Foxhound
06.12.10 | lots of albums I liked in high school. |
Enotron
06.12.10 | The Deathly Hallows blew me away. though the order of the phoenix is my personal favorite. both are teh best. then the goblet of fire. then the half blood prince. i haven't read the others in a while. |
fr33convict
06.12.10 | 4
2
3
1
5
6
7 |
Foxhound
06.12.10 | it was good but a small part of me wanted to see Harry lose. |
erasedcitizen
06.12.10 | Goblet of Fire is the best. |
Obfuscation24
06.12.10 | Switch 5 and 6,but otherwise I completely agree
And nice digs btw, especially 5 (AFI/anything related to AFI fanboys unite)
|
Foxhound
06.12.10 | haha, yeah 5 + 6 are pretty close. Just listened to 5 this week, really good. |
Foxhound
06.12.10 | wait just listened to 6 this week, now idk what I'm talking about though. |
tiesthatbind
06.12.10 | 3
2
4
1
6
5
7 |
Dryden
06.12.10 | u ever have a harry potter movie series weed session night |
Comatorium.
06.13.10 | I didnt like order of the phoenix much.
That said, i agree with you on 1. |
Emim
06.13.10 | Blarg |
Foxhound
06.13.10 | srry dry. I can't really stand the movies :/ |
qwe3
06.13.10 | best is OoP then GoF then PoA etc but cool list Harry Potter rules |
Dryden
06.13.10 | neither can i, got invited to one a while back though and there was aloooooooooooooooot of weed i just snuck my ipod in and ignored everything around me ^_^ |
PuddlesPuddles
06.13.10 | PoA is wayy better than GoF
If I can remember |
Foxhound
06.13.10 | No way GoF is when all the death eaters came back! |
Masochist
06.13.10 | Good to see you got #'s 1 and 7 right ;-).
Gonna say mine goes something like this:
HBP
PoA
DH
GoF
OotP
SS
CoS
The only one that underwhelmed me was "Chamber of Secrets;" the only reason "Sorcerer's Stone" is so low is because the books became longer reads at #4 (but I just love "Prisoner of Azkeban" for its minimal Voldemort involvement). |
Transient
06.13.10 | WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE
Prisoner of Azkaban
Sorcerer's Stone
Goblet of Fire
Chamber of Secrets
Half-Blood Prince
Deathly Hallows (Snape twist was the best thing in the entire series)
Order of the Phoenix |
PanasonicYouth
06.13.10 | chamber of secrets is so fucking gay
and prisoner of azkaban needs to be higher |
Foxhound
06.13.10 | I could see switching PoA and SS but that's it. |
FadeToBlack
06.13.10 | harry potter and the philosopher's stone |
Foxhound
06.13.10 | haha! not in California it's not =) |
Gyromania
06.13.10 | The books can't be read out of context, and therefore no particular book is more important or enjoyable than the last, as there's continuity to it. The only book that doesn't focus on its premise is the fourth, but it's still important for character development and introductions. |
FadeToBlack
06.13.10 | dumbed down for people who cant spell |
McCopper
06.13.10 | Althought the chamber of secrets was a boring read, ashes against the grain is the best out of your albums.
Bookwise:
7
4
6
5
3
1
2 |
Gyromania
06.13.10 | In what universe is the second book the least compelling? If anything, I would argue that its plot is the most interesting and is one of the more important books leading towards the end of the series. It showcases Harry's secret adoration for Ginny and has Harry destroy his first Horcrux. I wish the book were longer, as its plot was so excellent. |
Foxhound
06.13.10 | I can't argue that CoS isn't important but alls I mean with the raniking is that HbP and OoP were stunning and I felt that the first three books seemed like the powder keg for something amazing which was the subsequent 4th - 7th books. |
tiesthatbind
06.13.10 | The first three definitely can't compare to the last four. Still, they're all good. |
Gyromania
06.13.10 | I agree that they are the pretext, but honestly, the only thing I didn't enjoy as much as every other book in the series was the Order of the Phoenix, which had so much pointless dialogue. It's a fun read, and is essential, with some intriguing parts to it, but it's such a daunting task to read it all. |
Foxhound
06.13.10 | I honestly wish each book was twice as long. |
fr33convict
06.13.10 | How to "grow out" of books being to long or pointless: read the entire dictionary in one sitting. That'll make anything seem short and condensed. |
Gyromania
06.13.10 | The only one that I'm sure J.K. Rowling would also feel was regrettably too short was The Chamber of Secrets. The first and third seem to have a decent length tbh. The first book starts things off, and the third is basically for character introduction; the second book should have been longer as it was going off the success of the first and was very intricate.
