rockandmetaljunkie
08.22.11 | 2,3,8 could easily be the easiest 5's ever. |
clercqie
08.22.11 | Upon first listen?
Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago
and Bloc Party - Intimacy
Those are it |
RosaParks
08.22.11 | 2 probably |
RosaParks
08.22.11 | lol 13 |
omnipanzer
08.22.11 | Sgt. Pepper
Abbey Road
|
rockandmetaljunkie
08.22.11 | "Upon first listen?"
Yep |
benkim
08.22.11 | La Dispute - Somewhere at The Bottom of The River |
JamieTwort
08.22.11 | 2, 4, 13, Made in Japan, Physical Grafitti and Animals were all easy 5's for me. |
Deviant.
08.22.11 | Lifeforms - The Future Sound Of London
Tri-Repetae - Autechre
Endtroducing... - DJ Shadow
After The Eulogy - Boysetsfire |
Winesburgohio
08.22.11 | Bitches Brew and Enter the Wu-Tang(36 chambers) were 5s after a couple of listens, but I think Choirs of the Eye is the only 5 i have that i would've considered classic-worthy upon first listen.
Oh wait and 'Close to the Edge' by Yes |
MO
08.22.11 | Abbey Road [2] |
telebyrd
08.22.11 | Talking Heads - Stop Making Sense |
wittwright
08.22.11 | Defeater-lost ground, no doubt
|
ilikeforests
08.22.11 | the wild hunt |
Xplisit
08.22.11 | Black Sails in the Sunset |
pmmets07
08.22.11 | streetlight manifesto - everything goes numb
catch 22 - keasbey nights
dangers - messy, isn't it? |
accompliceofmydeath
08.22.11 | Poison the Well- The Opposite of December
Quicksand- Slip
Deadguy- Fixation on a Coworker
Black Flag- Damaged |
Thane
08.22.11 | Wish You Were Here |
WeepingBanana
08.22.11 | i don't think i ever 5'd anything upon first listen |
Electric City
08.22.11 | remain in light by talking heads and anything i listen to for the first time stoned |
Xplisit
08.22.11 | "I gave it a 5 while I was listening to the opening track for the first time."
dumb |
Emim
08.22.11 | Definitely Angel Dust and The Real Thing |
auberginedreams
08.22.11 | la dispute - somewhere at the bottom of the river...
circle takes the square - as the roots undo
i'm pretty sure my first two ratings were me 5ing them. |
ti0n
08.22.11 | Tool Aenima
Tool Lateralus
Animal Collective Feels
At the drive-in Relationship of Command
Built to Spill Perfect from now on
Modest Mouse Moon & Antarctica
Modest Mouse Building nothing out of something
|
xenocide.
08.22.11 | Tool - Aenima
Tool - Lateralus
Neurosis - Through Silver In Blood |
FromDaHood
08.22.11 | Prince- Purple Rain
Say Anything-... Is a Real Boy
Wu-Tang Clan- 36 Chambers
jack's Mannequin- Everything in Transit |
TheStefan
08.22.11 | Radiohead- OK Computer
i don't think i've ever 5'd something else after just 1 listen |
KimmsightMatters
08.22.11 | It usually takes me a while to rate an album, especially if I'm going to 5 it. Probably the quickest one I gave out was to
Guardians, but I think I'm going to change my rating to a 4.5 |
Knott-
08.22.11 | I think the only thing I've ever 5'd on first listen was
The Weakerthans - Live At Burton Cummings Theatre |
omnipanzer
08.22.11 | I would easily 5 this Dole Mandarins in Orange Jello I'm eating right now.
It's Delicious! |
KimmsightMatters
08.22.11 | Ahh I love fruit in jello! |
JamieTwort
08.22.11 | ^upon first taste? |
omnipanzer
08.22.11 | First taste! |
Irving
08.22.11 | The Decemberists' Crane Wife. |
CrisStyles
08.22.11 | High Violet from The National |
Drsmith4
08.22.11 | Radiohead - Kid A
|
North0House2
08.22.11 | LYSFLATH by GY!BE
F#A# (infinity) by GY!BE
Spiderland by Slint
TDAGARIM by Brand New
Tunnel Blanket by This Will Destroy You |
wyankeif1337
08.22.11 | Isis - Panopticon
GY!BE - Slow Riot... |
ThusSpokeZarathustra
08.22.11 | JOY DIVISION - CLOSER
Though these were pretty easy too:
Joy Division – Unknown Pleasures
Burzum – s/t
Burzum – Hvis Lyset Tar Oss
Graveland – Thousand Swords
Morbid Angel – Altars of Madness
Beherit – Drawing Down the Moon
|
ThusSpokeZarathustra
08.22.11 | Oops.. just realized I hadn't got around to rating the Joy Division albums, lolz.
