Masochist: So...which Game Wins?

Masochist 12.05.11	List is every album released in 2011 that I've listened to in full (not counting EP's)...#5 is the exception, but I'll have it before the end of the year. So...games. Which one wins? 1. Portal 2 2. Skyrim 3. Pokemon White 4. Deus Ex: Human Revolution 5. Batman: Arkham City (I only demo'd this one) Fill in the --blanks-- if you think I should add one (probably could've added Sonic Generations on here, for my own sake, at least).
Masochist 12.05.11	Also, these obviously aren't the only ones that came out this year, nor have I played anywhere NEAR all of them. These are just the ones that I thought got a lot of critical acclaim, or were just played by a bunch of people.
ffs 12.05.11	i couldnt say
PayneTiger777 12.05.11	1. Skyrim 2. Dark Souls 3. Uncharted 3 4. Dead Space 2 5. I have played it yet, but Batman would probably be up there as well.
Xenophanes 12.05.11	15, 18, and 22 are the only games I have played....so either of those?
Masochist 12.05.11	How is Mario 3D Land?
pmmets07 12.05.11	^ good but boring once your beat the main story.
Calculate 12.05.11	if i played games i probably wouldve enjoyed LA Noire the most
Xenophanes 12.05.11	It's a lot of fun, but the first part is only 3-4 hours long. The second part is hella difficult, but doesn't require that much time either. Basically, if you don't put a looooooot of time and effort into it, you aren't going to get much value. It's a 4/5 for me, so if you have a 3DS I'd get it because OoT 3D is bound to be getting old by now.
Tyrannic 12.05.11	skyrim. la noire got so boring towards the end.
Kris. 12.05.11	if anyone actually says mw3 i hope they get stabbed in the eye with something pointy
Masochist 12.05.11	Nah, I don't have a 3DS, unfortunately. I've also never made it all the way through OoT, either, though.
Satellite 12.05.11	1. skyrim 2. portal 2 3. deus ex 4. arkham 5. nba 2k12
Trebor17 12.05.11	Skyrim Portal 2
taxidermist 12.05.11	"if anyone actually says mw3 i hope they get stabbed in the eye with something pointy" MW3 :3
PayneTiger777 12.05.11	Anyone know how Golden Eye Reloaded is?
Winsomniac 12.05.11	...Skyrim. Then Dota 2.
Masochist 12.05.11	Knew Tax would say that. :-P I'mma go play it right now.
Ovrot 12.05.11	1. Dark Souls 2. Pokemon White 3. Arkham City 4. Skyrim Yeah
Ovrot 12.05.11	wait no fuck that 1. Monster Girl Quest 2. Monster Girl Quest 3. Monster Girl Quest
DeathByDaydream 12.05.11	Skyrim Little Big Planet 2 Super Mario 3D Land Forza 4 Not Modern Warfare 3
Winsomniac 12.05.11	Dota 2. :(
eternium 12.05.11	I want to play 2 so bad.
Satellite 12.05.11	1. including portal 2 2. being a colossal disappointment pick one
puma35 12.05.11	definitely skyrim at 1
Satellite 12.05.11	long time no see, puma
Ovrot 12.05.11	Monster Girl Quest
Winsomniac 12.05.11	And the award for "Most Rape-y Game of the Year" goes to...
FromDaHood 12.05.11	MUFUCKIN MOD 3 BITCH MAP PACK OF THE YEAR
MO 12.05.11	9 for me, a perfect balance of excellent story, killer gameplay, great visuals. Just an all around perfect game in my eyes. 8 and 23 are honorable mentions.
Ovrot 12.05.11	Monster Girl Quest?
Acanthus 12.05.11	Shooter wise - Crysis 2 Mixed genre - Deus Ex: Human Revolution RPG - Skyrim
RooseveltsGhost 12.06.11	The Collective is the clear winner here
Winsomniac 12.06.11	DEFENSE OF THE ANCIENTS MOTHER-OF-ALL-FUCKING-TWO
ffs 12.06.11	the only game in town
TheVoiceAndTheSnake 12.06.11	It's between Portal 2, Skyrim, or Arkham City
Winsomniac 12.06.11	UGH you console-blinded philistines.
TheVoiceAndTheSnake 12.06.11	or the re-release of Shadow of the Colossus/ICO
TheVoiceAndTheSnake 12.06.11	Yeah, I'd go with the re-release of Shadow of the Colossus/ICO
qwe3 12.06.11	skyward sword is so fucking good
Masochist 12.06.11	DOTA 2 officially comes out next year...it's only in beta right now.
Winsomniac 12.06.11	:( :( :( :( :( :( :(
Lumyth 12.06.11	when the fuck is diablo 3 coming out?
qwe3 12.06.11	2056
Winsomniac 12.06.11	They pushed it back to 2057. Pretty sure.
Imperial 12.06.11	Portal 2 was amazing but was too short in my opinion. Skyrim for GOTY.
Ignimbrite 12.06.11	From the very limited experience I've had with any of these games, I'd go for Skyrim or BF3.
