LegendofPittman
08.10.10 | List is the album ranked. |
qwe3
08.10.10 | omg what a dilemma i'd hate to be you right now |
AliW1993
08.10.10 | Change so low :o
I say keep it at 4.5 |
eternium
08.10.10 | 5555555555555555555555555555 it. |
LegendofPittman
08.10.10 | I want to, I just find some of the songs weaker than others, but then I also think that I feel that way because the other songs are just so freaking good. |
bloc
08.10.10 | I have a better suggestion
2.5 it |
ShadowRemains
08.10.10 | omg what a dilemma i'd hate to be you right now [2] |
Lambda
08.10.10 | Well a 4.75 rounds up... but do whatever you want, |
geng
08.10.10 | I found it was a 4.75 as well, but in the end I 5'd it mainly because I have so few albums on a 5. |
LegendofPittman
08.10.10 | Well I actually have quite a bit at a 5 for as few albums as I have rated. I usually never have this problem, but this album is just so hard to rate. |
MUNGOLOID
08.10.10 | follow your heart when it comes to 5/5 ratings, if it's truly is a classic in your eyes, then by all means, do it. but you should never force a 5 rating onto an album, just because a lot of other people did. |
SCREAM!
08.10.10 | lol mungoloid sounds like a parent having the sex talk with his kid |
TMobotron
08.10.10 | Lol hes right though. This has to be the dumbest list ever. |
TMobotron
08.10.10 | I mean look at his 5s hes already 5ed everything else sputnik told him to |
LegendofPittman
08.10.10 | I have to agree. I do not want to force this so it is staying with a 4.5. Also, there is a difference between rating a 5 on "what Sputnik tells me" and agreeing with the sites majority. The reason I love this site so much is because it is good to see the albums I love appreciated by musically inclined people. |
BigTuna
08.10.10 | Don't 5 it it's not that good |
TMobotron
08.10.10 | Haha I'm just giving you a hard time anyways. I'm not really in a position to talk, most of my 5s are pretty sputniky too. I guess that's why we're here.
I love Coheed too though, was my favorite band for the longest time.
WP is a 4 for me, some tracks just bore me to tears. I should re-listen though. |
bloc
08.10.10 | "...it is good to see the albums I love appreciated by musically inclined people."
If only this happened with me. |
LegendofPittman
08.10.10 | Haha I thought you were serious. My bad.
I still love Coheed, but not near as much as I use too. It was more of a gateway to modern music for me.
I suggest re-listen, some songs bored me the first few times but you just find parts that stick out and you slowly like it more and more. That's just my opinion. |
Psilocyanide
08.10.10 | If you can't decide the answer is most likely no. |
LegendofPittman
08.10.10 | ^^ Yep. I think it may be one of, it not, Maynard's best vocal performance. |
Deviant.
08.10.10 | Be a pony, not a sheep |
TMobotron
08.10.10 | It's all about the grudge though. And yeah Pittman they were kind of the gateway into modern music for me too. Still like them though for sure. Hasn't helped that they've been going downhill since their first album though (or maybe their second). YotBR might have been better than NWFT but I'm starting to wonder about that even. |
chaseguitar
08.10.10 | if you 5 it, imma kill myself. that's how big of a deal it is. |
