Fxxkit13
10.11.09 | variations (i.e. Melo-Death, Symphonic Black Metal) are cool too. |
rasputin
10.11.09 | and just when i thought lists on this site couldn't get dumber |
Fxxkit13
10.11.09 | whys it dumb |
Relinquished
10.11.09 | Death Metal. Cuz I got into it before Black Metal. Was listening to it since I was in middle school. Black Metal is awesome though, but I don't my feelings for it because I started listening to it since the year began.
P.S. I can tell that you're bored lol |
Tulannical
10.11.09 | profile pic is lol |
combustion07
10.11.09 | Death Metal
Black Metal is a very close second though
There has always been something that has drawn me to that genre more than anything else, I've never really thought about what it was. It may be my love for horror movies(that covers the lyrical department for many bands) and it all seems so out of control, while (for the most part) most other metal sub-genres almost feel too controlled.
Fuck it, I can't really explain... |
rasputin
10.11.09 | 1. it's vs. not vrs.
2. darkestrah are not ambient
3. most of these albums aren't very good
4. why would you even compare to totally different styles of music? it's like YO I LIEK DETH BETTER YO and someone else will be like YO NAH WAY MANG BLACK IS SO MUCH MORE KVLT
seriously what the fuck is the point? especially since you and most of the other users don't actually listen to any good death OR black metal |
Fxxkit13
10.11.09 | yeah, a little haha.
Its late, and i'm pretty tired, but can't sleep. I was gonna write a review, but i'm too tired |
Fxxkit13
10.11.09 | its not so much as a comparison as it is preference. I'm not asking anything about musical traits just which one is preferred. |
Fxxkit13
10.11.09 | And yeah, i don't have as vast a knowledge as you do when it comes to Black Metal, but it doesn't mean i don't know any good bands. Sure we have some differences in certain cases, but i'm sure if i ever got the chance to hear some of the bands that you know I'd like it. |
Athom
10.11.09 | fxxkit check out Gorgut's Erosion of Sanity and Immolation's Close to a World Below. both own pretty much every death metal album you have rated. |
Fxxkit13
10.11.09 | thats probably because i don't really know much DM, but thanks i'll definitely give those a listen. |
rasputin
10.11.09 | i dont have a vast knowledge of black metal at all
and redsky he doesnt actually have a single good death metal album rated so yeah, pretty much anything owns what he has rated |
Fxxkit13
10.11.09 | like i said, i really don't listen to much death metal. |
Athom
10.11.09 | there's a lot of really good death metal. you should get on that. |
rasputin
10.11.09 | http://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?memberid=261672&listid=30730 |
Fxxkit13
10.11.09 | yeah if you noticed i commented on that list saying it was good and how i'm going to check a lot of that out |
combustion07
10.11.09 | Check out Cancer, Jumpin' Jesus, Dream Death, and Resurrection as well. |
ameypv
10.11.09 | atmospheric black metal is my favourite.next comes technical death metal.melodeath is next |
joplinpicasso
10.11.09 | Can someone explain to me the fucking difference? |
rasputin
10.11.09 | are you serious |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | gorguts - obscura
demilich - nespithe
malevolent creation - retribution |
KTV
10.11.09 | i never liked black metal but i like some death metal. |
bodiesinflight57
10.11.09 | Death Metal >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Black Metal |
iranscam
10.11.09 | okay guys jazz v. doowop lets go whch one better and y? |
jingledeath
10.11.09 | death metal |
luci
10.11.09 | I like black metal becuase it i more emotional to me |
luci
10.11.09 | *is |
qwe3
10.11.09 | how the fuck can an entire GENRE of music be more emotional than another |
Phantom
10.11.09 | well this is faggotry |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | Black metal for me all the way. Much more emotion. Death Metal is almost more for laughs. I mean the instrumention is basically the only readon to listn to death metal. GOOD black metal often has very meaningful lyrics while most death metal is just nonsense when it comes to lyrics. |
rasputin
10.11.09 | yah and that's possibly the stupidest thing i've ever read |
BallsToTheWall
10.11.09 | We should probaly set up a giant death match over this. Axes, flaming towels, molotolvs, chariots and bricks, etc. Rasputin vs entire sputnik community. |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | don't be a fag basket, i'm not speaking in general, just the majority of death metal lyrics are incredibly laughable while i'd say the majority of black metal has awesome lyric (a few exceptions to this as well) Either way i love them both. But i certainly don't listen to death for the lyrics. More for the technicality and intensity. Black metal on the other had can overwhelm with emotions from the atmosphere it often creates. |
rasputin