'Closer' is probably my all-time favourite though.. |
dammets
08.22.11 | Atheist-Unquestionable Presence
Not sure about Angel Dust. I didn't think about stuff like this when I first listened to it, let alone even knowing that this site exists. |
Maniac!
08.22.11 | Tool - Aenima
Goodie Mob - Soul Food
Black Sabbath - Heaven and Hell |
Mewcopa0
08.22.11 | Electric Wizard - Dopethrone
Mr Bungle - California
Death - Symbolic |
aok
08.22.11 | kid a kid a kid a |
FrankRedHot
08.22.11 | Your mom |
JJwins
08.22.11 | F#A# (infinity) by GY!BE |
MentalityOfA
08.22.11 | Wonder What's Next, The Moon & Antarctica, Halo 3: ODST OST and Cities. Brother, Sister too. |
robertsona
08.22.11 | talk talk - laughing stock |
ffs
08.22.11 | i can only 5 an album after days of meditations and deliberating w/ the ancient pagan gods |
Motiv3
08.22.11 | pink floyd - wish you were here
opeth - blackwater park
edge of sanity - crimson II |
clercqie
08.22.11 | Don't forget the goat sacrifice to make the gods happy with your decision... |
ApplicationToHeaven
08.22.11 | slow riot for new zero zero kanada
|
plane
08.22.11 | James Blake - James Blake
Led Zeppelin - IV
Animal Collective - Merriweather Post Pavilion/Fall Be Kind
Built to Spill - Perfect From Now On
King Crimson - Red
Storm and Stress - Under Thunder and Fluorescent Light
Women - Public Strain
The Smiths - The Queen is Dead
|
MountainDewMe
08.22.11 | Eminem- The Marshall Mathers Lp. |
lucasjcockcroft
08.22.11 | blink-182, S/T |
YetAnotherBrick
08.22.11 | F#A#(Infinity) was an insta-5 for me. |
elephantREVOLUTION
08.22.11 | fun. - aim and ignite
fucking classic. |
nylertickel2
08.22.11 | Between the Buried and Me - Colours/The Great Misdirect
Protest the Hero - Fortress
Alexisonfire - Watch Out!
|
MudIdol
08.22.11 | Tool-Aenima
The Red Chord-Fused together in revolving doors
Mudvayne-the end of all things to come |
Acanthus
08.22.11 | The Prodigy - The Fat of The Land
The Cure - Disintegration |
patroneyes
08.22.11 | dj shadow - endtroducing
gza - liquid swords
dinosaur jr - you're living all over me
coltrane - a love supreme
my bloody valentine - loveless
the clash - london calling
jay-z - reasonable doubt |
ITsHxCTOASTER
08.22.11 | I'm going to be a generic sputniker here and say Lift Your Skinny Fists Like Antennas To Heaven and F#A#(Infinity). But also these:
Mew - Frengers
Sufjan Stevens - Illinois
The Reign of Kindo - This Is What Happens |
paxman
08.22.11 | Can't really think of any that I would five without hesitation, because I'm very analytical. I guess it'd have to be something that ultimately blew me away on first listen.
Dredg - El Cielo
Tool - Lateralus
Coheed and Cambria - Secrets of Silent Earth
BtBaM - Colors
Defeater - Lost Ground
Rush - Moving Pictures
Trophy Scars - Never Born, Never Dead
|
SaneTBP
08.22.11 | Tool - Lateralus
Kashiwa Daisuke - Program Music I |
Baphomet
08.22.11 | Shpongle - Nothing Lasts... But Nothing is Lost |
Yotimi
08.22.11 | Flaming Lips - The Soft Bulletin
Flaming Lips - Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots
Radiohead - Kid A
Radiohead - OK Computer
Saves the Day - Stay What You Are
Sunny Day Real Estate - How It Feels to be Something On
Bjork - Homogenic
All my others had to grow on me to a 5 |
AliW1993
08.22.11 | I've never 5'd an album until I've listened at least 2 times.