Imperial 12.06.11	They are pretty even to be honest. Portal 2 is perfectly executed. 10/10 voice acting, dialogue and story. Skyrim has the massive scale and content to make it on par.
FearThyEvil9 12.06.11	Battlefield 3 for multiplayer and Skyrim for singleplayer.
auberginedreams 12.06.11	skyrim and pokemon black/white
crackalakin 12.06.11	1.Skyrim 2. Dead space 3.portal 2 4. Fifa 12 5.Mw3 haven't played Dark souls or BF3 yet though.
DoubtGin 12.06.11	"Then Dota 2." THAT FUCKING KEY
Damrod 12.06.11	I enjoyed Portal 2 and Batman: Arkham City the most this year
Pentagon 12.06.11	1. Batman Arkham City 2. Gears of War 3 (I'm a huge fanboy) 3. Portal 2 4. Battlefield 3 5. Deus Ex:HR
Gilgamahesh 12.06.11	You fools. Zelda is always #1 Skyrim: #2 Portal 2: #3 DOTA 2: #4 BF3: #5
ohfoxxxycole 12.06.11	portal 2 skyrim Pokemon black rage
DaisyHill 12.06.11	Gears of war 3 Deus ex Forza 4
Piglet 12.06.11	sky fucking ward swordddd
Gilgamahesh 12.06.11	^someone give this man a prize skyward motherfucking sword
PastorOfMupp3ts 12.06.11	skyrim>batman>everything else
Crysis 12.06.11	1. Skyrim 2. The Witcher 2 3. Battlefield 3 Those are the only games I've bought that came out this year and all three were excellent.
KILL 12.06.11	bf3 on pc is the best multiplayer ever, real life mod fucking rules too
Pentagon 12.06.11	yeah fuck i wish i had a gaming pc. but i have to settle for bf3 on the xbox which is alright i guess
Gilgamahesh 12.06.11	Build a custom pc rather than shell out thousands of g's.
Gilgamahesh 12.06.11	http://www.guildwars2guru.com/forum/buying-building-pci-check-here-t10381.html The servers are down currently but when they're not there's a decent guide for custom builders there. Multiple budgets taken into account.
JizzInMyPants 12.06.11	monster girl quest is good but most of the girls on it looks fucked up, that fucking leech girl...fuck that shit, no wank, best H-game this year is going to be 7th-Dreams new joint thats going to be out on the 10th. Pretty girl may cry
JWT155 12.06.11	Skyrim. No contest.
Gilgamahesh 12.06.11	SKYWARD FUCKING SWORD. Have you fools never played a Zelda game in your lives. Granted that Skyrim is an easy 2nd place.
qwe3 12.06.11	dota 2 is p rad got a beta key for it
qwe3 12.06.11	dude i said skyward sword like ages ago
Pentagon 12.06.11	wii sucks. does it have anything worth playing besides skyward sword?
NeutralThunder12 12.06.11	oh and rage was absolute garbage
Winsomniac 12.06.11	Ugh, fuck you Qwe. Got a spare invite? :/
NeutralThunder12 12.06.11	yeah how does skyrim not win lol. gears was horrible, mw3 was horrible, dead island was meh, rage was horrible, battlefield 3 was pretty great but skyrim is fucking outstanding
X3ni92 12.06.11	Xenoblade or Skyward Sword.
NeutralThunder12 12.06.11	oh and bulletstorm was obnoxious
Winsomniac 12.06.11	It's entirely absurd how much better Skyrim is than anything else currently in the market content and detail wise. So yeah.
KILL 12.06.11	and bug wise, dont forget that
NeutralThunder12 12.06.11	skyrim is also the best elder scrolls gameeee
KILL 12.06.11	nope
NeutralThunder12 12.06.11	nah it is, morrowind is 2nd bro sorry
KILL 12.06.11	nah bro but stay rush m/
NeutralThunder12 12.06.11	morrowind would prolly be the best if it weren't for the worst combat system in all of gaming history
AlexanDerp 12.06.11	Morrowind is a cool game but the characters move too slow, combat sucks, the map is bland...I'd say Skyrim is the best game, but too simple. The best game would be a mix of Skyrim, Oblivion and Morrowind. Oblivion's map was the best, Skyrim's combat system is the best (except Destruction magic sucks), an Morrowind felt more like an RPG instead of an Action Game.
KILL 12.06.11	"the map is bland." fucking gonk i am pissed
KILL 12.06.11	"an Morrowind felt more like an RPG instead of an Action Game." wait are you saying thats a bad thing
Maniac! 12.06.11	obviously skyrim and I haven't even played it yet
NeutralThunder12 12.06.11	oblivions map was horrible morrowinds map is beautifully diverse and a pleasure to explore Skyrim is not too simple they just took the ridiculous over complexities that added pointless shit and simplified it into a better system destruction in skyrim doesnt suck you were wrong about everything
NeutralThunder12 12.06.11	"an Morrowind felt more like an RPG instead of an Action Game."- lol
Gilgamahesh 12.06.11	"dude i said skyward sword like ages ago" I know bro but you were pretty much the only one. Skyrim is amazing but fucking Zelda, people. Come on. And dude you have a beta key? Awesomesauce. Who do you use?