10.11.09 | the simple fact that you think the majority of black metal has well written lyrics disproves any statement about black metal you're trying to make |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | beware the troll in the darkest ov forests tonight we ride for the underdarkest satan bring forth swrds ov darkest blasphemy eeeeeuuuuugghhhhhh |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | into the tomb ov the farted one where undead reign with elves of mightiest summong fire powers ov darkest corpse paint |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | eeeuuuuuggggghh sayyyy tuhhhn eeuuugggghhh (atmosphere) coldest nights rainiest plauges eeuuuugh production ov kvltest tapes |
FadeToBlack
10.11.09 | depends what mood I'm in, but generally I listen to more DM |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | black metal has so much better lyrics |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | you all listen to shitty black metal is all there is to it |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | blakkest blakk ov the darkest dark |
KILL
10.11.09 | death metal because i said so |
rasputin
10.11.09 | hey guys foreverendeared thinks we listen to shitty black metal i wonder what he listens to
Burzum Hvis Lyset Tar Oss
Drudkh Estrangement
Drudkh Forgotten Legends
Alcest Souvenirs d'un autre Monde
Belphegor Pestapokalypse VI
Dimmu Borgir Enthrone Darkness Triumphant
Drudkh Blood In Our Wells
Mirrorthrone Carriers of Dust
Ulver Bergtatt
Darkestrah The Great Silk Road
Dimmu Borgir For All Tid
Dimmu Borgir Puritanical Euphoric Misanthropia
Drudkh Songs of Grief and Solitude
Fen The Malediction Fields
Kroda Fimbulvinter
Drudkh Microcosmos
Drudkh Autumn Aurora
Emperor Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk |
Crysis
10.11.09 | I prefer black metal |
KILL
10.11.09 | i wonder what hawks prefers |
Fxxkit13
10.11.09 | haha |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | oh that's awesome just pick some of the worst bands. the the FUCK is wrong with Drudkh and Ulver lol i will bite puch your ovaries |
rasputin
10.11.09 | i actually picked ALL the black metal you have rated above a 3, excepting the odd one or two i may have missed as i scrolled |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | you should also realize you're completely missing the point. And besides, i have like 3 albums rated below a 2. i obviously like nearly everything i listen to, but i also overrated a lot of shiity albums. who the fuck doesn't have some guilty pleasures. i think if u saw my lastfm listens you'd realize i mainly listen to Drudkh and Ulver. I take it no complainants there? Those two bands alone are worth proving that black metal trumps death metal any day of the week. |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | rofl |
rasputin
10.11.09 | whoa you listen to drudkh AND ulver? man you know your shit |
bloc
10.11.09 | death for me, i could never get into black. |
KILL
10.11.09 | i wish i was an elitist |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | you know usually you all are pretty funny with trolls but right now all u have to say is "haha" if you dont agree, argue, i'm no close minded |
rasputin
10.11.09 | yeah man youre totally no close minded you def know your shit please tell me more about how black metal makes you emotional and the atomspherics are so heavy and dense and the shrieking tears at your heart from its bleakness and desolateness |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | roflmo yeah because that's exactly what i'm feeling! |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | lol fag |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | i'll suk ur dik and il like it mmmmmmmmm |
Thor
10.11.09 | death metal because i'm not a faggot |
rasputin
10.11.09 | sorry but you can't troll if you don't actually listen to black metal, it's a job requirement |
KILL
10.11.09 | thor that is so rude!! you should be ashamed!! AHHHHHHH |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | u guys ever heard borknagar B-) |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | in my opinion and my opnion rules all, the best black metal bands out there today (no not fuckin dimmu borshit) are better than the best death metal bands. so suck the inner vagina on my inside thigh! |
rasputin
10.11.09 | youve listened to neither the best black nor the best death, you've barely listened to any of the significant bands in either genre, you're pretty much the joke of this discussion, oh yeah and u fuk niggers |
KILL
10.11.09 | u guys ever heard trollech? pretty lol |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | cause nigger can suck a mean dick with their big lips mmmm
dude no one rates every album thy listen to are you retarded? |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | pbviously you just haven t ratings yet |
rasputin
10.11.09 | and im sure if you did you'd have maybe 3 more black metal albums and some more dimmu
faggot |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | what rasputin doesn' realize is i like/have heard almost all of his favorite black and death bands. he's just talking out of his ass at this point. |
