johnnydeking29
03.07.12 | I sense an incoming shitstorm |
Erratic
03.07.12 | Oh look, this list again. |
Cheesesandwich2
03.07.12 | So is Octavarium dude |
johnnydeking29
03.07.12 | "I know it's all been done before, I wanna do it again, I wanna do it again" |
Metalguy908
03.07.12 | 3 is a 5 trololololo |
johnnydeking29
03.07.12 | Nah, Octavarium isn't overrated (although I probs like it more than anyone else) |
tiesthatbind
03.07.12 | Agreed on 2 minus the "genius" part |
FruityCatOfDoom
03.07.12 | 2 is overrated but that doesn't mean its not an excellent record. While 1 is overrated as hell and it is common knowledge that 3 is one of the worst pieces of music ever recorded and released to a mass audience. |
sublimefan1991
03.07.12 | as far as metallica goes, i haven't heard 1 but i believe it. i only gave ride the lightning like a 3/3.5, yet it's apparently the greatest album ever. |
johnnydeking29
03.07.12 | Tool defo has artistic vision; I can't deny that
However artistic vision =/= amazing music |
Betacra
03.07.12 | Horrible list in my opinion.
And Justice For All is anything but overrated, the album is kind of forgotten amongst the other classics Metallica have.
Aenima is better than Lateralus imo.
Lulu is bad, but it's not the worst thing ever... |
FruityCatOfDoom
03.07.12 | And Justice For All sucks. Kill Em All, Ride the Lightning and Master of Puppets is where its at. |
iambandersnatch
03.07.12 | tool in general is overrated but still pretty good |
Katechon
03.07.12 | ITAOTS |
Betacra
03.07.12 | @Katechon
Depends which part of the internet you're at. /mu/ praises it like no end most the time. But yea, can't see the hype about it at all. |
dannyboy89
03.07.12 | Lulu isn't overrated lol, almost everyone hates it on sputnik. |
TheNotrap
03.07.12 | ...And Justice For All is not overrated.
Metal as its finest.
|
johnnydeking29
03.07.12 | I beg to differ; MoP and RIP are metal at it's finest, AJFA is leagues away |
Trebor17
03.07.12 | SHORTEST STRAW |
Katechon
03.07.12 | "Depends which part of the internet you're at. /mu/ praises it like no end most the time. But yea, can't see the hype about it at all."
EVERY music site I've ever been to rides that album's dick. |
SpiritCrusher2
03.07.12 | AJFA rules yea
imagine how good would it be if it had bass :O |
TheFonz123
03.07.12 | I hate tool as much as anyone but the album you listed is a solid 3 its pretty descent. now lateralus on the other hand is horrible..... |
ReturnToRock
03.07.12 | Back In Black needs to be on here. |
pwalcher
03.07.12 | Thank you for 2, I have the same opinion on it. Some great hits that make for a good concert. Horribly long and dragging album though. When you see them live though they play a lot from Aenima, and tbh they play them very well and it's fantastic. |
Dimor
03.07.12 | Dude. Aenema is anything but boring. It may not be the best fucking album of all time like many people argue, but it is a great and innovative album nonetheless. And AJFA is not even close to being overrated, its hidden in the shadow of like every single other 'Tallica album.
|
Tyrannic
03.07.12 | so all the tool haters come to hide on this thread, huh? |
Dimor
03.07.12 | Are you one of them dude? I beg to god that youll tell me your not. |
TheFonz123
03.07.12 | yeah I also chose to hide in the 5 review of lateralus thread by bartender. I dont like tool, sorry! |
macadoolahicky
03.07.12 | Aenima isn't overrated. Lateralus on the other hand.... |
Tyrannic
03.07.12 | http://www.sputnikmusic.com/uservote.php?memberid=609145#7776 |
Dimor
03.07.12 | Thank you |
Dimor
03.07.12 | And btw Fonz rating Lateralus a 2 is just not cool man. ffs |
TheFonz123
03.07.12 | Im just bein honest
im just bein honest
dont want to meet your daddy
just want you in my caddy
im just bein honest
im just bein honest |
macadoolahicky
03.07.12 | I love you, fonz. |
WatchItExplode
03.07.12 | this list is pretty dum if u think about it |
Tyrannic
03.07.12 | i'll acknowledge that tool's other two aren't as good, but lateralus brings all that crazy shit together so well. if you just don't like their other albums oh well, but lateralus is pretty much the perfect tool album imo. |
Dimor
03.07.12 | ^Agree |
johnnydeking29
03.07.12 | I much prefer Aenima (which isn't a bad album, just not very entertaining) to what I've heard from Lateralus (Schism (one of the most boring songs I've ever heard), the title track and The Grudge (which was alright)) |
macadoolahicky
03.07.12 | They tried way too hard on Lateralus |
Dimor
03.07.12 | yeh they did, and the outcome was pretty awesome |
UnnamedOcean
03.07.12 | Tool tries to hard. "Hey look, we can write a song in the Fobonacci sequence! Dude like, Aenima is
like, about how the whole world is so messed up, it's like an Aenima, get it?! It's a metaphor!" |
Brumas
03.08.12 | oh look a dumb list, how is aenima boring?
And how is dyer's eve an awful song? |
IMZA1793
03.08.12 | "And how is dyer's eve an awful song?" [2] |
Tyrone187
03.16.12 | AJFA is underrated compared to their other albums and the same goes for tools Aenima.I think u lost the point of your subject line... And Dyer's eve is a masterful recording which u don't understand... I think u're better off looking in some Alternative/pop stuff for overrated material.... |
coneren
03.16.12 | baseline do you have sweet jugs |
Dimor
03.16.12 | @Baseline Exactly my thought, this whole thing about a band trying to hard is fucking retarded. |
Ovrot
03.16.12 | Dyer's Eve rules |
NightProwler
03.16.12 | Dyer's Eve rules [2]
Both Justice and Ænima are fucking awesome. You're just a fucking terrible troll! |
Dimor
03.16.12 | Yeh, Dyer's Eve is pretty brutal |
Oathbreaker
03.16.12 | "for me to really enjoy it."
I didn't know all music should be tailored for you to enjoy. |
johnnydeking29
03.16.12 | I never said it should be; I'm (quite obviously) just stating that that's what stops me from enjoying it |
Palimpsest
03.16.12 | Shortest Straw rules. |
demigod93
03.16.12 | fuck you, Aenima is a masterpiece dude. and no one really overrates And Justice, everyone just recognizes it's a solid album. I don't see many 5's in it's favor around here. |
johnnydeking29
03.16.12 | 751 votes for 5, average of 4.2; overrated, it should be a 3.8 at best
I don't mind Aenima, but it's certainly not a masterpiece imo; if u appreciate it as one, then good for you |
demigod93
03.16.12 | wow, i had no idea so many people liked Justice that much. it's a good record but definitely far from a 5. |
johnnydeking29
03.16.12 | I know, it surprised me too when I first saw it. I like parts of Justice, but others are bland and
forgettable |
heartofchambers355
06.14.12 | ughhh...Metallica is not all that great...they as a band are over rated nevermind specific albums |
demigod93
06.14.12 | they really are quite overrated, but they have some gooooood stuff early on. Justice is just a boring album overall. |