For Emma, Forever Ago is the easiest 4.5 I've ever given (I've subsequently bumped it to a 5). |
IrishJay91
08.22.11 | Black Sabbath - Black Sabbath
Iron Maiden - Powerslave
Cynic - Focus |
sportsboy
08.22.11 | btbam - colors (of course)
miles davis - bitches brew
beatles - sgt pepper
cowboy bebop ost
spongebob squarepants movie ost |
ShadowRemains
08.22.11 | close to a world below |
TheSpirit
08.22.11 | your mom
your mom
your mom
your mom
your mom |
FearThyEvil9
08.22.11 | Defeater-Travels
Tool-Lateralus |
ShadowRemains
08.22.11 | "your mom
your mom
your mom
your mom
your mom"
moar like a 10 |
derekkp
08.22.11 | animals |
wabbit
08.22.11 | you guys are doing a lot of lying.
Frank Turner- Love Ire and Song
I 5ed it before I knew prufrock before he got famous finished. |
Clamface
08.22.11 | Brother/Sister - mewithoutYou |
luschlotz
08.22.11 | 2,3, Sgt Peppers, Kid A, Hail To The Thief, Kind Of BLue, Time Out |
MisterSteel
08.22.11 | Mind.In.A.Box. - Crossroads |
cirq
08.22.11 | fuckin spirit took my post |
wabbit
08.22.11 | man I'm so elite I 5 jazz albums before I've even heard them #Sputnik |
pwalcher
08.22.11 | When I first listened to "White Pony" I 5'd it after one listen. Then I listened to "Around the Fur" and then "Diamond Eyes" started to sprout wings and resonate well so I had to move White Pony down to a 4/5 because it simply didn't compare. Only time that's happened. |
rockandmetaljunkie
08.22.11 | "i can only 5 an album after days of meditations and deliberating w/ the ancient pagan gods"
lol |
HaloDude442
08.22.11 | Counterparts - Prophets |
bry11
08.22.11 | Deftones - White Pony
Smashing Pumpkins - Siamese Dream |
FatChickIrl
08.22.11 | NSV |
fromtheinside
08.22.11 | I don't 5 albums they 5 me |
OrangeHologram
08.22.11 | radiohead |
tarkus
08.22.11 | In the court of the crimson king
|
Sanders
08.22.11 | "Frank Turner- Love Ire and Song
I 5ed it before I knew prufrock before he got famous finished."
The first time I heard that song I got ridiculous goosebumps. Still do when that build-up pays off. |
linchpin313
08.22.11 | Dry Kill Logic - The Darker Side Of Nonsense |
Torii
08.22.11 | The Beatles - Abbey Road
ISIS - Panopticon
Coheed and Cambria - SSTB
dredg - El Cielo
Discordance Axis - The Inalienable Dreamless
... Oh and: you guys are doing a lot of lying. [2] |
TheNotrap
08.22.11 | 5/5 without hesitation:
Pink Floyd-The Dark Side of the Moon. Best record ever made IMO
Iron Maiden-Powerslave. Best Metal album ever recorded IMO
Iron Maiden-Live After Death. Best live album ever recorded IMO
|
Mchailas
08.22.11 | Close to the edge... Opening riff, insta 5 |
Omaha
08.22.11 | LYSFLATH by GY!BE
Blood Sugar Sex Magik- RHCP |
Josh D.
08.22.11 | I don't know, probably The Moon Is A Dead World and Powerslave. |
Asiatic667
08.22.11 | Joy Division - Closer |
crazyblinddude
08.22.11 | Figuring that I had a lot of my 5's before I ever started rating, I guess the only album is De-Loused. The rest grew on me. |
coneren
08.22.11 | Dirt |
kangaroopoo
08.22.11 | Tool – Aenima
GNR – Appetite
Kyuss – Sky Valley
Pig Destroyer – Terrifyer
Cog – The New Normal
Porcupine Tree – FOABP
Smashing Pumpkins – Siamese Dream |
Jethro42
08.22.11 | Close to the edge... Opening riff, insta 5 [2] |
whywontyoudie
08.22.11 | Miranda Cosgrove- Sparks Fly |
gotsthedewsdood
08.22.11 | i don't think an immediate 5 marks the excellence of an album. |
danielito19
08.22.11 | Bubblegum Octopus - 8 legged Dance Moves |
climactic
08.22.11 | dark side, blackwater park |
andcas
08.22.11 | I love the beautiful and dark aura of afi's sing the sorrow. easy 5. |
iFghtffyrdmns
08.22.11 | oh you know, all the good ones. |
someguest
08.22.11 | nothing in your list is a 5 |
HBFS
08.22.11 | the wild hunt |
ECRbubs
08.23.11 | Aeroplane |
RagingStorm
08.23.11 | it takes a while for me to give anything a 5 but the monitor i guess |
MickeyPHager
08.23.11 | Brand New - Deja Entend/ The Devil And God Are Raging Inside Me
Bright Eyes - I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning
Radiohead - Ok Computer |
GnarlyShillelagh
08.23.11 | 5'd Mono's Hymn to the Immortal Wind right after I heard it for the first time.
