Counterfeit
07.12.10 | FUCKING TELL ME GAIZ |
8bit
07.12.10 | ITS JUST CUZ.... JUST CUZ............ I DONNO ITS A SECRET |
ShadowRemains
07.12.10 | that it combines everything that you enjoy in that type of music into the album. |
vanderb0b
07.12.10 | Because Mike Patton is involved with it. |
SlightlyEpic
07.12.10 | qwe made me |
Inveigh
07.12.10 | for me, a 5 has to have some sentimental value or emotional connection to me. So, whether I relate to the lyrics to a huge extent or the album's gotten me through tough times or was a gateway into a new style of music or somehow broadened my understanding on something (be it a genre or artist or way of thinking) -- there has to be something there that's bigger than just the music itself.
Generally, I have to like/love every song on the album as well and the album (generally, again) has to make some sort of cohesive, thematic statement rather than just being a collection of great songs. |
Romulus
07.12.10 | Inveigh just totally said what I was going to say
gotta love every track and the album has to have some special meaning for me |
Skybreaker
07.12.10 | Inveigh pretty much said it |
Nagrarok
07.12.10 | Yeah what Inveigh said. |
Yeahtoast
07.12.10 | Everything you said upto the staff part combined with what Shadow said is basically the makings of a 5 for me.
Also an album that you connect with on an emotional level or one that means something to you. |
Maniac!
07.12.10 | 1 was just for me, wasn't it feit? |
Counterfeit
07.12.10 | Inveigh wins. haha
And putting it on this list? Yes. 5'ing it? No. |
crazyblinddude
07.12.10 | like everyone else said. inveigh said it. |
Inveigh
07.12.10 | what inveigh said
errr, wait.. |
TheBaneofSputnik
07.12.10 | Don't let it get to your head, Blake. I mean, you were wrong about Bosh, James, and Wade, weren't you? As well as U.D. coming back, right?
Yes, I did it.
I brought basketball up again.
Big whoop, wanna fight about it? |
AnotherBrick
07.12.10 | something i can always listen to regardless of the mood i am in, never get sick of it, and love every second of it. |
acorncheese
07.12.10 | clas·sic (klsk)
winner |
Counterfeit
07.12.10 | Yeah 1 thing that really bothers me is skits. If they're too long/obnoxious that can stop me from 5ing it. Mostly that's just rap albums though. |
8bit
07.12.10 | It can't get old or stale. |
TheBaneofSputnik
07.12.10 | 8Bit- Ya, I know. The thoughts of the Heat dominating the league won't get old or stale. |
Counterfeit
07.12.10 | pfft. The motherfuckin Wolves are gonna dominate, wutchew talkin bout pit? |
TheBaneofSputnik
07.12.10 | yeah, michael beasley's going to be a 25 an 10 guy!!! I mean, we saw it while he was with the Heat, didn't we? |
acADHDemy
07.12.10 | if the album uses electric guitars OR fem vocalist -> 5 |
Inveigh
07.12.10 | Pit, if Miami fails to win the championship next season I will recruit as many users of Sputnik as I can to spam your lists and shoutbox with taunts for a full month. |
Parallels
07.12.10 | A 5 means a complete, flawless and classic album. The songs all work together to create a masterpiece of unrivaled work, one that rises above others and presents a influential stigma with no flaws whatsoever. |
Counterfeit
07.12.10 | Acad just gave us the best description for a 5 guys. Sorry Inveigh. |
luci
07.12.10 | For me a 5 can have a few 'poor' tracks or tracks that I don't particularly enjoy. It depends more on how high the highs are than if it has a few lows. |
acorncheese
07.12.10 | A 5/5 can be one of two things for me. 1) An album overflowing with nostalgia and sentiment. 2) An album that makes you look cooler than everyone else. |
pneumoniahawk93
07.12.10 | If an album can bring back vivid, deep memories for me and affect me emotionally, it's either a 5 or a 1.
The 1's are usually associated with nausea...aka Brokencyde. |
Prolapse
07.12.10 | I only give albums a 5 if they make me all tingly inside |
EVedder27
07.12.10 | if it's better than sex |
Romulus
07.12.10 | you know what I actually think that is a perfect method of deciding classicness |
Counterfeit
07.12.10 | Jane Doe makes you feel all tingly Johnny? |
Prolapse
07.12.10 | Shit yeah, especially when it super fucking loud |
Counterfeit
07.12.10 | hmm. I get all mad and sad at the same time. But to each their own I spose. |
Prolapse
07.12.10 | Well not really tingly, more like an explosion in your head |
8bit
07.12.10 | lol Timberwolves are going to finish dead last, yes, behind the Nets. And no those thoughts do not get stale and the Heat are going to get 3-4 championships in these next 6 years. |
Counterfeit
07.12.10 | Tha+ was the point 8bit. haha |
Dryden
07.12.10 | well its a 5 cuz |
Counterfeit
07.13.10 | cuz why? |
Dunpeal
07.13.10 | album gives good head |
