skippingboy123: What Makes a 5 Star Album?

MetallicOpeth 02.05.11	I guess it's just an album you listen to and you just know it's great music that's well put together with great songwriting and exhibits alot of different emotions.
couldwinarabbit 02.05.11	thom yorke. Also OKC #1 on rym charts bitches.
Spec 02.05.11	You have to wait for the mods to tell you it's five worthy.
fr33convict 02.05.11	"rI think rrating an album a 5, means that you have listened to it so many times that you know rmost of rthe lyrics>rYou listened to it alot, then came back to it a year later and like it more than you rorignally rliked it>rIf it greatly influenced many of today's music or revolutionized music for rthe good>rIf it has emotionally impacted you>rI think some of my 4.5 albums are worthy of ra 5" wait wut
Defeater 02.05.11	I have a few requirements: #1: No black members in the band (the opposite for rap). #2: No breakdowns declaring love for Jesus Christ. #3: No albums Bitchfork rates a 5. #4: No keyboard solos. #5: No Rush albums.
fr33convict 02.05.11	#6: No music with fans that's too mainstream.
Spec 02.05.11	If they have more than fifty fans, fuck it.
Defeater 02.05.11	a jacob bannon keyboard solo
Spec 02.05.11	YES A JACOB BANNON KEYBOARD SOLO!
skippingboy123 02.05.11	So the Beatles are too mainstream obivously?
eternium 02.05.11	Something that's simply of extremely high quality with the vast majority of songs being awesome. Something that connects to me emotionally to a strong degree. Something that has been very influential in the music world. Basically those three things to a certain degree. The third one helps for older albums.
bloc 02.05.11	It's definitely a number of things and they change depending on the listener. One of them for me is that it should playable anytime and anywhere no matter what kind of mood I am in.
eternium 02.05.11	I disagree with that. I'm not always in the mood to listen to Brand New because it gets me all emotional and shit, for example.
FromDaHood 02.05.11	Mine tend to have significance to me in some way as well as being really good
bloc 02.05.11	"I disagree with that. I'm not always in the mood to listen to Brand New because it gets me all emotional and shit, for example." That's understandable. But I usually don't let my music interfere with my emotions.
eternium 02.05.11	Is that not what part of connecting to music is?
tiesthatbind 02.05.11	It must have at least a 4.4 average rating on sputnikmusic.com
Deviant. 02.05.11	"It's definitely a number of things and they change depending on the listener. One of them for me is that it should playable anytime and anywhere no matter what kind of mood I am in." Hmmm, yes and no for me. There are times when I choose not to listen to a certain album because I simply can't have that one album as simply background music, I have to focus my attention on it. Some albums obviously work better at different times - Endtroducing is one. Always a great album, but it takes on a life of its own when you play it at night
bloc 02.05.11	"Is that not what part of connecting to music is? " Sure, but I'm not going to start crying when I'm listening to The Angelic Process or something
Ire 02.05.11	lol classic devient
fr33convict 02.05.11	"Sure, but I'm not going to start crying when I'm listening to The Angelic Process or something" You ain't a real man if you don't cry.
Deviant. 02.05.11	"That's understandable. But I usually don't let my music interfere with my emotions." Futurepop is a deeply personal genre that connects with its listeners on a multitude of intertwining layers. The maturity and depth with which its core artists handle their subject matter is second to none I'm blue, lada dee lada da
eternium 02.05.11	The Angelic Process is so close to a 5 for me..
fr33convict 02.05.11	It's an absolute 5 for me. It's just so perfect.
Ire 02.05.11	didn't know you could rate a band a 5
Dryden 02.05.11	no its not
fr33convict 02.05.11	"didn't know you could rate a band a 5" it's a secret sputnik feature
bloc 02.05.11	"Futurepop is a deeply personal genre that connects with its listeners on a multitude of intertwining layers. The maturity and depth with which its core artists handle their subject matter is second to none" Now you speaky my language
tiesthatbind 02.05.11	Futurelol
bloc 02.05.11	tiesthatblind
tiesthatbind 02.05.11	bloc...my ears from the futurepop
fr33convict 02.05.11	bloc idk i couldn't think of one
crowing51 02.05.11	what makes a 5? Coheed and Cambria yea thats about it.
bloc 02.05.11	tiesthatbind me from loving futurepop
fr33convict 02.05.11	tiesthatblocmydeviantfrombindingtotheacademy
tiesthatbind 02.05.11	bloc wins
fr33convict 02.05.11	WELL OF COURSE BLOC WINS racist
bloc 02.05.11	He is loyal
fr33convict 02.05.11	to his fellow klansmen
zarquan99 02.06.11	just 5 all of our 5's and then you'll be cool and non-conformist
acorncheese 02.06.11	5 when it's more than just music to you. Albums you couldn't live without. Albums you've listened to 100+ times and are still not tired of.
ShadowRemains 02.06.11	"#6: No music with fans that's too mainstream." dumbest thing i've ever read
zarquan99 02.06.11	I'm not gonna include Pink Floyd in my top 10 of the 70's list because they're so mainstream now
BlueW 02.06.11	It's a five if I personally think it deserves so
climactic 02.06.11	an album where all the songs are very high quality and interesting an album that made a huge impact on music that is still very enjoyable (timeless) an album that connects with you emotionally and makes you keep listening over and over or any combination of the 3
fr33convict 02.06.11	"dumbest thing i've ever read" It's the mentality a lot of people have on this site to be honest.
couldwinarabbit 02.06.11	like everyone who says nirvana sucks.
Butkuiss 02.06.11	Basically, it's just an album that has great emotional impact or significance on or for me. That's basically it.
foreverendeared 02.06.11	I dunno I just 5 shit I like
astrel 02.06.11	Here is what makes a 5 star album for me. 1. Go to the drop down box that says rate it. 2. Click on said box 3. Align the mouse to the 5 - Classic score 4. Click it (this part is crucial)
nsbm 02.06.11	shit wasn't funny yo
astrel 02.06.11	I am not joking. Now Necrophagist, that guy has the right idea.
MetallicOpeth 02.06.11	he would if they would release an album less than every 7 years
DrEpic4181 02.21.11	great albums, pinkerton/abbey road ftw