Niceinvader
09.13.09 | I disagree, you should check out forgive durden and say anything, those bands might change your mind |
Knott-
09.13.09 | sigh.
there is some incredible pop-punk in the world. |
Electric City
09.13.09 | dude i ask myself the same question of rap every day |
shortone323
09.13.09 | Probably because it's fun and easy to listen to. Even an uncreative and unskilled band can usually make at least one catchy song that's fun to listen to before it gets overplayed on the raido. |
CompanionCube
09.13.09 | good pop punk > this list |
americanmusicmachine
09.13.09 | listen to dillinger four. they'll answer your question. |
redskyformiles
09.13.09 | Say Anything, Dillinger Four, The Get Up Kids, Alkaline Trio, Saves the Day, Taking Back Sunday, Motion City Soundtrack, Northstar, Further Seems Forever, Rufio, Daggermouth, Paramore, The Ataris, Millencolin, New Found Glory.
forgive durden is pretty eh.
|
americanmusicmachine
09.13.09 | also avail and lifetime!!! and jawbreaker!!! |
NortherlyNanook
09.13.09 | milo goes to college would beg to differ |
Prophet178
09.13.09 | 3 and 8 aren't disappointments. |
Masochist
09.13.09 | Mae is amazing. Anberlin and Jimmy Eat World, if you consider them pop-punk, are also amazing. The Get-Up Kids, Alkaline Trio, and fuck yes MILLENCOLIN are all worthy.
And 'Catch Without Arms' is damn amazing. |
redskyformiles
09.13.09 | CWA is my favorite dredg album |
IsItLuck?
09.13.09 | you say that but every genre has equal amounts of terrible bands, it's a matter of how accessible pop-punk is to the mainstream audience |
americanmusicmachine
09.13.09 | "Deja Entendu was probably the best pop punk album ever. That or ...Is a Real Boy."
no!!!!!!!! |
XulOnerom
09.13.09 | Pop-punk can be good. What I really dislike are generic bands just playing power chords with tired vocal melodies, trying to be the next Blink 182. But there are also good and innovative pop punk bands. Stop making generalizations |
shindip
09.13.09 | 3 and 6 were amazing IMO |
americanmusicmachine
09.13.09 | "Yeah"
agree to disagree? |
Titan50
09.13.09 | ugh |
fromtheinside
09.13.09 | if FOB is pop-punk than i would really disagree with this list. |
bloc
09.13.09 | that's a good question, what genre is FOB anyway? |
EasternLight
09.13.09 | id say straight pop. |
darksunwithin
09.13.09 | 8 is awesome gtfo |
fromtheinside
09.13.09 | nah dude, FOB is often to heavy for just straight pop.
especially their earlier stuff. |
adkymo
09.13.09 | Pop-punk is fantastic is fantastic if it's well executed.
As for this list though, I think you're spot on... except I did find myself enjoying 5 (but I put that down to me being a little fan boyish). |
bloc
09.13.09 | i guess they went through a genre phase with each album. in terms of right now, i'd go with pop-rock or something. |
SeaAnemone
09.13.09 | 1. Listen to Northstar- Pollyanna and Park- It Won't Snow Where You're Going
2. Promptly change your mind about the aforementioned statement.
3. Apologize |
VicariousIntent
09.13.09 | ...Is A Real Boy by Say Anything is almost guaranteed to change your mind. It pushes the limits of pop punk to a completely new level.
Pop Punk is a genre often criticized for lack of originality, but I find it's one of the few genres with artists who are constantly pushing the limits of what they can do. And those bands really care about their fans, which is always nice. |
cirq
09.13.09 | pop punk is fun and stupid.. quit bitchin |
joobakka
09.13.09 | props for 8! |
scyther
09.13.09 | "you say that but every genre has equal amounts of terrible bands"
How could you possibly come to this conclusion? |
bodiesinflight57
09.14.09 | I did say 'for the most part'. There are a few ok pop-punkish bands, TBS for example. But overall it's not the genre for me and the majority of pop-punk bands may be fun if you like the genre but the lack of imagination is despicable. I know some people like 8 but not me I'm afraid...very average. |
StreetlightRock
09.14.09 | hes right through 95% of all music is shithouse |
qwe
09.14.09 | opinions guys : ( |
PuddlesPuddles
09.14.09 | The hell - Catch Without Arms is great |
Carnifex
09.14.09 | Pop punk is catchy and is a guilty pleasure of most of us, enough said. |
qwe
09.14.09 | ^ no |
FadeToBlack
09.14.09 | exactly.
anyway, question should be why does deathcore (and metalcore) exist |
bodiesinflight57
09.14.09 | The list could very easily have 'metalcore' or 'deathcore' substituted in but let's not be pedantic |
R6Rider
09.14.09 | list is true except for 10 |
austin888
02.17.11 | I loved 3. |
dixoncocks
02.17.11 | so kids like you can complain about it. |
andcas
02.17.11 | get it right. pop punk rules. |
OutOfMyself
02.17.11 | This Time Next Year.
your argument is now invalid |
IAmHollywood
02.17.11 | anyway, question should be why does deathcore (and metalcore) exist
Converge, Between The Buried And Me, The Chariot, Poison The Well |
andcas
02.17.11 | i'd like to know what bodies even considers pop punk. good and bad. |
Dryden
02.17.11 | nothin exists |
FromDaHood
02.17.11 | Pop-punk has some pretty awesome albums. And it makes hella dollars. |
Kris.
02.17.11 | the ergs! are so awesome guys |
Josh D.
02.17.11 | I hate when people say things like "You just aren't listening to GOOD pop punk".
No, it sucks. |
HaydenDyson
02.17.11 | A day to remember and blink 182 are the catchiest bands ever even if there not that good they still are enjoyable. |
andcas
02.17.11 | listen to any band on run for cover records. excellent pop punk. |
SowingSeason
02.17.11 | pop-punk doesn't suck at all. you just need to stop listening to shitty music and find the right bands |
Josh D.
02.17.11 | "A day to remember and blink 182 are the catchiest bands ever even if there not that good they still are enjoyable."
Jesus fuck, you're wrong about everything. |
Scoot
02.17.11 | pop-punk does not exist
it faithfully insists |
andcas
02.17.11 | http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5DmWbq9f2-E get on it. |