|UserAlbum Ratings 177Objectivity 68%Last Active 11-17-09 3:45 pmJoined 09-09-09Forum Posts 0Review Comments 36
|Best Afi Albums|
My favorite AFI albums ranked. The top 4 can be switched based on my mood as I think they are all amazing albums. The other 3 are where they are because of changed tastes over the years.
Black Sails In The Sunset
This CD is number 1 because this is when I first discovered AFI. The first song I ever heard by AFI was God Called in Sick Today and I was hooked. Other standouts on this cd are: Malleus Maleficarum, Porphyria Cutanea Tarda, No Poetic Device, and every other song is great also.
Sing The Sorrow
Standout Tracks are: Leaving Song Pt. 2, Girls Not Grey, Death of Seasons, Silver and Cold, ...But Home Is Nowhere, and the hidden track This Time Imperfect. Once again I can listen to this whole song without changing any tracks.
The Art Of Drowning
I think this is AFI's first nearly perfect CD. Black Sails is great but there are a few songs that are not great, every song on this CD is great imo. Standouts: 6 to 8, Wester, The Days Of the Phoenix, Of Greeting and Goodbyes, A Story at Three, The Lost Souls, and of course Morningstar.
Now when I said that all 4 albums can be switched, I really meant it. I enjoy all 4 of these albums alot and give almost all of them the same rating, DU took AFI in a new direction, as every CD does, and it was a little more poppy, some people didn't like it, I liked it alot and thought it was another great album. Standouts: Love Like Winter, Summer Shudder, Affliction, Kiss and Control, The Killing Lights, 37mm, Endlessly She Said, this is one of there more complete albums I think in terms of all songs having the same feel.
Very Proud Of Ya
One of the first real punk albums I ever heard and can still listen to today. Alot of good punk songs on here, some of the standouts: He Who Laughs Last.., Fishbowl, File 13, This Secret Ninja, Soap Box Derby, Advances In Modern Technology, Wake-Up Call, and a few other standouts, overall solid punk album.
Shut Your Mouth and Open Your Eyes
The followup to Very Proud Of Ya had some high expectations from me and it barely missed it which is why I rate it lower than Very Proud Of Ya even though there are some tracks on here that blow that CD away. Standouts: Three Reasons, A Single Second (still one of their best songs to date), Third Season and ph Low.
Answer That and Stay Fashionable
Overall a ok album. It can be ranked either 6 or 7, but because of the quality of the audio I'm putting it 7, even though Brownie Bottom Sundae is still one of my favorite songs by them. Standouts: Brownie Bottom Sundae, Wanna Get a Mohawk (But Mom Won't Let Me Get One), High School Football Hero, and a few other decent tracks.
|apart from #1: WRONG|
|ANSWER THAT - THEIR WORST? whaaaaaaaaat|
|i know right|
|I ranked them how I like them. When ATSF came out I loved it but since then I have started to not like punk music as much which is why its low|
|Ugh, take out Decemberunderground for All Hallows and you got yourself a list.|
|All Hallows is a EP, I said albums.|
|i dont like this band|
|Don't listen to these fags you're absolutely right, apart from the fact that STS needs to be #1. You still describe it as perfect so no big deal.|
or something like that
thanks for agreeing lol, but I disagree that STS is better than Black Sails.