Digging: Vampire Weekend - Modern Vampires of the City

Its amazing how people are still going about this, I mean do you really think Q listens to Immolation etc? Who do you think works there??

This list will undoubtedly be better than half of the userbase's end of year's that will include the likes of Periphery

Jason u mad?

Nope, u dum?

i smrt

THIS IS A SHIT LIST
SHIT
SHIT SHIIIIIITTTT, although I am pleases to see AF finally get a rating they deserve. But VP, MGMT? SHITTTTTT

Its amazing how people are still going about this, I mean do you really think Q listens to Immolation etc? Who do you think works there??

This list will undoubtedly be better than half of the userbase's end of year's that will include the likes of Periphery

28 should be higher.

if one were to look upon this list with no knowledge in any form of music whatsoever, they would say this was a terrible year in music

I disagree.

Digging: This Will Destroy You - Young Mountain

every time i see comments like the majority of the ones in this thread it makes me want to once again petition to delete the user base. you stupid motherfuckers need to learn what context is.

omg this doesnt have x album by x band

list suxxx

yo adam did you ever seriously do such a thing?

[img]http://images.blackheartgoldpants.com/images/admin/Fif.jpg[/img]

can they actually delete the entire user base all at once that easily?



jeremy shoulda done that fucking eons ago

Digging: Wu-Block - Wu-Block

you'd think

mx should create an algorithm that permabans any user whose pie chart has over 40 percent of any kind of metal

death and black

mx should create an algorithm that permabans any user whose pie chart has over 40 percent of any kind of music

spose

and andcas black metals great getouttahere

true but to be the only thing?

i mean judging people based on what their pie chart says is retarded

but its funny how most users who laugh at people for having too much metal have like over 50% alt/indie

too much of anything is no good. diversify.

was joking about the algorithm, just saying

only users who bother me are the ones who complain about the lack of genre on a list

the only users that bother me are the retards.

No Alcest? Travesty.

This list is a list. I do not agree with it. Except for Gorillaz... and I did love "The Suburbs," though perhaps not that much. That is my post.

They got it right with Arcade Fire being #1, that's all I care about.

where's Hasselhoth's new record?