I hope that her next series is of the Marauders, how cool would that be? |
Foxhound
06.13.10 | next list: Harry Potter Vs Twilight |
FadeToBlack
06.13.10 | harry has a black cock
there i ruined ur wizadry fantasies |
ameypv
06.13.10 | ^ lol
i liked only 2 tbh |
Tulannical
06.13.10 | switch 2 & 3 and 5 & 6 and that's mine. |
AliW1993
06.13.10 | 6 and 7 are two of my favourites |
Static
06.13.10 | DEATHLY HALLOWS > ALL
FUCK Y'ALL NIGGZ |
Disconnected
06.13.10 | 1
4
6
3
2
7
5 |
Captain North
06.13.10 | Order is wrong. 7 is right, 1 is probably right from what I remember. But 3 was kinda crappy compared to 4 and 6. 6 was great too. |
Foxhound
06.13.10 | "Order is wrong."
made me chuckle. |
ThirtySixChambers
07.20.10 | Jesus christ you ranked these almost exactly the same as me. I'd switch 5 with 4 |
Aids
08.09.10 | I have a very similar ranking for HP books. Nice |
TBliss
08.09.10 | 3, 1 and 6 are the best I a reckon |
Lunarfall
08.09.10 | Last 4 > First 3
Can't really think of an order outside of that. |
Psilocyanide
08.09.10 | 3
5
1
6
4
7
2 |
Foxhound
08.27.10 | hope the 7th movie has lotsa violence |
BallsToTheWall
08.27.10 | Been listening to Ministry of Magic all day, I cannot wait to have another Harry Potter drinking night. |
8bit
08.27.10 | Hermoine's gonna be so hot man |
Foxhound
08.27.10 | I want a second harry potter type series from Rowling. Make it violent as hell and sex, drugs, killins all the cool stuff they didn't get in the first series. |
Ire
08.27.10 | The third movie sucked.
the latest was the best
oh yeah, harry potter is so gay |
Foxhound
08.27.10 | lol i can delete comments.. hmmmm, jk |
BallsToTheWall
08.27.10 | 6th movie sucked actually, third movie was good. Get your shit together son. |
PlayCrackSky
08.27.10 | From best to worst:
5
7
3
4
6
2
1
Hated the writing in HBP, loved it in Phoenix. Phoenix is the best written and most interesting one, so it wins. Azkaban does too for its plot-twist. And of course Deathly Hallows make the series come together really complexly and mind blowingly cuz everything makes such perfect sense. |
PlayCrackSky
08.27.10 | 6th movie sucked, 3rd was soooooo goooood. |
8bit
08.27.10 | Hermoine falcon punched Malfoy in the third movie. |
PlayCrackSky
08.27.10 | Also, it serves as a testament to how fucking good these are the no one's said "HRARY POTTR SUCKS" after 60 comments. |
Ire
08.27.10 | naaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhh |
Foxhound
08.27.10 | i'm usually tied with 5 and 6. but 6 cause i was stunned when snape killed dumbledore |
Slum
08.27.10 | Ahh the summer when I read all the books in a row was so great |
BallsToTheWall
08.27.10 | Hermoine falcon punched Malfoy in the third movie.
That made my night...ahh you guys should really try the game. |
dnor
08.27.10 | 1
7
6
4
5
3
2
imo |
taroo
08.27.10 | Harry Potter kind of inspired some of my own writing only if I only read the first three books (fourth book's beginning is as boring as hell, had to put it down) and I've only seen the first 5 movie and the ending of the 6th. |
Foxhound
08.27.10 | taroo... finish the series |
taroo
08.27.10 | ok... I'll try to read the forth book again... |
Foxhound
08.27.10 | lol you don't really have to. i personally can't find any boring parts in any of the harry potter books, but if you think the first part of the 4th book is slow trust me it gets better. |
ThirtySixChambers
08.27.10 | List is correct |
taroo
08.27.10 | I'm pretty sure it does, my brother told me it gets way better... but I don't read that much anyways... I write a lot though... I have dreams of being a fantasy novelist. huh...someday... |
Foxhound
08.27.10 | well good luck. read from the best, i'm sure it'll help conjure some new ideas for you. |
joshuatree
08.27.10 | ugh these books. looking forward to final movie(s) even though they always seem underwhelming. last one had some seriously breathtaking cinematography though
and deathly hollows is my favorite hp book, that final snape twist just did me in on first read. though i do tend to ignore that chessy epilogue |
robertsona
08.27.10 | fifth movie was the worst one but sixth was an improvement
need to rewatch first four but iirc they were all varying levels of good |
BallsToTheWall
08.27.10 | fifth movie was the worst one but sixth was an improvement
complete opposite im afraid. |
robertsona
08.27.10 | fifth movie was like boring nothing happened snooze |
BallsToTheWall
08.27.10 | LOL that was the entire 6th movie + Twilight level of excessive romance. |
joshuatree
08.27.10 | 6th movie took out best part of 6th book
but it hardly had "excessive romance" even though i'm not sure what twilight level excessive romance is bc i haven't seen one of those yet |
PlayCrackSky
08.27.10 | Yeah too much Twilight competing I agree. I liked the way they handled Draco + also Dumbledore's death. |
Masochist
08.27.10 | (I hate when you edit a comment and it takes out all the line breaks...) |
Masochist
