Some of your comments don't make sense in relation to the ranking. But oh well, my list is fairly similar, I would trade spots with Torbjorn and Soldier 34. I would also trade spots between Symmetrail and Reinhart.
Just played for the first time tonight. Didn't try many characters, but I was averaging a 5+ k/d with Soldier 76 and Tracer was aight for auxiliary slaying and objective play, but can't carry for shit.