Still my favorite album of all time. |
nnnope
08.23.11 | Radiohead - In Rainbows |
JamieTwort
08.23.11 | "nothing in your list is a 5"
Says the guy with one of these album's 5'd... |
TheNotrap
08.23.11 | Hahaha ups... |
RCKilm
08.23.11 | btmi - scrambles
and la dispute / TA split.
i think those are my only 5s anyway. |
PayneTiger777
08.23.11 | The Mayan Factor - 44 |
Masochist
08.23.11 | Easiest 5 for me was Pink Floyd's 'Wish You Were Here,' King Crimson's 'In The Court of the Crimson King' and Nas's 'Illmatic'. |
GnFnRs87
08.26.11 | Pink Floyd- Wish You Were Here
Guns N' Roses- Appetite For Destruction
Black Sabbath- Master of Reality
Metallica- Ride the Lightning
Iron Maiden- Number of the Beast |
Knave
08.28.11 | I never 5d something after the first listen |
FromDaHood
08.28.11 | Ur so elite |
PedalToTheMetal
09.20.11 | mewithoutYou - Catch For Us The Foxes
Rosetta - A Determinism Of Morality
Underoath - Define The Great Line
Karnivool - Sound Awake
Arcade Fire - Funeral |
pcar
09.20.11 | Illmatic probably |
jdennis31
09.20.11 | thrice - vheissu
thrice - major/minor
trophy scars - darkness, oh hell
tallest man on earth - the wild hunt |
illmitch
09.20.11 | the high 5 i gave to my bro after we double teamed ur mom |
slutnik
09.20.11 | Majoras Mask and OoT Soundtracks |
toxin.
09.20.11 | None, I'd say. The closest to a 5 automatically was probably Red-Innocence & Instinct though but it had time to grow before I joined Sputnik. |
taroo
09.20.11 | Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here
Yes - Close to the Edge
Mother 3i
Team Shanghai Alice - Changeability of Strange Dream
Sound Horizon - Elysion
GZA - Liquid Swords
Johnny Cash - At Folsom Prison
Patti Smith - Horses |
DinoX
09.20.11 | pg.99- document 8
circle takes the square- as the roots undo
|
TheJackal
05.28.12 | Refused- Shape Of Punk To Come
Elliott Smith- Either/Or |
Jethro42
05.28.12 | countless |
Lelle
05.28.12 | I've never given an instant 5 (or many 5's at all for that matter), the best music takes a while to fully grasp, and if it's REALLY good you are still discovering things years later |
The7thVermicide
05.28.12 | Pink Floyd-Wish You Were Here
Megadeth-Rust In Peace
Opeth-Blackwater Park
Massive Attack-Mezzanine
Anathema-Judge
Nightwish-Oceanborn
The Mars Volta-Frances The Mute |
rockandmetaljunkie
05.28.12 | "the best music takes a while to fully grasp"
I can't say for sure if this stands me. There are some albums which i 5'd upon the first listen. Some artists are so good that you don't have to listen to them twice to grasp their magic. |
Venpts16
05.28.12 | Megadeth - Rust in Peace
Testament - The New Order
Blind Guardian - Imaginations From the Other Side
Gamma Ray - Somewhere Out in Space
Dark Tranquillity - The Gallery |
UnnamedOcean
05.28.12 | Both LYSF and F# by Godspeed and Talk Talk. |
londoncalling457
05.28.12 | real estate- days
yes- close to the edge
sabbath- master of reality |
Gwynbleiddsfang
05.28.12 | Brand New - TDaGaRIM
Radiohead - OK Computer (i also rated KID A with a 5, but that one took a while)
System of a Down - S/T
off the top of my head |
plane
05.28.12 | Storm and Stress - Under Thunder and Fluorescent Light |
expire
05.28.12 | have heart - the things we carry |
plane
05.28.12 | "i can only 5 an album after days of meditations and deliberating w/ the ancient pagan gods"
;D |
treos777
05.29.12 | The Receiving End of Sirens-The Earth Sings Mi Fa Mi
Manchester Orchestra-Mean Everything to Nothing
The Felix Culpa-Sever Your Roots
Thrice-Major/Minor
|
BlueW
05.29.12 | Kyary Pamyu Pamyu Pamyu Pamyu Revolution |
Scoot
05.29.12 | endtroducing
everything goes numb
wish you were here
pree much the only ones, the rest have taken a lot of time. i need to fix some of my 5s that are no longer classics to me. hell, the moon is a dead world is my favorite album of all time and it took months before it grew on me |
Spec
05.29.12 | Goodbye Cool World I think then like Wish You Were Here but that's obvious.