PropaneNightmares 12.06.11	black/white version was the best Pokemon game yet, you actually had to try in the battles
Pentagon 12.06.11	lol peeps sayimg sky rims game of the year even though half of them haven't played it...
qwe3 12.06.11	"Morrowind felt more like an RPG instead of an Action Game." morrowind is an rpg...
ncguitar 12.06.11	WoW in its peak
Winsomniac 12.06.11	Qwe, tell me you have an extra beta invite.
NeutralThunder12 12.06.11	morrowind is more of an fps than an action game
Gilgamahesh 12.06.11	"WoW in its peak" :*( I played during pre-BC days and they were some of the best and most immersive times I've ever had in video gaming. I played during Wrath too and it was still great until I started my habit of moving to countries with terrible internet access. Fucking pandas and pokemon battles are what's coming man. I would've come back to Cata for nostalgia reasons alone but seeing how it's going to be in the next expansion I'll just jump ship to GW2/SWTOR. Qwe, tell me you have an extra beta invite. [2]
Masochist 12.06.11	Hahaha...I was going to edit this list with the ones that seemed to get mentioned a lot that weren't on the list (and were actually offically released in 2011), but I wasn't expecting all the album art to show up, and I know if I go back an edit it, some of them will disappear, so I'm hesitant. Still, Dark Souls probably deserves a spot on here.
Emim 12.06.11	skyrim was probably my favorite, then revelations and bf3
Scoot 12.06.11	yeah skyrim takes it
Yotimi 12.06.11	1. Skyrim 2. Portal 2 3. Bastion (nobody else play this?) 4. Dead Space 2 Still need to play Batman, Uncharted, and Zelda though
Gilgamahesh 12.06.11	I've played Zelda and Skyrim and they are easily my favorite two. I spent some time with BF3 on a decent machine with a few buds and it's fun but not in the same league. The lack of decent competition may have been a factor. Played Batman at an EB Games for about 20 minutes and I already know that it isn't spectacular. Fun though. Portal 2 is amazing just as its predecessor was.
Ovrot 12.06.11	Monster Girl Quest
InAbsentia 12.06.11	Skyrim.
Ovrot 12.06.11	Monster Girl Quest
theacademy 12.06.11	infamous 2 was pretty close to uncharted 3 in terms of quality, but dead space extraction might have been my favorite game of this year (that i've played thus far) that shit was incredibly fun.
theashesfromautumn01 12.06.11	wish they made an hd collection of the final fantasy games. get on it square
Thane 12.06.11	Skyrim for me so far, not played Dark Souls yet though. Or well, I got to the dragon on the bridge, got past it and missed the bonfire. If you die after that, its apparently impossible to get past the dragon again. So I raged. Going to pick it up again as soon as I'm done with Skyrim though.
minty901 12.06.11	Skyrim Dead Space 2 Battlefield 3 Fifa 12 Portal 2 Batman: Arkham City
tkxxx7 12.06.11	"the dragon on the bridge, got past it and missed the bonfire. If you die after that, its apparently impossible to get past the dragon again." that's not true at all Dark Souls GOTY
Thane 12.06.11	That's weird, I remember reading something like "good luck if you miss the bonfire" or something. Made it easily first time, after that it just killed me in 1 hit while I was running away :p Game seems fucking awesome though, so...yeah.
tkxxx7 12.06.11	the only thing you need that bonfire for is the Sunbro covenant as long as you kicked the ladder down the first bonfire in the Burg, your life is complete
JAV 12.06.11	Off this list Batman Deus Ex Portal 2 Haven't tried Zelda, Skyrim or Gears yet.
Ovrot 12.06.11	Dark Souls GOTYAY
AlexanDerp 12.06.11	Are you guys trolling me? I was saying Morrowind felt more like a RPG instead of an Action game(Oblivion/Skyrim) as a good thing. "Skyrim is not too simple they just took the ridiculous over complexities that added pointless shit and simplified it into a better system destruction in skyrim doesnt suck" Skyrim IS too simple. Few spells, takes about 2 hours to get a crafting skill to 100, once that happens the game is litterally over, Fatigue doesn't do shit, I can sneak during broad day light with a torch in my hand...the list goes on. As for Destruction, clearly you haven't level your character high/ you play on Adept or lower. Don't get me wrong, I love the game, and it is GOTY for me riht now, but there is still room for improvment.
Ovrot 12.06.11	Monster Girl Quest
JumpTheShark 12.07.11	Dead Space 2, Arkham City, Skyrim and Dark Souls were my favorites. Battlefield 3 is only fun for multiplayer and coop.
Strider 12.07.11	Arkham City, Skyward Sword, Minecraft, Fifa 12, Skyrim, waiting for the new Naruto too. might be missing some