ManintheBox: The Faceless Ranked

ManintheBox 08.27.12	and seriously, does anyone know what that one really trve and kvlt user afterthebreakdown rated autotheism...interested to see if he 5'd that shit or not..
ILJ 08.27.12	2 is 3. Otherwise correct.
auberginedreams 08.27.12	planetary duality is decent, but it's still only like a 3.5 at best for me.
ManintheBox 08.27.12	yeah when a band only has like 3 albums, it gets harder to mess the rankings up m/!!!
ManintheBox 08.27.12	dude I guess I'm insane but its pd is like the best death metal album ive heard in the last 5 years.
intotheshit 08.27.12	terrible ranking, terrible list, terrible band
XingKing 08.27.12	PD = Akel >>>>> Auto
ITsHxCTOASTER 08.27.12	Haven't heard the new album but otherwise 3 is 1 and it's still not a good album
InFiction 08.27.12	Akeldama > Planetary > Autotheism.
MichaelSnoxall 08.27.12	Akeldama is their best. Because it was their only release where they tried to have their own sound.
Evreaia 08.27.12	ratings are wrong, ranking is correct
MichaelSnoxall 08.27.12	Autotheism blows hard.
Evreaia 08.27.12	not really, it's just like their older stuff, only bit more singy
GiaNXGX 08.27.12	Akeldama>Authoteism
MetallicOpeth 08.27.12	akeldama is ok
ManintheBox 08.27.12	yeah I just prefer the devin townsend and opeth influences on autotheism when compared to the more metalcore approach of akeldama.
ManintheBox 08.27.12	Also thought they had they're own sound on planetary, admittidley there were alot of cynic and necrophagist thrown in for good measure. I mean they were definitley their own on songs like legion of the serpent and sons of beliel.
Insurrection 08.27.12	list is backwards
ManintheBox 08.27.12	its to keep you on the edge of your seat until you scroll down m/!
Insurrection 08.27.12	i mean its backwards like 3 > 2 > 1
Rikardur 08.27.12	maybe if they had faces they'd make better music
Motiv3 08.27.12	terrible ranking. 3>1>>>>>>2
Yazz_Flute 08.27.12	Akeldama > Planetary Duality > Autotheism
bloc 08.27.12	Tough call between 1 and 2 for me
Hawks 08.27.12	Didn't listen to 2 because 1 and 3 both suck ass.
ManintheBox 08.27.12	surprised with the preference of akeldama on here...not surprised with haawks distaste. hail trveee m/!!!
ManintheBox 08.27.12	and come on bros, the autotheistic movements and accelerated evolution are sick songsm/!!
XingKing 08.28.12	I think the love for Akeldama comes from the fact that it has it's own unique sound. Planetary is just worship of all the bands they wish they were, while admittedly being good worship, and Autotheism is just trash.
ManintheBox 08.28.12	Good point, when it was released it was definitely a unique album. still not getting the hate for autotheism though. the cleans are goofy at times admittidly.
XingKing 08.29.12	The band should have spent more time evolving from what they moved towards with Planetary Duality. PD was the obvious evolutionary step after Akeldama by ditching the core elements. Autotheism came out of left field and is blatant plagiarism and fan worship. It's so obvious that Keene wishes he was Townsend and Akerfeldt that it's painful.
ManintheBox 08.31.12	Yeah that was actually my reaction when I heard the chorus for the eidelon reality, what do you think they should have done instead of adopting opeth/townsend elements? I honestly wasn't really to surprised either, from interviews and stuff it seemed like the faceless basicly turned into the keene project...
climactic 08.31.12	PD is all u need
AfterTheBreakdown 09.04.12	@maninthebox i rated it 4.5 i like it a lot just not quite as much as the others. But switch 2 and 3 around.
ShadowRemains 09.04.12	foad
jayfatha 09.04.12	They get worse chronologically I think
ManintheBox 09.19.12	Yeah no matter how you look at it Autotheism is nowhere near as good as planetary, and I still think the evolution itself sounded way to forced.
HitlerIsTheBest 09.19.12	why would you rank a 3 album discography
ManintheBox 09.19.12	So I can argue about which album is better, I mean there could be like 5 different opinions about ranking still plenty of shit to argue about.
intotheshit 09.19.12	"why would you rank a 3 album discography" Must have taken a lot of perseverance and hard work.
JAXETA 09.19.12	very much so
ManintheBox 09.19.12	It did take me 5 days of nonstop grueling work to complete the list, I lost 50 pounds and practicly my will to live but I did it!
oltnabrick 09.19.12	Not too much to argue about really.
Yazz_Flute 09.19.12	Leica is still their best song.
JAXETA 09.19.12	nope, an autopsy is
Yazz_Flute 09.19.12	3:45 to the end in Leica is like the coolest shit ever don't you dare front
Shuyin 09.19.12	not my favorite band, but for what ive heard from them akeldama is the best. PD was kinda boring and the new album only had 2-3 decent songs
ManintheBox 09.19.12	In my humble opinion Planetary duality is by far their best song, then lecia
JAXETA 09.19.12	nuh uh BATTLE ME BRO
Mickeymau5 09.19.12	Akeldama > Planetary > Autotheism.
ManintheBox 09.19.12	and dude looks like theres about 50 comments of arguing going on, oooh snap!
JAXETA 09.19.12	tends to happen
intotheshit 09.19.12	"It did take me 5 days of nonstop grueling work to complete the list, I lost 50 pounds and practicly my will to live but I did it!" Wishing you would have followed through on the latter.
Keyblade 09.19.12	yea cuz like, he shud dye for liking muzic u dont
JAXETA 09.19.12	mhmm
ManintheBox 09.19.12	Wishing you would have followed through on the latter.[2] everyone knows that musical opinions are worth dying over...
isisfan467 09.19.12	sucks
Fluttertrank 09.19.12	agreed haha
AfterTheBreakdown 09.19.12	"Leica is still their best song" i thought i was the only one who thought this haha.
ViralOblivion 09.19.12	I agree they just get worse and worse every release Especially after how long it took them to write the new album it should've been better than that
ManintheBox 09.19.12	I think everyone will agree that autotheism is nowhere near as good as their earlier stuff.
AfterTheBreakdown 09.19.12	yeah but its still good.
ManintheBox 09.19.12	yeah no doubt, will be on my year end list m/!!
Surtur 12.13.12	Autotheism is their best imo cue hate
AfterTheBreakdown 12.16.12	all 3 are excellent.
DotEight 12.16.12	Haven't given much of a shit about this band since Akeldama.
ManintheBox 12.16.12	You should jam PD bro, while not the most original album ever, its pretty sick. and @after Totally agree dude m/!
DotEight 12.16.12	I've heard all 3 several times. I just don't think they compare to Akeldama. Even Brewer's Alone is way better than Autotheism. It doesn't do his skills justice.