ManintheBox
03.22.12 | Gonna get some rad shit for 4 m/ |
DominionMM1
03.22.12 | I loved it when it first came out.
OT: Macho Man Randy Savage- Be A Man |
Maniac!
03.22.12 | Rishloo - Feathergun
I don't think it's a classic, but I enjoy it enough to rate it a 5, where most don't. |
ManintheBox
03.22.12 | 4? same here...Now I know for a fact it isn't and never was a classic but back when I was 14 to 15 jammed to that shit for like a year straight. I say it needs some kind of award :P |
FearThyEvil9
03.22.12 | Chevelle-Wonder What's Next
|
KILL
03.22.12 | yea none of these are close to a 5 agreed |
DominionMM1
03.22.12 | no love for danzig, kill? |
macadoolahicky
03.22.12 | Love 1. I like it more than Lateralus, actually.
I don't think the handful of people that know The Sleepover Series by Hammock consider it a classic. I also consider Strapping Young Lad's Alien a classic. |
KILL
03.22.12 | theyre ok |
ManintheBox
03.22.12 | @KILL most people would bra.
|
macadoolahicky
03.22.12 | And yeah, 4 is a really good listen not going to lie. |
Imperial
03.22.12 | Akercocke - Words That Go Unspoken, Deeds That Go Undone. |
DominionMM1
03.22.12 | and all this time I thought you were m/ |
ManintheBox
03.22.12 | maybe the rest of their stuff is ok, but seriously lucifuge should at least earn a 4 to 4.5 for those who respect the satan rawk m/! |
SpiritCrusher2
03.22.12 | ^ lol |
KILL
03.22.12 | sorry i'm not hans i only like elite metal but stay ac/dc dom m/ |
ManintheBox
03.22.12 | @mac: yeah dude 10,000 days really surprised me with how awesome it is. Seriously still can't get over the title tracks and right in two. |
DominionMM1
03.22.12 | will do m/ |
ManintheBox
03.22.12 | I guess I could add Back in Black here since it is only at a 4. |
clercqie
03.22.12 | Bloc Party - Intimacy |
WhiteTieBlackJacket
03.22.12 | I love Axe to Fall and since it was the first record by Converge I ever listened to, and hence the first time I was blown away by them, it is my favorite record of theirs'. I enjoy Jane Doe and You Fail Me as much as the next guy but Axe to Fall....holy fuck. |
ManintheBox
03.22.12 | ^interesting pick, very interesting. |
MalleusMaleficarum
03.22.12 | Women - Public Strain |
TheNotrap
03.22.12 | Genesis - Duke |
ThroneOfAgony
03.22.12 | Tiesto- In Search of Sunrise 5 |
evilford
03.22.12 | interesting list idea
High on Fire - Death is This Communion
Godflesh - Pure |
clercqie
03.22.12 | "Tiesto- In Search of Sunrise 5"
Ugh... |
ManintheBox
03.22.12 | Dude WhiteTie I agree entirely, that was the album I started with aswell still by far my favorite. It's like the angriest thing ever, and then you get to Cruel Bloom and Wretched World, and as you said.......holy fuck. |
Yotimi
03.22.12 | 4 would've been a 5 one time in my life (15 years or so ago) so I can understand it.
For me, Saves the Day - In Reverie |
Adabelle
03.22.12 | Neil Perry - Lineage Situation (although a fair few people on the forum site worship it)
Beirut - Gulag Orkestar
Yaphet Kotto - First two albums
|
RooseveltsGhost
03.22.12 | Steven Wilson- Insurgentes
Vanessa Carlton- Be Not Nobody
Scale the Summit- Carving Desert Canyons
Pelican- City of Echoes |
ManintheBox
03.22.12 | @Yoti yeah as of now I just don't have the heart to dock its rating.