rasputin
10.11.09 | hahahahaha gimme a list plz plz plz |
rasputin
10.11.09 | he'll prob post my death metal list and totally save face |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | what foreverendeared doesn't know is that its actually a lean pocket |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | i actually owned almost ever dimmu album at one point. you got me there, but that was like 12 fuckin years ago. i also listen to fall out boy and tailor swift so fuckin what stop licking ur moms clit |
KILL
10.11.09 | out for my own..out to be freeee!!!!!!!!!!! |
cirq
10.11.09 | metal fags |
rasputin
10.11.09 | nice one man give us another |
cirq
10.11.09 | sorry, im all out |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | oh jeez i'm sorry you are all so elite!! i'll have stay away from everything black and death from now on since i've listened to shitty black and death metal in the past. |
rasputin
10.11.09 | nah you just havent listened to any, so it's pretty funny when you try to make it sound like you have
i've also seen your lastfm, you're not fooling anybody
though youre pretty convicning that black metal is emitional and makes you atmoshpherics so much more meaningful |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | this list is gay |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | the RIGHT black metal is emotional. Drudkh does it well, as does Burzum to some extent. you realize tat i've only had a last fm for maybe 2 years. i've been listening to music a lot longer than 2 years lol if lastfm kept track since i started listening to music well let's just say you woudn't be criticising it. wow your stupidity right now is incredible. good thing you've got fishtits to make it sound like i'm the one who doesn't know jack shit |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | all the bitches be droppin my name like whoa |
rasputin
10.11.09 | wow your stupidity right now is incredible. good thing you've got fishtits to make it sound like i'm the one who doesn't know jack shit
this is more ironic than al gore |
rasputin
10.11.09 | more ironic than that one time when i fuk niggers |
cvlts
10.11.09 | man, their STILL bitchin and complainin? |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | it's ironic in the sense that your assumptions must be true. If it isn't true, irony is dead. i'm off to toot some line and listen to panoptican. you can go listen to my raping your dad with my giant black dildo i bought used off ebay |
rasputin
10.11.09 | rofl
so where's this list? what's all the black metal you listened to 2 years ago before anyone was even borned? i heard you listened to darkthrone before they even existed? |
foreverendeared
10.11.09 | what the fuck are you talking about. you should work for fox news. they'd love you.
|
iranscam
10.11.09 | panoptican sam |
rasputin
10.11.09 | man i heard you and fenriz go way back what's he like? i heard he's so black metal he doesn't even take milk with his tea |
cvlts
10.11.09 | CONGRATULATIONS!
and the winner is:
ABSOLUTELY NO ONE
You're all F*ckin Idiots!
good job. |
rasputin
10.11.09 | this argument was over when foreverendeared didn't actually listen to black metal |
zuzek
10.11.09 | Death Metal.
I don't know that much about either genre but I mostly listen to it for the instruments. In either genre I have trouble truly appreciating the vocals. Death Metal has it's fair share of silly bands but Black Metal just ends up being more intolerable to me because of the ridiculous screeching and shrieking. That and it doesn't help that a lot of the genre seems to be plagued by cringeworthy lyrical apes. In both genres, whatever I check out usually results in me having a chuckle behind the monitor. It's that clean singing simply does not suit the instrumental ongoings, but the vocals are pretty fucking stupid most of the time. Growling, screeching, whatever it is.
Bring ze flames! |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | nah |
Relinquished
10.11.09 | wow thread fails |
combustion07
10.11.09 | Thor's comment ftw |
Fxxkit13
10.11.09 | WTF so much has gone down since I've been away |
Wizard
10.11.09 | I can't believe the idiocy going on in this thread. I love all of you but you make me cry when you have all to be elitist and shit. This makes me want to quit this site because I DUNT NOSE GUD NIG METAL AND MORBID METALZZZ. |
Fxxkit13
10.11.09 | I agree. I don't understand why they can't agree in the fact that they have varying opinions |
charlesfishowitz
10.11.09 | yeah what's the deal with that
i mean c'mon |
combustion07
10.11.09 | Yeah the elitist shit has gotten a bit ridiculous, I just found thors comment funny |
Fxxkit13
10.11.09 | It was pretty funny |
SlightlyEpic
10.11.09 | I don't listen to either do I win |
Fxxkit13
10.11.09 | Yes |
joplinpicasso
10.11.09 | Holy shit, guys. I asked what the fucking difference was, and I get an, "Are you serious?"