And Yankee Hotel Foxtrot.
And Geogaddi. |
Spec
05.29.12 | And maybe Mezz.
Yeah mezz. |
ChuckyTruant
05.29.12 | Rush - discog |
HitlerIsGod
05.29.12 | Agalloch - The Mantle
Warning - Watching From a Distance
The Antlers - In the Attic of the Universe
In Flames - Whoracle, The Jester Race
Lustmord - Heresy
Ulver - Bergtatt |
MyNameIsPencil
04.29.13 | Weezer - The Blue Album
Portishead - Dummy
Led Zeppelin IV
Deftones - White Pony
Foo Fighters - The Colour and the Shape |
toxin.
04.29.13 | 2BA Master |
Chortles
04.29.13 | Better Music - discog |
demigod93
04.29.13 | bizarre ride 2 the pharcyde
animals
keasbey nights
liquid swords
jane doe
loveless |
Keyblade
04.29.13 | Music Has the Right to Children
lemon squeezy |
DrMaximus
04.29.13 | No question, Ulver- Bergtatt
|
johnnydeking29
04.29.13 | None
Closest thing to it would be Oceansize - Frames |
lou1000
04.29.13 | Radiohead - OK Computer/Kid A
Burial - Untrue |
ViralOblivion
04.29.13 | Death- human and symbolic
Athiest- unquestionable presence |
demigod93
04.29.13 | oh yea kid a too |
toxin.
04.29.13 | None, I'd say. The closest to a 5 automatically was probably Red-Innocence & Instinct though but it had time to grow before I joined Sputnik. [2] |
zakalwe
04.29.13 | R.E.M - Automatic
Nirvana - Nevermind, Generation definer that blew the doors open,was instantly identifiable and still rocks to this day. |
Yotimi
04.29.13 | Only album I knew was a 5 before finishing it was Soft Bulletin |
DikkoZinner
04.29.13 | 2 & 10 |
ZilbelPing
04.29.13 | TDAGARIM by Brand New and F#A#oo by GY!BE
The one that took me the longest was Bad Luck by Trophy Scars but I fucking love it now. |
gwynbleidd
04.29.13 | Not counting albums I heard before i started really using this website...
Jane Doe
Madvillainy
The Heat Death of the Universe
Worship and Tribute
Leaves Turn Inside You |
Kman418
04.29.13 | the arrogant sons of bitches - three cheers for disappointment
bomb the music industry - scrambles
converge - jane doe
the arrogant sons of bitches - three cheers for disappointment
glassjaw - worship and tribute
the arrogant sons of bitches - three cheers for disappointment |
Arnaud
04.29.13 | F#A#oo was also automaticly a classic when I first listened to it, but LYSF took more time to digest. |
Arnaud
04.29.13 | Haven't seen The Seer being mentioned above, anyone instant 5'd it? |
Cygnatti
04.29.13 | taylor swift - discography |
StallionMang
04.29.13 | Endtroducing
Frances The Mute
Dark Side of the Moon
In The Aeroplane Over the Sea
OK Computer
311: Greatest Hits '93-'03 (laugh if you want) |
climactic
04.29.13 | fucking POWERSLAVE |