@roosevelt unique picks bra |
ITsHxCTOASTER
03.22.12 | I don't have anything outrageous at a 5, I guess my most controversial 5 would be Letlive - Fake History |
Funeralopolis
03.22.12 | but fake history is a 5 |
MalleusMaleficarum
03.22.12 | ahahahaha |
KILL
03.22.12 | ioi |
Shuyin
03.22.12 | classic and korn dont match |
VinVal
03.22.12 | Phantom limb fell in love with it the first listen ive listened to that album at least 5 times a day for the past week since i found it |
ManintheBox
03.22.12 | @shuyin and cannibal corpse's kill and classic do? |
ManintheBox
03.22.12 | @toaster alot of people seem to dig that, especially the reissue. |
Shuyin
03.22.12 | 'and cannibal corpse's kill and classic do?'
nope, kill matches with MASTERPIECE M/ |
mastille
03.22.12 | 65dos One Time for All Time
how people can rate it below a 5 is beyond me |
ManintheBox
03.22.12 | @shuyin: Well played, Sir. |
J1996
03.22.12 | yay 1 |
ChuckyTruant
03.22.12 | Architects - Hollow Crown |
ManintheBox
03.22.12 | @J1996 fuck yeah 1 |
ohfoxxxycole
03.22.12 | i dont see a lot of people with the blood brother - burn piano island burn or japandroids - post-nothing as 5s so theres my answer to your question |
Turtlestlker
03.22.12 | I'm pretty sure I'm the only one on this site who think The Black Dahlia Murder-Ritual is a five. |
Dev518
03.22.12 | Not quite what you are looking for, but I rated Ride the Lightning as a 5 and Master of Puppets as a 4. Most would say that Master of Puppets is the better album but they are wrong. |
ManintheBox
03.22.12 | @turtlebra probably I thought was awesome and their best yet but they'd have to make some unworldly good dm to make 5. |
ManintheBox
03.22.12 | @dev yeah very controversial move my friend. |
InbredJed
03.30.12 | This is a cool list idea, I agree that none of the albums you selected deserve a classic rating. My personal entries for this category are Neil Young & Crazy Horse - Greendale, Anthrax-Sound of White Noise and Persistence of Time, Faith No More-King for a Day.... and Slayer - Diabolus in Musica |
InbredJed
03.30.12 | Ps blood brothers BPIB is a 5 for sure! |
ManintheBox
04.02.12 | @Jed thanks bra, and yeah those are good too. what are your reasons for diabolus which is a pretty off the wall 5. |
BallsToTheWall
04.02.12 | Danzig II is indeed a classic. |
coneren
04.02.12 | i agree with ballsout |
BallsToTheWall
04.02.12 | i agree with coneren's agreement. |
StokesForJustice
04.02.12 | i agree with you both |
coneren
04.02.12 | im glad we can all agree i agrree with us all agreeing great work guys everyone agree with that? |
BallsToTheWall
04.02.12 | We're all in agreement with our mutual agreements then? Fantastic... |
coneren
04.02.12 | im happy to say i can agree with that |
BallsToTheWall
04.02.12 | Agreed. |
coneren
04.02.12 | i agree |
Katechon
04.02.12 | Lurker of Chalice's S/T. |
evilford
04.02.12 | I concur w/ all stmts |
BallsToTheWall
04.02.12 | I agree with all of your agreements, it's not so hard to agree with these agreements when the agreements are easy to agree on.. Praise you all.... |
evilford
04.02.12 | this is by far the most I've ever seen anyone agree with anything that anyone has said on this site thus far
refreshing |
Tyrael
04.02.12 | Opeth - My Arms, Your Hearse
Tigers On Trains - Grandfather
Fall Out Boy - Take This To Your Grave
Wintersun - Wintersun
The Ocean - Precambrian
Shai Hulud - That Within Blood Ill-Tempered
Dimmu Borgir - Stormblast
Cradle of Filth - Dusk... And Her Embrace
Emery - In Shallow Seas We Sail...