Yes, so what's the difference? |
TricksterGRex
10.11.09 | are you serious |
FadeToBlack
10.11.09 | heys guyz wats the difference between indy an hip-hop help pleasew |
SlightlyEpic
10.11.09 | idk dey sound the same 2 me |
combustion07
10.11.09 | Listen to some things considered black metal (Wolves in the Throne Room, Summoning, Borknagar)
Then listen to death metal (Cryptopsy, Massacre, Bloodbath etc)
Your question should be answered |
combustion07
10.11.09 | @Benzum
Yes, their first 2 albums would be best imo |
OllieS
10.11.09 | Well I don't listen to much straight Death or Black Metal (usually just melodic variants/stuff that crosses genres), but I have to say Death because Black Metal is emotionally just too dark. |
FadeToBlack
10.11.09 | death metal can be like that too though, like Immolation |
OllieS
10.11.09 | "I can't believe the idiocy going on in this thread. I love all of you but you make me cry when you have all to be elitist and shit. This makes me want to quit this site because I DUNT NOSE GUD NIG METAL AND MORBID METALZZZ." - this comment is awesome. |
rasputin
10.12.09 | it wasn't about him not knowing it was about him pretending to know. and he was feeding the trolls so hard it started to become scary. |
Inveigh
10.12.09 | brokencyde is like the best death metal band ever, so death metal wins |
Zip
10.12.09 | death metal more |
Fxxkit13
10.12.09 | really? i thought it wouldve BM for you for sure |
DLNation
10.12.09 | If you pay attention to any of the bands... Black Metal, Death Metal, Doom Metal, and any other ridiculous sub-genre that people try to label it with, are all made up of the same members. Good metal is good metal, and all the shit about eating feces or drinking a chalice of blood in a snowy forrest is just nonsensical. Almost all of these aforementioned bands lack any real talent.
Dark Tranquillity - The Gallery
Dissection - The Somberlain
One "Death Metal" and the other "Black Metal."
I ask you... is there much of a difference? |
Inveigh
10.12.09 | mmm.... Dissection and Dark Tranquillity are both death metal in my book. |
Inveigh
10.12.09 | take that back, I was thinking Dismember. Dissection is definitely black metal. |
DLNation
10.12.09 | I don't know if this translates worldwide/countrywide, but in my experience...
Death Metal = White Trash
Black Metal = FanBoys (Whether it be comics or D&D)
|
KTV
10.12.09 | huge difference |
DLNation
10.12.09 | Add an assload of reverb and bad production and the albums are not too far off. Basic song structure and the use of guitar harmonies. |
Inveigh
10.12.09 | vocals are completely different too. not to mention lyrical themes and tempos. So, between production, lyrics, vocals, tempos and the prevalent use of synths, I guess there's not much of a difference, huh? |
DLNation
10.12.09 | Synths? I don't recall either band carrying a keyboardist, nor are there synths in either one of these albums (minus an intro or outro). Tempos... about the same. Higher pitched vocals... check. (You can understand DT a little bit more? but maybe it's the production value? You're going to base two bands sounding different between lyrical content? That makes no sense. |
Inveigh
10.12.09 | oh shit, I thought we were back to comparing black metal and death metal as genres. no, what i said makes no sense in reference to those particular albums. |
iranscam
10.12.09 | was trying to refrain from commenting in a vain attempt to contribute to this thread's death
but fuck it come on 666 comments |
foreverendeared
10.13.09 | i'm sorry rasputin but you're a fucking idiot. I probably haven't rated/scrobbled 10% of all the music i've listened to. In fact I've probably listened to more black metal than you. I was big into thrash around the same time i got into black metal. That was at least 13 fucking years ago. I think you'll notice i've hardly any thrash rated/listened to either because i've only been keeping track for 2 goddamn years. jesus fucking christ get a brain. |
charlesfishowitz
10.13.09 | please dont egg him on dude |
Jesuslaves
10.13.09 | Never saw the appeal with black metal. DM is alright. |
foreverendeared
10.13.09 | but it's entertaining. gotta do somethin while i'm stoned |
deathmetal101
10.25.09 | ........... |
Emim
10.26.09 | lulz at the super "elite" idiots here. Get a freaking life.
DM btw. |
ninjacat11
10.26.09 | Death metal. I don't know why, but I can't really get into Black Metal.
They're both metal at it's most ridiculous. |
deathmetal101
10.26.09 | gotta be honest....ive been getting into alot of black metal lately and it is pretty cool, but i choose death metal FTW |
ultradevilgod
06.07.12 | Definitely DM, I listen to BM but most of those bands are "elitists" and close-minded. |
Hyperion1001
06.07.12 | how the fuck do you people bump these lists? |
JosephLong
06.07.12 | both suck |
Hyperion1001
06.07.12 | agreed metal is terrible |
Wolfhorde
06.07.12 | "how the fuck do you people bump these lists?"
lack of reading comprehension. |
IdiotequeCigar
06.07.12 | Blackened death |