lyzakthellama
03.01.14 | Honorable mentions- Every other Led Zeppelin song in existence, this was a tough list |
Chrisjon89
03.01.14 | good songs. can't complain. i'd have a few of these. definitely would have No Quarter and Achilles Last Stand. |
hikingmetalpunk
03.01.14 | beauty list my man, grab a cold one. |
Snowdog808
03.01.14 | Where would you rate "No Quarter" and "In the Light?" |
ExcentrifugalForz
03.01.14 | 6 is good |
JamieTwort
03.01.14 | Great list. 1 and 2 are my favorites too, although I'd probably switch them around. |
VermTheImpaler
03.01.14 | 2 should be 1 |
Comatorium.
03.01.14 | I'd definitely have Houses of the Holy and Immigrant Song but good songs. First comment kinda sums this band up. |
Mad.
03.01.14 | Stairway is a cliche but it should be on here |
Ryus
03.01.14 | dude props for the rain song, it rules |
ArsMoriendi
03.01.14 | Nothing from Presence? Also "Stairway to Heaven" is like one of the most boring Led Zeppelin songs ever, so boring that when it first premiered, it was said they were booed off stage.
With that said...decent list my favorite is "For Your Life." |
YoYoMancuso
03.01.14 | 9, 1 and 2 is my top 3 |
FearTomorrow
03.01.14 | Ramble On |
lyzakthellama
03.01.14 | i was so close to putting ramble on on this |
MrSirLordGentleman
03.01.14 | List really needs Achilles and No Quarter |
mandan
03.01.14 | List needs "No Quarter"[4] and "The Lemon Song", but it's solid all the same. |
Natherey
03.01.14 | Tea For One anyone? |
mandan
03.01.14 | This is prob the least controversial band on Sput. Most users who like 'em like more or less the same albums to a similar extent. Ofc, there are debates over which is their best album, but not as heated as the Opeth debates. |
Muisc4Life26
03.01.14 | List rules but it needs Dazed and Confused. |
menawati
03.01.14 | everyones ratings for zep vary a lot, id definitely have achilles in there near top though |
lyzakthellama
03.01.14 | Yeah I find that zeppelin actually ranges quite a bit, for instance my favorite album is III and certain people would find that ridiculous |
MyRubberSoulAlt
03.01.14 | Nah,III was my first Zeppelin and my favorite for some time as well. |
mandan
03.01.14 | Yeah, but Zep discussions seldom heat up that much. |
lyzakthellama
03.01.14 | Yeah no doubt, zep talk is always super relaxed |
NeroCorleone80
03.01.14 | III def isnt their best |
Artuma
03.01.14 | wtf where's no quarter? |
Jethro42
03.01.14 | How Many More Times |
lyzakthellama
03.01.14 | you just solidified my point, thank you @nerocorleone |
NeroCorleone80
03.01.14 | I dont think its ridiculous thats its your favorite though, I can see why it might be. |
neurisis17
03.01.14 | No Stairway? Denied... Seriously though that should be here. It's one of those overplayed songs that is overplayed for good reason. Also Kashmir should be higher. |
ArsMoriendi
03.01.14 | @neurisis17: "Stairway to Heaven" would probably make my 10 least favorites by Zeppelin, especially if you didn't count Coda songs as eligible. |
lyzakthellama
03.01.14 | I like stairway, I just like all these more plus Kashmir is one of those songs I've just listened to way too much |
neurisis17
03.01.14 | ^yeah seem to be the expert Mark... er, Lyzak (I don't pretend to be a connoisseur of Led Zeppelin)
@ArsMoriendi why your bottom 10? |
ArsMoriendi
03.02.14 | @neurisis17: I can start by saying the intro was ripped from an earlier song, it takes way too long to pick up, there's literally no bass part (what the hell JPJ?) , and Plant's vocals aren't nearly as impressive on it as most LZ songs. It's certainly the worst song on LZ IV.
With that said the lyrics themselves are excellent. The guitar and drums do save it from being a bore completely. I feel like it got so popular because of the "demonic" back masking and the deep meaningful lyrics. |
neurisis17
03.02.14 | fair enough. You're definitely right about the bass, but I feel enjoy the length of the intro. Also I've never thought of Plant's vocals as that spectacular, so that wasn't a problem for me in the first place. |
mandan
03.02.14 | Plant sang with a spirit like no other.
I will admit that Page wouldn't make my Top 10 guitar players. |
climactic
03.02.14 | No Quarter and Achilles Last Stand [2] |
CK
03.02.14 | Needs more Battle of Evermore |
MrSirLordGentleman
03.02.14 | Oh, I forgot it... No love for The Rover? |
mandan
03.02.14 | "No Quarter" [6] |