Botch - We Are The Romans
etc etc etc |
BallsToTheWall
04.02.12 | 2Pac Me Against the World
2Pac All Eyez on Me
Agalloch The Mantle
Agalloch Pale Folklore
Agalloch Ashes Against the Grain
Amia Venera Landscape The Long Procession
Amorphis Silent Waters
Arghoslent Hornets of the Pogrom
Ash Borer 2009 Demo
Ash Borer/Fell Voices Split
Autopsy Mental Funeral
Burzum Hvis lyset tar oss
Candlemass Nightfall
Chthonic Seediq Bale
Coldworld Melancholie
Cradle of Filth Midian
Cradle of Filth Dusk... and Her Embrace
Cradle of Filth The Principle of Evil Made Flesh
Cradle of Filth Vempire or Dark Fairytales in Phallustei
Cradle of Filth Cruelty and the Beast
Cryptopsy None So Vile
Cynic Focus
Darkthrone Transilvanian Hunger
Deafheaven Roads To Judah
Death Individual Thought Patterns
Death Cab For Cutie Plans
Demilich Nespithe
Dimmu Borgir Enthrone Darkness Triumphant
Dirty The Pimp & Da Gangsta
Dissection Storm of the Light's Bane
Eminem The Marshall Mathers LP
Emperor In the Nightside Eclipse
Emperor Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk
Funebrarum The Sleep of Morbid Dreams
Goodie Mob Soul Food
Gorguts From Wisdom to Hate
GZA Liquid Swords
Hooded Menace Fulfill the Curse
Immolation Close to a World Below
Immortal Sons of Northern Darkness
Incantation Onward to Golgotha
Incantation Mortal Throne of Nazarene
Jay-Z The Blueprint
La Dispute Somewhere at the Bottom of the River...
Marduk Plague Angel
Mayhem De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas
Mercyful Fate Melissa
Mercyful Fate Don't Break the Oath
Misery Signals Controller
Mobb Deep The Infamous
Modern Life Is War Witness
Nas Illmatic
Opeth Ghost Reveries
Orphaned Land Mabool (The Story of the Three Sons...)
Outkast Aquemini
Outkast ATLiens
Primordial The Gathering Wilderness
Primordial To The Nameless Dead
Raekwon Only Built 4 Cuban Linx...
Silencer Death - Pierce Me
Silverstein Discovering the Waterfront
Suffocation Effigy of the Forgotten
The Notorious B.I.G. Ready to Die
The Weeknd House of Balloons
Ulver Nattens Madrigal
Ulver Bergtatt
Underoath They're Only Chasing Safety
Walknut Graveforests And Their Shadows
Warning Watching From a Distance
Wintersun Wintersun
Wu-Tang Clan Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers) |
YankeeDudel
04.02.12 | Korn is supreme influence incarnate |
Hawks
04.02.12 | Lmao fuck you Balls. |
BallsToTheWall
04.02.12 | HAWKS RAWKS....love u buddy |
Tyrael
04.02.12 | Oh Hawks... |
Hawks
04.02.12 | Mine lol. |
VinVal
04.02.12 | everything korn has made is terrible, especially their debut |
coneren
04.02.12 | hawks |
BallsToTheWall
04.02.12 | hawks bawks at cawks. |
coneren
04.02.12 | hawks is gay |
YankeeDudel
04.02.12 | Nah Korn is cool. You're just uncool. |
Hawks
04.02.12 | Shut the fuck up Cone that's why I fuck Balls now instead of your faggot ass. |
BallsToTheWall
04.02.12 | hanging at the dawks with good ol hawks. |
coneren
04.02.12 | thats too bad for balls |
foxxxyroxxx
04.02.12 | hawks please unban me |
coneren
04.02.12 | wtf he banned you? what a fucking asshole |
ManintheBox
04.07.12 | Woah just checked this....Way to post deep and thought provoking comments guysss! |
InbredJed
08.05.12 | My reason for Diablolus In Musica as a 5 is simply personal taste as a result of the time I was born I think. I was born in 84, so I didn't start listening to the classic thrash bands until the mid-late nineties when they had started to dilute their sounds. One of the first albums I owned was Anthrax-Sound of White Noise. I also was a big fan of Machine Head's first album, so when I heard Diabolus and its combination of thrash with some more experimental song structures and interesting noise-esque leads, I was hooked. I think it is by far the most diverse Slayer album, and I think more than some of their other, the lyrics really epitomize what Slayer appears to aim for; providing an a mirror of frustrated and violent thoughts as a reaction to this fucked up world. I may not agree with all of the views stated, but I can identify because I have thought those thoughts before at one time, or know someone else who has. Plus who doesn't feel like they could destroy a brick house after listening to Bitter Peace? |
InbredJed
08.06.12 | It's an opinion, I never said it was well informed. :l
|
ManintheBox
08.11.12 | dude I respect your opinion fully bro, especially when it sounds like valid reasons. I mean 10,000 days is when of my favorite all time albums for my own reasons not other peoples reasons, so rock on bro m/ |
jayfatha
08.11.12 | Pantera - The Great Southern Trendkill
my favorite album ever |
SaneTBP
08.11.12 | 1 is masterpiece agreed |
InbredJed
08.18.12 | DUDE! Trendkill..... how could I forget? My out and out favourite 90's metal album!
