intotheshit: Metalcore Sucks

intotheshit 09.09.12	Inb4 Chuck says PtW sucks.
FadeToBlack 09.09.12	metalcore sucks
intotheshit 09.09.12	For the most part it does.
Chortles 09.09.12	pretty much
Maniac! 09.09.12	I'd even hazard to rank the top three: 1,3,2. 2 was definitely awesome and influential, but didn't age as well as I'd like. I definitely listen to 3 more than 2.
intotheshit 09.09.12	I wouldn't say that. 1 and 2 are almost interchangeable.
FadeToBlack 09.09.12	yeah misery signals is my favourite metalcore band, never been able to get into ptw apart from the first album
intotheshit 09.09.12	Misery Signals is one of probably 3 bands in the genre that are actually interesting. THe rest is boring shit.
WeepingBanana 09.09.12	still haven't listened to these guys, are they anything like Deadguy?
Maniac! 09.09.12	I definitely see where you're coming from, Nick. I'd probably say all 3 are interchangeable depending on mood. They're all top-notch, anyway.
Maniac! 09.09.12	"still haven't listened to these guys, are they anything like Deadguy?" No.
intotheshit 09.09.12	Weeping, they're nothing like Deadguy. PtW, along with Shai Hulud, were really one of the first bands to incorporate a lot of melody into their music.
WeepingBanana 09.09.12	hmm I tend to like the noisier end of metalcore like Deadguy and KEN Mode but i've been meaning to check PtW, Shai Hulud and Misery Signals for fucking ever now, so i'll probably get on that soon
ILJ 09.09.12	I haven't listened to much Poison the Well but what I've heard is fucking awesome.
Maniac! 09.09.12	http://turntable.fm/tattoos_and_dunkeroos
Fluttertrank 09.09.12	misery signals
ViralOblivion 09.09.12	Deliver Us from Darkest Hour is a great metalcore album, sucks they went to shit after that
intotheshit 09.09.12	Too bad Darkest Hour aren't really metalcore.
Lenix 09.09.12	misery signals is good but most metalcore sucks
intotheshit 09.09.12	And I find it hilarious that you compare a mediocre album to a band that changed the genre forever.
Maniac! 09.09.12	TURNTABLE NAO
ViralOblivion 09.09.12	that album is metalcore imo or i guess you could call it melodic metal but its closest they came to metalcore, not their stuff before that tho
Fluttertrank 09.09.12	2 is so amazing
Funeralopolis 09.09.12	ptw does suck though
Fluttertrank 09.09.12	fuck no
intotheshit 09.09.12	"ptw does suck though" You must love cock.
Maniac! 09.09.12	"You must love cock." Not that there's anything wrong with that.
Youtellme 09.09.12	most Metalcore bands i've seen suck dick.
ChuckyTruant 09.09.12	Darn beat me to it
intotheshit 09.09.12	"most Metalcore bands i've seen suck dick." Yeah, because all the good ones are dead and gone pretty much
ConcubinaryCode 09.09.12	6 is too low IMO. I love that album. Versions is my least favorite but I haven't heard 7 though.
ChuckyTruant 09.09.12	Nah I'm not a huge PtW fan but they certainly don't suck
Fluttertrank 09.09.12	"Darn beat me to it" yep misery signals haha but there is a lot of good metalcore, just dont be such a douchebag about the genre and you can have fun with it.
Muisc4Life26 09.09.12	Never listened to Poison The Well.
intotheshit 09.09.12	Just because Tear from the Red is at 6 doesn't mean I don't love it. And I love the experimentation on Versions. There isn't any other metalcore/post-hardcore album out there like it.
ILJ 09.09.12	" Yeah, because all the good ones are dead and gone pretty much" Are there any that are still around that you think are good? Just curious.
intotheshit 09.09.12	"Are there any that are still around that you think are good? Just curious." Misery Signals, KEN Mode, Shai Hulud(assuming the release new material), and bands like Counterparts are ok to meh, but the rest is shit.
ConcubinaryCode 09.09.12	Versions was good but I think tropic rot is where they found the sound they were looking for.
intotheshit 09.09.12	http://turntable.fm/tattoos_and_dunkeroos Come on fellas.
witchxrapist 09.09.12	Aside from that horrid first album, Poison The Well is by far one of the best bands in the genre. Old scene bands were so fucking good live, why did it have to turn into auto-tunecore?
tcat84 09.09.12	#1 got me into anything heavier than screamo, i Hated #2 but thought i would give #1 a chance Abbas changed my world
tcat84 09.09.12	Abbas = and
tcat84 09.09.12	was in seattle and had a chance to see them live but my friends are gay and didn't wanna go...scarred me forever
bakkermaarten007 09.09.12	Should've just gone by yourself.
FearThyEvil9 09.09.12	I find 6 so underrated to be honest. Also, 2 would be 1 for me no doubt.
someguest 09.09.12	it's pretty cool they weren't even out of high school when they put their debut LP together
witchxrapist 09.09.12	for me its tear from the red > 2006 demo > versions > you come before you > opposite of december > the tropic rot and fuck the first album
intotheshit 09.09.12	I don't mind the first EP. I just can't stand Aryeh's vox.
MichaelSnoxall 09.09.12	I agree with this.
witchxrapist 09.09.12	I like the screamo sounding vocals, but the clean singing kills it.
Scoot 09.09.12	good band tfu was better though
Dolving999 09.10.12	Metalcore DOESN'T suck. Bands who gave Metalcore a bad reputation suck. Oh, and I love PTW. My fav in this list is 5. They're doing a re-issue of 2 & 6 on Rise Records... How ironic is that?