08.27.10 | Balls: I believe it was you who said of the sixth movie, "Twilight: Wizard Edition" (If Waior's Sputnikmovies spoof is to be believed)
BOOKS:
6
3
7
4
5
1
2
MOVIES:
6
5
1
2
3
4
Also...I didn't realize how old this list was, nor did I realize that I had already posted in it :-P. Hahaha...at least the book ranking is still the same! |
Rugter32
08.27.10 | My own rating:
3
5
7
4
6
1
2
...Wait, that's eerily similar to how I rate the arcs of Umineko thus far... I see how that works... |
Electric City
08.27.10 | really? why does everyone hate prisoner of azkaban so much? |
ThirtySixChambers
08.27.10 | Besides Sirius Black, it didn't have all that much going for it. Of course I still thoroughly enjoyed it, but it's by far the weakest |
Electric City
08.27.10 | deathly hallows is pretty bad
half blood prince
prisoner of azkaban
goblet of fire
order of the phoenix
deathly hallows
chamber of secrets
sorcerer's stone |
ThirtySixChambers
08.27.10 | You got beef with Sorcerer's? |
PuddlesPuddles
08.27.10 | Sorcerer's is 2nd worst to of course chamber of secrets |
Hyperion1001
08.27.10 | The books were written how they are ranked. First were good, after the Goblet of Fire, they blew. 1,2,3,4,5,6,7 |
Foxhound
09.12.10 | Harry Potter guyz |
TMobotron
09.12.10 | deathly hallows sucked dick |
wyankeif1337
09.12.10 | You kidding me? Deathly Hallows was the shit. |
Foxhound
09.12.10 | I think hermione could have been raped or something, at least brutally kill off a main character.. what i was hoping for anyway... |
wyankeif1337
09.12.10 | Well, none of them were really brutal killings, but a shitload of primary characters did die...
Fred, Lupin, Tonks, Hedwig, Snape, Creevy, and more I'm forgetting. My point is that there was more than enough killing for me. |
Foxhound
09.12.10 | I wanted the book to go in a way darker, more adult direction. if she ever makes a new series i'll be crossing my fingers. |
wyankeif1337
09.12.10 | Well, maybe it didn't go that dark, but it was darker than all the previous books. |
Foxhound
11.21.10 | sharin the love |
Emim
11.21.10 | Blarg |
andcas
11.21.10 | http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pSwy412nttI
|
Strider
11.21.10 | I prefer my ranking |
TheEnigmaPrognosis
07.26.11 | Great list, but mine's along the lines of
1. Prisoner of Azkaban : This deals with some of the most abstract magical concepts I can even imagine.
2. Goblet of Fire : Brilliant book from top to bottom, introduced a long-time fav (Mad-Eye), and the tasks were really cool.
3. Deathly Hallows : I thought the first act of the book was good, but the 2nd was amazing!
4. Half-Blood Prince : So much character was packed into this book, I just ate it up.
5. Chamber of Secrets : Thought the mystery-solving for the heir of Slytherin was awesome.
6. Philosopher's Stone : 'Twas the initial adventure, and was obviously great reading about Harry discovering magic for the first time.
7. Order of the Phoenix : Kind of bored me during long stretches of the book, however certain portions made up for it. |
TheEnigmaPrognosis
07.26.11 | Great list, but mine's along the lines of
1. Prisoner of Azkaban : This deals with some of the most abstract magical concepts I can even imagine.
2. Goblet of Fire : Brilliant book from top to bottom, introduced a long-time fav (Mad-Eye), and the tasks were really cool.
3. Deathly Hallows : I thought the first act of the book was good, but the 2nd was amazing!
4. Half-Blood Prince : So much character was packed into this book, I just ate it up.
5. Chamber of Secrets : Thought the mystery-solving for the heir of Slytherin was awesome.
6. Philosopher's Stone : 'Twas the initial adventure, and was obviously great reading about Harry discovering magic for the first time.
7. Order of the Phoenix : Kind of bored me during long stretches of the book, however certain portions made up for it. |
Masochist
07.26.11 | I posted my list twice already; not posting it again.
Will say that Prisoner was my favorite book until #6; still second favorite though. Also, just got done watching the last movie earlier today...maybe my favorite movie. The Pensieve scene was perfect. |
taxidermist
07.26.11 | You finally saw it ey mas? The pensieve scene was fucking perfect. |
pwalcher
07.26.11 | haha chamber of secrets gets so much hate, it's just unfortunate that it along with order of the phoenix are mediocre compared to the rest, the series is soooo good |
AliW1993
07.26.11 | Chamber Of Secrets is my favourite of the early books, I just wish it was longer.
|
Masochist
07.26.11 | "You finally saw it ey mas? The pensieve scene was fucking perfect."
Yeah...sis and I finally found time to see it together. Was so excited, because there were certain parts that reminded me of the earlier movies, which absolutely capture the magic (no pun intended) of the books. |
wyankeif1337
07.26.11 | yeah, the movie rocked. |
HelplessnessBlues
07.26.11 | mine would have to be:
1. Order of the Phoenix
2. Deathly Hallows
3. Half Blood Prince
4. Goblet Of Fire
5. Chamber Of Secrets
6. Sorcer's Stone
7. Prisoner of Azkaban |
