|StaffReviews 177Soundoffs 186News Articles 10Band Edits + Tags 60Album Edits 19Album Ratings 1672Objectivity 76%Last Active 07-30-14 3:07 pmJoined 08-08-09Forum Posts 206Review Comments 9,687
|My Top Ten Reviewing Mistakes|
I like to think that I'm at least consistent in quality with my reviews, but rI know I've fucked up rrquite a bit too. Sometimes successes have to rfollow a line of failures, and so this is my list of rrthings I messed up with rmy reviews. I don't feel like editing my reviews at the moment, but I'll rrdo rso at some point. Sorry if I've wasted any of your time with my fuck-ups rin my reviewing.
LoTR/D&D: In my Holy Diver review, I called the lyrics "lots of Lord of the Rings, lots
of Dungeons and Dragons, etc"; the statement was completely ignorant. There's
obviously a diverse well of fantasy literature and other work to draw from, and I
was making a ridiculous generalization. I'm still not a big fan of the album, but I was
giving the lyrics an unfair assessment.
The Divine Wings of Tragedy
Russell Allen's singing: When reviewing this album, I mentioned that Russell Allen
"may not be the best vocalist, but he fits the band very well." Well, that shit is
straight-up wrong. I'm not sure why I considered Allen the weakest link in the band,
especially considering that he's also one of the most acclaimed singers in popular
prog metal (or even just prog metal in general). Regardless, he rules.
Little Broken Hearts
Genre mix-up: When reviewing Little Broken Hearts, I mentioned that Norah's
previous album The Fall included a lot of hard rock, which is a major error. There
was practically nothing hard rock-oriented about the record; it's more of a mix
between alternative rock, folk, and jazz. You guys should definitely check Little
Broken Hearts though, very underrated.
The intro: The intro I currently have for Madvillainy doesn't even explain anything
about the album, just the label it's on. The original intro I had there was even
worse, making a bunch of negative hip-hop generalizations. But yeah, I don't even
like the one that's there now.
Reign in Blood
See below: Similar to the last entry on this list, my Reign in Blood review starts with
nothing even describing Slayer or applying to what I'll say about the album. Here's
the first paragraph: "As I sit here typing this review, there lies an eerie breeze and
foggy weather outside my window. The storm just passed, and now the skies are
gray and darkened above me. Everything looks miserable and gloomy, and the
clouds are looming over my house as I write. Now, what does this have to do with
anything? Well unfortunately, the description is an accurate metaphor for the
thrash "classic" Reign in Blood by Slayer."
|5||At the Drive-In|
Relationship of Command
Another genre mix-up: Not only is this a shitty review as it is, but I considered this
album a mix of prog rock, hardcore punk, "surreal ambiance," and metal... damn.
The repetition argument: I still dislike this record, but I didn't explain my arguments
well enough at all. I emphasized the repetition way too much and didn't even
mention many of the tracks. I think I was pissed when I was making the review, so
I probably came off as a bit ranty as well. Repetition shouldn't always completely
break an album, so I'll elaborate more in the future.
The entire review of Deliverance: I really dislike my review of this. It was way too
long and long-winded. It felt as if I was just giving a bunch of technical info (some
of it wrong, I think) and didn't explain the pros and cons very well. I just really
needed to pare it down.
|2||The Devin Townsend Project|
The rush for attention: I rushed my Ghost review out so I could get a bunch of
comments and overall attention, not realizing just how empty and non-descriptive it
was. I barely mentioned any tracks, and my writing was pretty bland. I try not to
rush out any reviews anymore.
My original Escape review was such a fucking trainwreck
that it's the only review I've everd. It was ranty beyond belief, and I was
apparently pissed that Journey were popular or something. I was trying so hard to
make a better review than SyphonAss's write-up (even mentioning that during the
review) that mine suffered. I also used way too much inclusive language to top it
all off. So yeah, I'm happy that I rewrote it and actually put more genuine effort
|nice to see some honesty in self reflection keep strivin for improvement brother|
|You're a Contributor here, of course you fuck up all the time.|
|lol all of my reviews are mistakes dont feel too bad|
|Trebor staff 2014|
|you're kidding right|
|Happy New Year's Eve dude. |
Dio's lyrics are like power metal lyrics in the sense that they may seem cheesy at first but they are allegorical most of the times and open to interpretations. As such, dragons might be problems or fears in our lives and swords the courage we must have. Shit, even my comment seems cheesy but you know what I mean...
|At least they're not as bad as Dragonforce or Hammerfall's lyrics :P|
|But... I agree with your description of 5. It covers a lot of stuff lol|
|Your biggest reviewing mistake was giving Reign In Blood a 2.|
Nah, in all seriousness, awesome list. You're a solid reviewer, and I probably would have never noticed most of these mistakes had you not pointed out. You should definitely apply for Staff next month. I was thinking of applying for contributor myself.
|Good honest list bro|
|I've done a lot of mistakes on my reviews, probably bigger than yours Necro. Still, seeing this list does make me feel a bit better about it. Quality reviewing is a learned skill, rather than an innate one.|
|Yea reviewing isn't easy. I still have lots of improvement to do but I think I've gotten so much better.|
|Good list we could all benefit from doing something like this|
|I agree man|
|By the way, on my Escape entry, it's supposed to say "ever deleted," not "everd." lol|
|Mongi blowing his own trumpet hard.|
|No, he's just being honest|
|i'd blow mongi's trumpet too have you seen that thing|
|I know blowing so hard|
|Mongi saying that he still has lots of improving to do isn't him blowing his own trumpet at all...|
|I find Chan's reviews entertaining and that's p much it.|
|Tommy the kind words are too much man stop.|
|everyone check out the fall by norah jones its good|
|Norah Jones is just awesome in general.|
haha yeah, I know
|"But... I agree with your description of 5. It covers a lot of stuff lol"|
A lot of other people were saying I was wrong though, so idk. I didn't like that review anyway :P