EVedder27
10.30.09 | This probably doesn't cover everything that's affected me this way, but its a good overview. May do lists with other emotions next. |
Titan50
10.30.09 | I never saw 9 like that :/ |
EVedder27
10.30.09 | its sooo dark. Especially the last 5 or 6 tracks. I mean just look at the songtitles. |
Inveigh
10.30.09 | 9 is an incredibly dark album. 1 and 2 I'm with you on completely.
I might want to add A Perfect Circle's The Thirteenth Step onto this list; along with Dysfunction by Staind (which is actually a very good album). I just remember being 15 and getting all depressed while listening to that Staind disc. Weird. |
theacademy
10.30.09 | agree with everything except 4 (and 8 but ill put that aside)
4 is really great but 2 or 3 songs does not an 'emotionally draining album' make
a lot of this is undercut by how much radio play these tracks got...its hard not to associate the album with too many external factors...still love the CD tho.. |
Lions
10.30.09 | definitely I agree with 2 and 8. Here some of my others
Dredg's el cielo
Silver Mt. Zion - He Has Left Us Alone But Shafts Of Light Still Grace The Corners of Our Rooms
GY!BE - F# A# Infinity
mwY - Catch For Us The Foxes
Sigur Ros - ( )
Cursive - Domestica
Elliot Smith - s/t
there's tons. |
EVedder27
10.30.09 | ^yeah I know what you mean. I was pretty skeptical about putting 4 on here, I guess it doesn't belong here. I mean it definitely is a dark album, but doesn't compare to some of the others on here. |
OllieS
10.30.09 | Daylight Dies - Dismantling Devotion - takes your emotions, makes them depressed then gives them back. |
EVedder27
10.30.09 | that was supposed to be at theacademy. And I definitely need to get el cielo and ( ). On my recs list for a while now. |
Hostile101
10.30.09 | if u want a depressing album and a real emotional drainer get this
SWANS - White Light From The Mouth Of Infinty
|
theacademy
10.30.09 | yea wow that was unexpectedly hard to explain...made so much sense in my head tho |
EVedder27
10.30.09 | I understood you for the most part |
Titan50
10.30.09 | Dodnward Spiral - Nine Inch Nails
As the Roots Undo - CTTS |
fattytoeben
10.30.09 | Great list. Need to listen to The Wall. |
illmitch
10.30.09 | swans - public castration is a good idea
joy division - closer
bright eyes - amy in the white coat (song, not album) |
EVedder27
10.30.09 | Yes and get the movie. Its so fucked up and confusing and awesome at the same time. |
Schizophrenik
10.30.09 | Weezer - Pinkerton
Against Me! - Reinventing Axl Rose |
EVedder27
10.31.09 | Pinkerton drains your emotions? I mean its awesome and all, but I've always seen it as a feel good album. |
Captain North
10.31.09 | 7, 8 and 2 are the most so on this list. Don't entirely agree with 4 or 6. |
EVedder27
10.31.09 | don't really disagree with 4. I decided earlier it doesn't really belong here although some tracks do. |
Captain North
10.31.09 | Anyway, mine would be:
Lost in the Sound of Separation ~ Underoath
Controller ~ Misery Signals
Imago ~ The Butterfly Effect
The Fountain Soundtrack
Soundtrack to a Vacant Life ~ The Flashbulb
In Rainbows ~ Radiohead (more so than Kid A for me)
|
IdLewyld
10.31.09 | Dear EVedder27.
Your a pussy |
IdLewyld
10.31.09 | took one look at list and lol'd |
Captain North
10.31.09 | Not acknowledging your feelings doesn't make you a man. It makes you stupid. |
IdLewyld
10.31.09 | yeah, ask any wuss you want |
Schizophrenik
10.31.09 | @ EVedder27
Don't listen to him, Captain North is right. And Pinkerton is actually a pretty dark and honest look into river's emotional state at the time |
Titan50
10.31.09 | IdLewyld, I hope you suffer an emotional breakdown :) |
romgsom
10.31.09 | Great list, agreed with pretty much all except I see 3 as more of a relaxing album. Check out Mad Season- Above if you haven't already, I think you'd like it. |
musicaddiction101
10.31.09 | As Cities Burn- Come Now Sleep
The Antlers- Hospice (GET THIS NOW!)
|
maqwep
10.31.09 | 10 is soooooooooo overrated |
Titan50
10.31.09 | No it's not |
maqwep
10.31.09 | and so is 5 |
BrandNewBoognish
10.31.09 | I agree with the guy that recommended Swans. And yeah, 5 and 10 are very overrated |
EVedder27
10.31.09 | no way are 5 and 10 overrated. Although 5 is probably my 4th or 5th favorite Pink Floyd album. And IdLewyld, you have no soul. |
MilesR
10.31.09 | as I'm writing this I'm on Tylenol 3 and listening to Sigur Ros ( ) and it is without a doubt the most draining thing ever (esp. track#3). dredg el cielo would be a very close 2nd. Kid A isn't so draining the first listen but the 10th time through during that break in motion picture soundtrack.
Also while not technically the greatest music matthew good's live at Massey hall is about the most depressing album ever.
Great list |
maqwep
10.31.09 | no dude 5 and 10 are wayy overrated. The Wall is maybe a 3 outta 5 and Quadrophenia is about the same. maybe a bit more |
Chewie
10.31.09 | The Downward Spiral and F# A# Infinity for me |
thrice1987
11.01.09 | 2 is so so very good, but yeah, very emotionally draining. one of the most depressing albums i've ever heard. It's really an emotional punch in the gut. Especially Millstone |
EVedder27
11.01.09 | Yeah, I think the most depressing is probably Handcuffs. Lyrics are like woah. |
EasternLight
11.01.09 | ^12 the fucking 3 |
Dougie
11.01.09 | Frank Ticheli - Sanctuary EP
Get on it straight away! One 12 minute ride of emotion! |
Lions
11.01.09 | ^sounds interesting. Describe? |
Alligator
11.01.09 | I have 10 on Vinyl, depresing?
List needs In Utero - Nirvana, I feel like jumping off a bridge after listening to that. |
Dougie
11.01.09 | Check out the review... |
EVedder27
11.01.09 | 10 gives me chills at the end |
Captain North
11.02.09 | Oh sweet, finally someone agrees with me about Handcuffs. |
Stumble
Digg
Del.icio.us