|
Satellite
08.18.12 | like half of my fives |
YetAnotherBrick
08.18.12 | Andrew Jackson Jihad - Knife Man |
lacesout39
08.18.12 | My most controversial 5 is probably Scurrilous. I just enjoyed the hell out of it for like 6 months of nearly daily listening, I couldn't not give it a 5. |
ManintheBox
08.27.12 | dude sane' respect dude..that album is amazing..practicly 5'd it for 10,000 days alone m/! |
elephantREVOLUTION
08.27.12 | steel panther - feel the steel |
YoYoMancuso
09.19.12 | Smashing Pumpkins-Gish
Pearl Jam-Vitalogy
dredg-Leitmotif
Deftones-Adrenaline |
ManintheBox
09.23.12 | Cool picks dude, especially adrenaline. |
Masochist
09.23.12 | Bad Religion - 'The Empire Strikes First' |
MichaelSnoxall
09.23.12 | Rishloo - Feathergun [2] |
XingKing
09.23.12 | Korn is awful but that album is definitely a classic for it's genre. There is no denying that. |
TomArnoldsArmpit
09.23.12 | sevens travels and the balancing act |
ManintheBox
09.24.12 | yeah I have since lowered my rating for that album to a 4.5, it kind of does suck but still I have lots of memories regarding it and it probably is like the pinnacle nu metal album. |
ManintheBox
10.24.12 | Imma have to add Gojira's L 'Enfant Sauvage to this list. |
Aids
10.24.12 | Coldplay - Viva La Vida
Eluvium - Static Nocturne
Regina Spektor - Songs
|
ManintheBox
01.09.13 | Agalloch Pale Folklore and Gojira L'enfant Sauvage |
evilford
01.09.13 | pink floyd - dark side of the moon |
SpiritCrusher2
01.09.13 | converge - jane doe |
ViperAces
01.09.13 | kmb is the lowest rated 5 i have |
Chortles
01.09.13 | lol ford |
gwynbleidd
01.09.13 | Converge - jane doe |
ViperAces
01.09.13 | yea ford breathless> |
East Hastings
01.09.13 | dgd s/t |
Keyblade
01.09.13 | Mindflowers - Improgressive |
ManintheBox
01.09.13 | oh wow you guys 5'd jane doe too, what a small world..you dudes are one of a kind. |
slipnslide
01.09.13 | list is old |
ManintheBox
01.09.13 | comments were new though... |
pissbore
01.10.13 | abominations of desolation |
ManintheBox
01.13.13 | m/!! |
ManintheBox
04.02.13 | I'm going to have to add Kvelertak - Kvelertak to this list, It's a fucking masterpiece and the most fun album I've ever listened too. |
InbredJed
04.02.13 | I've been checking out the new album recently, you think the self titled is better? |
NeoSpaz
04.02.13 | Scale the Summit - The Collective
woop woop
|
StallionMang
04.02.13 | The Mars Volta- Amputechture |
pissbore
04.02.13 | talking heads: 77 |
InbredJed
04.03.13 | Talking Heads, nice
There's no way its a 5 but I can't stop spinning Days - Real Estate
|
Kman418
04.03.13 | Off minor - some blood
Don't even try to say heat death is better |
toxin.
04.03.13 | rating < 4? hm
jimmy eat world - futures. personally of course it's not a classic by any other means |
