Being on this site for 32 months has been quite an experience. With only LPs, here are my first 50 LP I rated as Classics. All are in order I rated them by date.
Fuck yeah you think that Year Zero and Evil Empire are their best! Nice.
I love Mellon Collie too, but there's a couple of flaws on it in my opinion. Still have it 4.5'd. I'm curious to why you like it more than Siamese Dream.