GnarlyShillelagh
03.18.10 | Obviously in reverse order.
After posting this list, I am sure to be UNFORGIVEN LOLOL fuck James Hetfield |
Sowing
03.18.10 | death magnetic > load, reload |
Dylan620
03.18.10 | What's with the numbers (like 3.7, 3.6, etc.)? |
ninjuice
03.18.10 | How the hell is DM not better than Load/Reload? |
GnarlyShillelagh
03.18.10 | Numbers are my personal rating.
DM is worse than Load/Reload because I expected greatness when it came out and it sucked dick. |
ninjuice
03.18.10 | DM has more than 1 great song, which makes it better than the other two. |
Skybreaker
03.18.10 | What the hel? Just because you expected DM to be amazing doesn't mean it had to be to be a good album.
Sure, they aren't reinventing MoP, but it's a good album in it's own right. It IS better than Reload, and probably better than Load too. |
Curse.
03.18.10 | Just wondering, why were you expecting greatness with the ratings you have up of all of their other albums? |
GnarlyShillelagh
03.18.10 | I didn't actually listen to it until like a year after it came out 'cause I figured it would be the same old Metallica bullshit.
But my friends insisted it was like no other Metallica album they had ever heard and that it was so fucking good so I got it and then I killed them all for being wrong as fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuk. |
Inveigh
03.18.10 | I'm usually all for, like, other people's opinions and stuff, but this is list is wrong dude. |
GnarlyShillelagh
03.18.10 | may i ask why |
hando
03.18.10 | hahahahhahahaha |
kitteezrfunnieslawlz
03.18.10 | you say this is the greatest band ever but you gave all but two albums terrible ratings and the last four deserve above a three at least out of a five |
GnarlyShillelagh
03.18.10 | hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhaahaha |
Baphomet
03.18.10 | this is so wrong in so many ways |
killrobotmusic
03.18.10 | AJFA is the best man and i don't even like metallica that much. |
Trundle
03.18.10 | obvious troll is obvious |
sniper
03.18.10 | This list is right! seriously though, fuck Metallica after Justice. And kinda before that too. |
bungy
03.18.10 | and during justice |
paxman
03.18.10 | List sucks dick even more than Hetfield. |
GnarlyShillelagh
03.18.10 | No I'm not a troll I'm legit Metallica sucks |
TRMshadow
03.18.10 | Squeeze 2 in between 4 & 5 and you'll have my list |
Parallels
03.18.10 | wow he got the ratings right on too! awesome list man! |
qwe3
03.18.10 | best band ever is Queen list is invalid |
Trundle
03.18.10 | cool story, bro |
DoubtGin
03.18.10 | sucks |
Captain North
03.18.10 | How can they be the greatest band ever if their best album isn't even a 4? |
tiesthatbind
03.18.10 | Lol I'm pretty sure the "Greatest Band Ever" title is sarcasm. |
Captain North
03.18.10 | That'll teach me for not reading the comments. |
Knott-
03.18.10 | itt lots of people that dont get he was kidding |
NeutralThunder12
03.18.10 | lol Metallica is so good. |
BigHans
03.18.10 | Massive Fail. |
bloc
03.18.10 | GIMME FUE
GIMME FIE
GIMME DABAJABAZA |
KILL
03.18.10 | faggot list js |
Zipzop5565
03.18.10 | Metallica is good bro |
qwe3
03.18.10 | metallica is alright MoP and Justice are 4+ but Queen is the greatest band ever fuckoff everyone |
theacademy
03.18.10 | kill em all and unforgiven II are the only great metallica entries |
bungy
03.18.10 | Metallica is best when it's actually a different band. |
